“1866: A California Paper's Savage Attack on Tennessee's Radical Governor—and Why It Matters”
What's on the Front Page
The Placer Herald's July 7, 1866 front page is dominated by a scathing editorial assault on Tennessee Governor William G. Brownlow, reprinted from the Louisville Journal. The piece, titled "Prentice on Brownlow," launches a withering personal attack on the controversial Republican governor, accusing him of hypocrisy, treason, and moral depravity. The editor compares Brownlow unfavorably to a 'black shrike' and 'hungry cat,' claiming he professes Christianity while promoting 'strifes, and fights and bloodshed.' The editorial alleges that Brownlow initially sympathized with slavery in 1850, then feigned Unionism during the war when politically expedient. It also defends a business associate, Mr. Henderson, against charges of wartime mule-contracting fraud. Beyond this political bombast, the page carries practical advertisements for local Auburn professionals—attorneys, a dentist, a boot maker, an undertaker, and the United States House tavern—alongside miscellaneous items including a cautionary tale about nitroglycerin smuggling in England and a humorous account of a pickpocket returning a newspaper editor's empty wallet.
Why It Matters
In July 1866, just fourteen months after Lee's surrender at Appomattox, the nation was convulsing through Reconstruction. Tennessee, under Radical Republican governor Brownlow, represented the North's aggressive Reconstruction policy—and Southern papers like the Placer Herald, even in distant California, were deeply invested in attacking it. This editorial reflects the bitter partisan warfare consuming the country as Republicans pushed for Black suffrage and Southern disenfranchisement while Democrats and their sympathizers fought back with character assassination and claims of Federal overreach. The Placer Herald's decision to reprint this Louisville Journal screed shows how Reconstruction debates reached even Gold Country California, where political allegiances still ran along Civil War lines.
Hidden Gems
- Subscription costs reveal the Gold Rush economy: $6 for a year's subscription, $3 for six months—payable in 'Gold and Silver—invariably in Advance.' California's precious metal wealth was literally the currency of local journalism.
- The classified ads reveal Auburn's professional landscape in 1866: Among the lawyers and doctors is James Walsh, a boot and shoe maker who also repairs harnesses and works 'on Main St.' in the 'Middle Row'—suggesting Auburn's downtown was organized into distinct commercial blocks just two decades after the Gold Rush peak.
- Thomas Jamison advertised as 'County Coroner, and General Undertaker' with a specialty service: 'Especial attention given to disinterring and removing bodies.' This suggests a brisk trade in relocating graves—likely families moving remains from provisional Gold Rush burial grounds to permanent cemeteries.
- An embedded anecdote tells of a pickpocket's code of honor: after stealing a newspaper editor's wallet, the thief returned it with a note saying 'I never robs any only gentlemen'—finding the editor insufficiently wealthy to rob. It's a sardonic commentary on 1860s class consciousness.
- The page warns of nitroglycerine (labeled 'glonin oil') being smuggled through English ports disguised as 'Manchester goods.' Seventy cases shipped from London could have 'shaken the metropolis to its center'—revealing how explosives trafficking and industrial espionage were already international problems by 1866.
Fun Facts
- William G. Brownlow, the target of this vicious attack, would remain Tennessee governor until 1869 and later serve in the U.S. Senate. Despite this editor's ferocious character assassination, Brownlow became a defining figure of Radical Reconstruction and lived until 1877—long enough to see his policies largely undone.
- The reference to Judge C. F. Trigg, described as 'United States Judge of Tennessee,' connects to the Federal court system being actively reconstructed in the South. Judges like Trigg were crucial architects of Radical Reconstruction policy, making them natural targets for Democratic editorial fury.
- The nitroglycerin smuggling story, while seeming like a foreign curiosity, foreshadows a problem that would plague California itself: explosives trafficking. Within a decade, dynamite would become crucial to mining and railroad construction in the Sierra Nevada—but also a tool of industrial sabotage.
- Auburn in 1866 was still booming from the Gold Rush (peak was 1852-1853, but production continued), yet its professional class—five lawyers, two doctors, an undertaker—suggests it was transitioning from mining camp to permanent town. This page captures that moment.
- The editorial's savage tone reflects how bitter Reconstruction had become by mid-1866. Congress had just passed the Civil Rights Act over Johnson's veto (April 1866), and the 14th Amendment was pending ratification—this paper was fighting a losing battle against Republican dominance, which explains the apocalyptic rhetoric.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free