“He Called Thaddeus Stevens the Devil's Agent: Inside the Speech That Split America (1866)”
What's on the Front Page
The Bedford Gazette's March 23, 1866 front page is dominated by a fiery speech from Congressman Samuel S. Cox supporting President Andrew Johnson's veto of the Freedmen's Bureau Bill. Cox, addressing a massive crowd at Grover's Theatre in Washington, delivered a passionate defense of Johnson's constitutional position, attacking the "Radical" Republican Congress for what Cox saw as an unconstitutional power grab. The speech is laced with biblical imagery—Cox compares the Democratic Party's revival to the resurrection of saints, and warns that "If this be done in the green tree, what will be done in the dry?" He unleashes nine numbered objections to the Freedmen's Bureau, calling it "bureaucracy against democracy," a "war measure," and "ruinously expensive" that creates "government dependents for charity." Behind the political theater lies the real battle shaping Reconstruction: whether the Executive or Congress would control the terms of readmitting Southern states and managing the legal status of formerly enslaved people.
Why It Matters
March 1866 was the precise moment when Reconstruction fractured irreparably. Johnson's veto of the Freedmen's Bureau Bill—legislation designed to provide education, medical care, and land assistance to freedmen—signaled his determination to block Republican attempts at sweeping federal intervention in Southern affairs. Cox's speech represents the Democratic counterattack, positioning Johnson as a constitutional guardian against radical overreach. What few realized that day was that this veto would trigger a cascade: Congress would override the next veto, push through the Civil Rights Act, launch the 14th Amendment, and essentially declare war on Johnson's lenient Reconstruction policies. The speech captures a pivotal moment before the conflict spiraled into impeachment and the complete Republican domination of Reconstruction. Cox's invocation of "one million eight hundred thousand Democrats" rallying behind Johnson proved wildly optimistic—the party was actually fracturing, and moderate Republicans were abandoning the President.
Hidden Gems
- The entire front page is devoted to this single speech with no competing headlines whatsoever—suggesting the Bedford editors viewed this moment as extraordinarily consequential to their Pennsylvania readers, many of whom had family ties to the Radical Republican stronghold of the state.
- Cox specifically names Thaddeus Stevens as holding "a commission from the Devil, with a supply of salt petre and matches to make a little hell on earth"—a vicious personal attack that reveals the visceral hatred between Reconstruction factions, and Stevens, a Lancaster, Pennsylvania native, would have been well-known to this local audience.
- The reverse side carries extensive local lawyer and doctor advertisements, almost all mentioning specialized attention to 'Military claims, back pay, bounty'—evidence that 11 months after Appomattox, Bedford was still processing the financial chaos of demobilization, with attorneys profiting from soldiers' claims.
- Daniel Border's jewelry shop on Pitt Street advertised 'Spectacles of Brilliant Double Reflected Glasse[s], also Scotch Pebble Glares'—showing that even in rural Pennsylvania, imported optical technology was available to those who could afford it.
- The masthead shows the Gazette is published by 'MEYERS & MENGEL' and advertises that the office 'has just been refitted with a Power Press and new type'—indicating that even in small-town Pennsylvania, the post-war economy enabled modernization of printing technology.
Fun Facts
- Cox's speech references the veto power as established by the Constitution and invokes Andrew Jackson as precedent—but Cox was writing at exactly the moment when Johnson's veto would be overridden repeatedly, fundamentally weakening the executive branch's Reconstruction authority for decades to come.
- The speech mentions 'Mr. Thaddeus Stevens' from Pennsylvania—Stevens, who died just 18 months later in August 1868, would become the architect of the 14th Amendment and the driving force behind Johnson's impeachment, making him the second-most powerful figure in American politics during these exact months.
- Cox declares the country is 'in the path to peace and Union' and that 'the very sky is bluer, the air more blithe'—yet within weeks, race riots would erupt in Memphis and New Orleans, and by summer 1866, the midterm elections would hand Republicans a supermajority that would completely override Johnson's vision.
- The Freedmen's Bureau that Cox attacks so viciously would, despite Johnson's veto, become one of the most important federal agencies of the era, establishing schools that would educate over 250,000 freedmen by 1870—the foundation of Black education in the South.
- Cox appeals to 'one million eight hundred thousand Democrats' as 'the great reserve corps in this struggle'—but the 1866 midterms just months away would prove Democrats had far less power than Cox believed, as Republicans won 3-to-1 congressional margins.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free