Monday
March 19, 1866
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.) — Cook, Chicago
“When Irish-American Veterans Threatened to Invade Canada: The Fenian Crisis of 1866”
Art Deco mural for March 19, 1866
Original newspaper scan from March 19, 1866
Original front page — Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Chicago Tribune's front page on March 19, 1866, is consumed by the specter of a Fenian invasion. The Irish nationalist organization, fresh off Civil War military experience, is threatening to raid Canada from American soil—a crisis serious enough that the British have reportedly ordered 10,000 regulars to Halifax and are mobilizing their West Indian squadron. The paper breathlessly reports that Canadian detectives were beaten with "mops, dubwater and brooms" by Irish residents of Milwaukee's Third Ward, while Six Nations Iroquois (descendants of Chief Brant) have offered 3,600 warriors to fight the invaders. St. Patrick's Day celebrations, normally boisterous, were notably muted by the tension. Beyond the Fenian panic, major fires dominate: Minneapolis lost 30 buildings ($100,000 loss), and Buffalo's New York Central freight depot was destroyed along with 400,000 bushels of grain ($3,000,000 damage). Meanwhile, Missouri's Quartermaster General reports the state spent $1.8 million on Civil War supplies alone—a staggering figure capturing the war's lingering financial shadow just over a year after Appomattox.

Why It Matters

This page captures America in a precarious moment of Reconstruction. The Civil War has ended, but its veterans are restless, and the Fenian Brotherhood—armed Irish-Americans fighting for Irish independence through raids on British Canadian territory—represents a genuine geopolitical threat that will simmer until the 1870s. The ease with which newspapers report militia mobilizations and invasion fears shows how fractured and vulnerable the nation still was. Meanwhile, Southern Illinois is attempting to cultivate cotton (detailed extensively on the back page), a failed agricultural experiment representing the post-war South's desperate economic struggles. The reports from Louisiana about rebel officers seeking political power reveal the bitter power struggles over Reconstruction policy consuming Washington—Andrew Johnson's lenient approach versus Congressional demands for loyalty oaths.

Hidden Gems
  • A young blacksmith from Aurora, jailed for burning a barn, committed suicide in Geneva jail by removing his bedstead's sheets, inserting his head between the crossbars, and rolling over to produce 'strangulation or dislocation of the neck'—a grimly ingenious method that the paper notes he'd attempted once before with his suspenders. He was deemed 'temporarily deranged.'
  • In St. Louis, Mrs. Kerrigan was struck and killed by a railroad car, and her husband sued for damages—until the trial revealed she had two living husbands, making the plaintiff legally a non-person with no standing to claim her death. The defendant railroad walked free.
  • San Francisco is being threatened by speculators and legislators plotting to reclaim 5,000-6,000 acres of bay, filling in the water to create new waterfront—a scheme that would render current valuable waterfront properties 'far inland,' destroying millions in real estate value. It nearly passed the California legislature disguised as an innocent bill.
  • A U.S. Army lieutenant at the Rio Grande has been operating a thriving black market, selling cavalry equipment, ammunition, and supplies by the boatload to Mexican Imperialists—40,000 rounds of ammunition crossed the river in a single night (though only 15,000 succeeded). He escaped by cutting through his tent and swimming the Rio Grande above Brownsville.
  • Southern Illinois cotton production in 1865 totaled 7,298 bales valued at $1.37 million—an enormous agricultural pivot barely a year after the Civil War, with Jefferson County alone producing 240 bales. The paper notes it takes 2.5 to 3.5 pounds of cotton seed to make one pound of lint.
Fun Facts
  • The Fenian Brotherhood raids mentioned here represent the era's strangest military campaign: Irish-American Civil War veterans literally invaded Canada multiple times (1866-1870) seeking to hold it hostage for Irish independence. The Tribune's breathless reporting captures the moment before the first major raids—within months, battles would be fought on Canadian soil with hundreds of casualties. The movement ultimately failed but terrified the British Empire.
  • That $3,000,000 grain loss in Buffalo (400,000 bushels) represents the scale of American agricultural wealth about to be conquered by the Midwest—within a decade, Chicago would overtake Buffalo as America's grain hub, making the Tribune's own city the agricultural capital of the nation.
  • The Louisiana political delegations seeking Andrew Johnson's favor represent the opening salvo of what would become the fierce battle over Reconstruction. Within two years, Congress would override Johnson's lenient policies and impose military rule on the South—exactly the outcome these 'Copperhead' delegations feared.
  • The mention of Senator Pomeroy introducing an anti-bribery bill with penalties up to $5,000 or 10 years imprisonment reflects post-Civil War fears about legislative corruption. The rapid industrialization about to sweep America would make such corruption endemic—the Gilded Age's notorious bribing of legislatures was already beginning.
  • Southern Illinois's experimental cotton cultivation—totaling 7,298 bales in 1865 alone—represents a failed dream of turning the North into cotton country post-emancipation. Within five years, Northern farmers would abandon cotton cultivation as Southern production recovered and Northern agriculture pivoted to grain and livestock.
Anxious Reconstruction Politics International War Conflict Military Disaster Fire Crime Violent
March 18, 1866 March 20, 1866

Also on March 19

1836
Rails & Slaves: Inside Virginia's 1836 Race for Progress
Richmond enquirer (Richmond, Va.)
1846
Indiana's $5 Million Debt Blows Up in London—and the State Blames the...
Indiana State sentinel (Indianapolis)
1856
Selling the Future: A Slaveholder's Final Auction Before America Breaks Apart...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1861
Andrew Johnson Called a 'Southern Traitor'—And the South Would Soon Make Him...
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1862
Escape by Turkey: How a Saw and Stolen Livestock Got Two Officers Past Federal...
Washington telegraph (Washington, Ark.)
1863
1863: A Confederate Editor Warns of Despotism—From Within the South Itself
Memphis daily appeal (Memphis, Tenn.)
1864
Grant Takes Command: How the Union Finally Got Its Act Together (March 1864)
Springfield weekly Republican (Springfield, Mass.)
1865
March 20, 1865: Military trials, war bonds, and opera — Washington 3 weeks...
Daily national Republican (Washington, D.C.)
1876
An Axe, Blood-Stained Cuffs, and a Widow's Murder: Inside a Brutal 1876 NYC...
The sun (New York [N.Y.])
1896
COUNTED OUT: How Populists Won Alabama—Then Got Robbed (1896)
The Nebraska independent (Lincoln, Nebraska)
1906
1906: Kansas Politicians Battle Railroads While Epic Snowstorm Shuts Down...
The Topeka state journal (Topeka, Kansas)
1926
1926: When Poker Jim's Christmas Crisis Hit Small-Town Maryland
Montgomery County sentinel (Rockville, Md.)
1927
1927: Cleveland's Black Leaders Clash Over $1 Million Debt—And a Lawyer's...
The gazette (Cleveland, Ohio)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free