Monday
November 19, 1866
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.) — Illinois, Cook
“A Minister's Fall & Mexico's Emperor: The Scandals Shaking America, November 1866”
Art Deco mural for November 19, 1866
Original newspaper scan from November 19, 1866
Original front page — Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Chicago Tribune's November 19, 1866 front page captures America in a turbulent moment of Reconstruction. A scandalous ecclesiastical trial dominates: Rev. James Prestley, D.D., pastor of Pittsburgh's Second United Presbyterian Church, has been convicted of brutal cruelty toward his wife and children, vulgar profanity, and infidelity. The charges included choking his wife in Hookstown, kicking her, and maintaining an improper correspondence with a widow in New York—intercepted letters addressed to 'James Peterson' containing intimate expressions. The Presbytery found him unanimously guilty and expelled him from the ministry. Meanwhile, dispatches from Mexico report that Emperor Maximilian remains a prisoner after being intercepted during his 'march to the sea,' with French General Bazaine demanding his abdication. Domestically, produce markets show steep declines: Spring Extra Flour down $1 per barrel, corn down 8 cents, and Mess Pork down $2 per barrel. A census of Mississippi reveals profound demographic upheaval—white population decreased 2.5% while Black population dropped 13%, likely reflecting migration patterns in the post-war South.

Why It Matters

This November 1866 edition reflects a nation grappling with two seismic shifts. Reconstruction is unfolding in the South with Congressional Amendment ratification debates consuming Washington—the Tribune notes President Johnson's recent conferences with Chief Justice Chase. The Democratic institutions and moral authority of the North are being tested through highly publicized scandals like Prestley's fall from grace, which would have reverberated through Protestant denominations. Simultaneously, Mexico's fate—with a European-backed emperor crumbling—reveals America's anxieties about foreign intervention in the hemisphere during a vulnerable post-Civil War moment. The Mississippi population data hints at the massive internal migration reshaping America as freedmen sought northern opportunity and white Southerners fled Reconstruction.

Hidden Gems
  • Louis Napoleon purchased the racehorse 'Rustic' from the Duke of Beaufort for $10,000—a staggering sum suggesting the imperial French court remained confident and lavish just five years before the Franco-Prussian War would topple the Second Empire.
  • A 20-inch naval gun was successfully cast at Fort Pitt Works using 110,000 pounds of Bloomfield or Juniata pig iron—evidence of America's rapid militarization of ironclad naval technology that would dominate global navies for decades.
  • The carpenters of New York adopted resolutions on November 14 demanding the 'eight-hour system of labor'—this is an extraordinarily early appearance of what would become labor's defining demand, a full decade before the 1876 uprisings.
  • Revenue officers seized $1,700,000 worth of smuggled sherry, wines, silks, and ribbons imported into New York—indicating a massive fraud operation that underscores just how valuable international trade had become and how sophisticated smuggling networks were.
  • Rev. Cyrus Dickson reported that of 937,000 colored persons in the North, fewer than 1,500 belonged to the Presbyterian Church, while in the South only 14,000 of 4,330,000 were Presbyterian—a stark indictment of Protestant denominations' failure to minister to freedmen, creating missionary opportunity the Catholic Church was explicitly targeting.
Fun Facts
  • The article mentions that British regulars in Canada now number 13,000—the largest garrison since 1814. Just two years later, Confederation (1867) would transform British North America into the Dominion of Canada, and these troops would gradually withdraw as the young nation took on its own defense.
  • Actress Rachel (likely the famous French tragedienne Rachel) netted $100,000 in receipts across 26 performances in New York/Brooklyn and Boston in just seven weeks—performing in a foreign language. She was one of the highest-paid entertainers of the era and would help establish that stars could command extraordinary compensation.
  • The newspaper notes that Mississippi's Black population had declined 13% in six years (1860-1866), from roughly 437,000 to an estimated 380,000. This reflects the massive mortality and displacement of the Civil War, but also the beginning of the Great Migration that would accelerate dramatically in the 20th century.
  • The Danish government's royal commission approved the 'Peabody gun,' an American breech-loader, signaling that U.S. military technology was competing successfully on the international market—America was becoming an exporter of arms and expertise, not just agricultural goods.
  • Rev. Henry Ward Beecher withdrew publication rights of his sermons from the Independent due to political antagonism with editor Henry Tilton—this same Beecher-Tilton conflict would explode spectacularly in 1874 with adultery allegations that consumed American newspapers and nearly destroyed both men, making this 1866 note a tremor before the earthquake.
Anxious Reconstruction Crime Trial Politics International Economy Markets Religion Military
November 17, 1866 November 20, 1866

Also on November 19

1836
26 Hours From Baltimore to the Carolinas: How America Became Obsessed with...
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1846
Desperate Tailors, Defiant Mexico, and a Mysterious $5M Loan Gone Wrong—Nov....
American Republican and Baltimore daily clipper (Baltimore, Md.)
1856
82 Miles of Empire: How the South Raced to Build Its Future (Four Years Before...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1861
When America Was at War but Evansville Kept Selling Stoves: November 1861
The Evansville daily journal (Evansville, Ia. [i.e. Ind.])
1862
When the South Almost Took California: A Civil War Plot That Almost Changed...
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1863
November 1863: A Small-Town Iowa Editor Demands Total War—And Won't Back Down
Charles City Republican intelligencer (Charles City, Iowa)
1865
1865: Iowa's Thanksgiving, Missing $176M in Whiskey Taxes, and Why...
The daily Gate City (Keokuk, Iowa)
1876
Election Day 1876: When Sherman & Hayes Watched the South Count—and Democracy...
New Orleans Republican (New Orleans, La)
1886
Ex-President Arthur Dead at 56: A Stroke in the Night Changes America's Course
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1896
"100 Fake Voters & a Wheat Boom: South Dakota's 1896 Election Chaos Explained"
Turner County herald (Hurley, Dakota [S.D.])
1906
41 Dead in Puget Sound Disaster + Kansas Buried Under Season's First Blizzard
The Topeka state journal (Topeka, Kansas)
1926
1926: When a Ford cost $150 and your local paper published full novels
Montgomery County sentinel (Rockville, Md.)
1927
How a 17-Year-Old Became Sultan Before His Father's Tomb Closed—and Why...
Evening star (Washington, D.C.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free