“Democracy in Collapse: The Day Andrew Johnson's Presidency Died in Front of Crowds (Sept. 11, 1866)”
What's on the Front Page
The Chicago Tribune's September 11, 1866 front page screams with Republican triumph: Maine has just delivered an overwhelming Union victory with a 25,000-vote majority, sweeping every congressional district and nearly the entire state legislature—a staggering gain of 8,000 votes over the 1864 presidential election. But the real drama dominates the lower half: President Andrew Johnson's electioneering tour has become a catastrophe. At Indianapolis the previous evening, Johnson attempted to address assembled thousands but was utterly drowned out by crowds cheering for General Grant and groaning mockingly for "the Bread-and-Butter brigade." The president made several futile attempts to speak over the roar, which continued for more than two hours punctuated by patriotic songs like "Glory Hallelujah" and "Battle Cry of Freedom." Finally humiliated, Johnson gave up and retired. A melee erupted during the evening chaos—one citizen killed, several wounded. A fascinating dispatch from Chicago quotes General Grant's alleged private disgust: "I am disgusted with this trip. I am disgusted at hearing a man make speeches on the way to his own funeral." Meanwhile, Southern Loyalists are being feted in New York City with grand receptions at Cooper Institute and Beecher's Church, a stark contrast to the president's humiliation.
Why It Matters
This page captures the precise moment when Andrew Johnson's presidency was collapsing in real time. Just sixteen months after Lincoln's assassination, Johnson—a Tennessee Democrat thrust into office—had become a pariah to the Republican Party that nominally controlled Congress. His lenient Reconstruction policies clashed violently with Northern demands for harsher terms toward the South. The Maine election signaled the coming Republican landslide in the 1866 midterms, which would give Republicans overwhelming majorities and effectively sideline Johnson. The contrast between Johnson's public humiliation and the celebration of Southern Loyalists underscores the fundamental battle: who would control Reconstruction? Johnson's tour, meant to rally support, instead exposed how thoroughly he'd lost the North's confidence.
Hidden Gems
- A Russian prince, Nicholas Ourousow, is described as 'one of the lions of New York City'—a reminder that even amid Civil War aftermath, wealthy foreign aristocrats were celebrity attractions in American society.
- The Texas Comptroller reported that the loss of tax revenue from abolishing slavery totaled $645,501.17, calculated on slave valuations from 1860 at a tax rate of 194 cents per hundred dollars—a chilling quantification of the South's economic devastation.
- A judge in Warsaw, New York angrily compared selling liquor without a license to 'the crime of high treason, in which everybody goes free and nobody is punished'—a pointed jab at the apparent immunity being given to Southern Confederate leaders.
- The discovery of a new asteroid in the constellation Capricorn by the Marseilles Observatory on August 6th brings the total known asteroids to eighty-eight—scientific discovery proceeded apace even as the nation convulsed politically.
- Brown University had just received $100,000 donations from five Rhode Island gentlemen including William Sprague, each giving $20,000, with a matching challenge of another $100,000 to reach $250,000 total—one of the era's largest education endowments, reflecting the wealth concentration among Northern industrialists.
Fun Facts
- The page mentions General Oliver O. Howard, head of the Freedmen's Bureau, being invited to lead Lincoln College in Kansas. Howard would go on to found Howard University in Washington D.C. in 1867, which became one of the nation's premier Historically Black Universities—all while rumors of his resignation were swirling in September 1866.
- J.G. Blaine, the Union State Committee chairman declaring Maine's victory, was a rising Republican star in 1866. He would serve as Speaker of the House, Senator, Secretary of State, and run for president multiple times—this Maine victory was a crucial moment in his political ascendancy.
- The article notes that the Douglas family (relatives of Stephen Douglas) were traveling with Johnson's party but 'were not included with the President's party until their arrival in Chicago' and had to pay their own expenses. Stephen Douglas died in 1861, yet his family was still prominent enough to merit mention—his legacy still haunted the political landscape.
- Andrew Johnson's tour was explicitly designed to build support before the 1866 midterms, but the Indianapolis disaster and the Maine results made clear this strategy had catastrophically backfired. Within months, Republicans would control Congress with veto-proof majorities.
- The article mentions that Cincinnati's City Council voted 16-0 to refuse giving Johnson a reception, with Republicans deliberately absenting themselves to prevent a quorum. This wasn't passive disagreement—it was institutional sabotage of a sitting president by his own party.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free