“When Kansas Mocked a President: A Small-Town Paper's Savage Take on Andrew Johnson's Failed 1866 Tour”
What's on the Front Page
The White Cloud Kansas Chief leads with patriotic verse celebrating the Union and national harmony just one year after the Civil War ended. The front page features Sol Miller's editorial framing—"The Constitution and the Union"—alongside poetry about the harp of the minstrel and the spheres of astronomy, all serving as metaphors for the necessity of holding states together. Below the lofty rhetoric sits a serialized story titled "Why He Didn't Propose," a humorous cautionary tale about a gentleman who abandons his marriage prospects after witnessing his romantic interest spend $135 in a single morning's shopping spree ($2,400 in today's money) on items she admitted not needing. The story ends with him concluding that such extravagance would bankrupt him faster than Frank Palmer's recent $20,000 failure. The page also features a satirical "Digest of the President's Stout Speeches," mocking Andrew Johnson's defensive rhetoric about charges of being a demagogue, traitor, and usurper, interspersed with his boasts about running the government and being the negro's only friend.
Why It Matters
This September 1866 edition captures a nation in fractious transition. The Civil War ended just sixteen months prior, and Andrew Johnson's lenient Reconstruction policies were already provoking fierce congressional opposition. Johnson's defensive speeches—mocked here—reflect the real constitutional crisis unfolding: radical Republicans wanted harsh Reconstruction; Johnson wanted quick restoration of Southern states. The humor about Johnson's endless self-justification and his bragging about appointing loyalists reveals how polarized the country had become. Meanwhile, the earnest patriotic poetry suggests Kansas editors like Miller were trying to rally citizens around national unity during a period when that unity was fragmenting. The shopping story, though seemingly trivial, reflects genuine anxieties about women's consumer power and economic instability in the immediate postwar economy.
Hidden Gems
- The satire describes the President as having 'been in office ever since I can remember' and lists his positions as 'Alderman, Constable, Supervisor, Tax-gatherer, Congressman, and by the help of Booth, President'—a darkly ironic reference to John Wilkes Booth's assassination of Lincoln, whom Johnson succeeded.
- The shawl Caroline purchases is described as 'imported from France' and costs 'thirty-five dollars'—an astronomical sum for 1866, equivalent to roughly $630 today, yet she buys it on her father's credit without his consent, suggesting significant gender-based economic tensions.
- The satirical piece notes that Southern delegates to the Philadelphia Convention gifted bone pins 'made of the bones of Federal soldiers' with some 'particularly valuable in weeks, having been made from the bones at the first soldiers who fell at Ball Run'—describing jewelry crafted from Union soldiers' remains as diplomatic gifts.
- A column titled 'Moses' earnestly compares ideal leadership qualities (not being fluent but being a fine writer, being sober and truthful) to—then implicitly contrasts with—contemporary political figures, suggesting readers would immediately catch the reference to current failed leadership.
- The Reverend Petroleum V. Nasby's account describes clerks in Federal Departments being 'assessed' (forced to contribute) for a 'clean shirt' to improve the Presidential party's appearance, with refusers 'intimately dismissed for their disloyalty'—revealing patronage corruption and coercive loyalty demands.
Fun Facts
- Sol Miller, editor of this Kansas paper, would later become a significant figure in Kansas Republican politics and journalism, representing the state's radical Republican faction that opposed Johnson's Reconstruction policies—making this page's mockery of Johnson part of a broader editorial campaign that would shape Kansas politics for decades.
- The Petroleum V. Nasby column, a recurring feature, was actually written by David Ross Locke, one of America's most influential political satirists of the era. His mockery of Johnson's tour was syndicated nationally, making this small Kansas paper part of a coordinated satirical assault on the President's credibility.
- Andrew Johnson's actual 'Swing Around the Circle' tour in August-September 1866 (which this page covers) was considered a political disaster—his speeches were widely mocked, and Republicans used the tour's failure to justify their overwhelming victory in the fall 1866 midterm elections, which gave them veto-proof majorities to pass Reconstruction Acts.
- The reference to Frank Palmer's '$20,000 failure' reflects the financial instability of the immediate postwar period. The American economy was experiencing severe deflation and credit crises as the government demobilized from wartime production, leading to widespread business failures among those who couldn't adapt to peacetime economics.
- White Cloud, Kansas, where this paper was published, was founded in 1856 and became a Free Soil stronghold during the 'Bleeding Kansas' conflicts. By 1866, it represented the abolitionist, radical Republican core of the state—explaining why this editor was so hostile to Johnson's lenient policies toward the defeated South.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free