“When America Sent 10,000 Troops to Mexico (and Nearly Started a War with Canada) — Oct. 31, 1866”
What's on the Front Page
The Evansville Journal's front page on October 31, 1866, leads with major international news: the U.S. government is preparing to send 10,000 troops under General Grant to Mexico to support President Benito Juárez's government as French forces withdraw. Secretary of State William Seward has authorized this protective arrangement, with custom revenues from Mexican ports pledged to cover expenses and foreign debts owed to England and France. Simultaneously, the paper devotes substantial coverage to Fenian Brotherhood troubles in Canada. Irish-American raiders have been arrested and tried, with execution sentences drawing fierce resistance from Catholic communities in Lower Canada. Attorney General Weed faces assassination threats if he permits executions. The page also reports railroad incidents in New York, yellow fever cases aboard the U.S. steamer Rieuville, and General Sheridan's departure for Texas regarding Mexican affairs. Local Evansville includes cholera reports and a Fenian meeting.
Why It Matters
This October 1866 edition captures America in a critical post-Civil War moment. The nation is asserting itself as a regional power in the Americas, standing against European imperial ambitions in Mexico—a preview of the Monroe Doctrine's enforcement for decades to come. Simultaneously, the Fenian crisis exposes deep tensions between Irish-Americans seeking to liberate Ireland through raids on British Canada, and U.S. government reluctance to provoke Britain. These dual crises reveal how America's internal divisions (North-South reconciliation still incomplete) complicate its foreign policy. The cholera and yellow fever reports underscore the public health challenges of the era, while the general tone reflects a nation simultaneously ambitious, uncertain, and still finding its footing in the postwar world.
Hidden Gems
- General Ortega, a Mexican political rival to Juárez, was apparently boarding in Evansville—the paper notes he 'left this evening per steamship St. Mary for Brasos Santiago,' refusing to consider himself bound by General Sheridan's opinions on Mexican constitutional authority. A deposed general essentially using American port cities as waypoints.
- An ocean yacht race was being organized for December with a prize purse of $100,000 (roughly $1.8 million today), featuring three yachts racing from Sandy Hook to the Isle of Wight. This suggests thriving wealth and leisure culture emerging just 18 months after Appomattox.
- Dr. Lighthill's medical advertisement includes a lengthy testimonial from a Cincinnati printer claiming cure from consumption (tuberculosis) after six weeks of treatment, having 'gained twenty-one pounds in the period mentioned.' The desperation and hope embedded in such claims reflect the terror tuberculosis inspired.
- The dental practice of Drs. Haas & Cooke advertised 'americanhides for alleviating pain when extracting teeth in its first instance,' suggesting anesthesia was still a luxury service, not standard.
- Cholera cases were being reported in Evansville itself, 'most thereof occurring to people recently from Cincinnati'—disease traveled with migration and commerce in ways residents understood viscerally.
Fun Facts
- The paper mentions Napoleon preparing to withdraw the entire French army from Mexico 'next month,' with the full withdrawal expected by January 1st. This marked the effective end of France's Mexican adventure and Emperor Maximilian's doomed reign—he'd be executed just months later in June 1867, making this troop withdrawal announcement a quiet herald of imperial collapse.
- General Sheridan, mentioned as possibly leading the U.S. military mission to Mexico, would within a decade become commanding general of the entire U.S. Army and a towering Civil War legend. At this moment he's being considered for international police work.
- The Fenian Brotherhood mentioned throughout was an Irish-American paramilitary organization that had already launched invasion attempts on Canada in 1866 and would try again in 1870-71. These newspaper reports capture them at peak influence and desperation, before U.S. authorities finally cracked down seriously.
- William Seward, whose letter on Mexican affairs is referenced, was the same secretary of state who would negotiate the Alaska Purchase just eight months after this newspaper was printed—a stunning geopolitical pivot few readers anticipated.
- The paper reports 18 cases of yellow fever aboard the Rieuville and mentions it lost 'three officers and eleven men' to disease between St. Thomas and Port au Prince. Yellow fever deaths were so routine in tropical ports they warranted only brief mention, yet this was a disease that would terrify American cities for decades to come.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free