“"We Are Living in a State of Siege": How One Union Leader Turned on President Johnson—Feb. 1866”
What's on the Front Page
Just one year after Appomattox, Washington is in turmoil over President Andrew Johnson's lenient Reconstruction policies. Col. J.W. Forney delivered a blistering speech to Union soldiers at the Capitol, declaring that he feels as though the North is living "in a state of siege" — that former Confederate sympathizers who once mocked Union troops are now "claiming their accidental President" and celebrating Johnson's soft hand toward the South. Meanwhile, Congress debates a Constitutional amendment while Johnson dismisses the test oath for Southern officials as "too severe." The front page is dominated by other urgent dispatches: Union men are being driven out of Kentucky; a Fenian Brotherhood delegation in Pittsburgh is demanding the U.S. government intervene to free Irish-American prisoners convicted in Dublin; General Grant received a $100,000 gift during his New York reception; and a locomotive boiler explosion near Schenectady killed three railroad men. From Nashville, reports show Tennessee establishing an asylum for colored insane—with only $10,000 appropriated, a sum deemed "utterly insufficient" given the influx of freed people now "wandering over the country."
Why It Matters
This February 1866 paper captures the nation at a critical hinge point. Johnson's presidency was careening toward the showdown that would produce Radical Reconstruction and, eventually, his impeachment. Forney's fury—that Northern loyalists were being sidelined while Southern planter elites regained influence—reflected the growing rupture between Johnson and Congressional Republicans. The Fenian agitation hints at how Irish immigration and Irish-American power were reshaping American politics. And the Tennessee asylum item reveals the grinding practical crisis of Reconstruction: millions of newly free Black Americans needed institutions, services, and protection that the South had no will and no resources to provide. These aren't separate stories—they're all threads in the unraveling of Johnson's lenient vision.
Hidden Gems
- A store in Richmond, Virginia rented for $7,500 after $20,000 was refused just three months earlier in November—a dramatic collapse in Southern property values and economic confidence barely a year after the war's end.
- The Flying Cloud locomotive explosion near Schenectady killed the engineer, fireman, and conductor instantly, yet no investigation, safety regulations, or worker compensation are mentioned—a stark reminder that industrial deaths in 1866 were simply accepted as the cost of progress.
- Tennessee's Insane Hospital report shows 244 patients total in treatment, with 12 deaths recorded, but the asylum explicitly states it has repeatedly been asked to admit colored patients and has 'large numbers now wandering over the country'—revealing the deliberate exclusion of freed people from basic institutional care.
- A Fort Kearney paper boasts they'll soon receive four daily mails and three telegraph lines to the Pacific coast via the Union Pacific Railroad—infrastructure that wouldn't actually reach completion for years, showing how newspapers hyped western development that was still mostly on the drawing board.
- The New Jersey railroad meeting in Newark focused entirely on gaining legislative approval for a new rail line between Newark and New York—a project that required state intervention, showing how infrastructure in the 1860s was built through patronage and special legislative acts rather than private capital alone.
Fun Facts
- Col. Forney, the speaker Forney here, was a powerful Republican editor and politician who would serve as Clerk of the House—yet even his stature couldn't shield him from worrying that administration critics were "marked out for sacrifice," showing how perilous the political landscape was for Radical Republicans in early 1866.
- General Grant received a $100,000 testimonial gift in New York just weeks into his tour—adjusted for inflation, roughly $1.8 million today—and the paper casually mentions he nearly shot himself examining a new rifle prototype, a reminder that Grant's personal struggles with injury, illness, and depression plagued him throughout his life.
- The Fenian Brotherhood delegation demanding U.S. intervention for Irish prisoners represented a growing political force: by the 1870s, Irish-American voters would become kingmakers in urban politics, and the Fenian raids into Canada (which would happen later in 1866) would nearly trigger a war between the U.S. and Britain.
- Tennessee's appropriation of only $10,000 for a colored insane asylum was typical Southern intransigence—within a year, Congress would pass the First Reconstruction Act, fundamentally stripping Southern governments of power, in large part because they refused to establish basic services for freed people.
- The report mentions the Insane Hospital had treated 244 patients with expenses of $90,580 over two years—roughly $400 per patient annually, a sum that underscores how grossly underfunded Southern institutions were compared to Northern asylums, part of the larger infrastructure collapse of the postwar South.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free