“When Hawaii Feared a Killer Comet (And Laughed About It): A Pacific Island Paper from 1866”
What's on the Front Page
The Pacific Commercial Advertiser leads with a whimsical piece titled "The Coming Comet," reporting on astronomical predictions that a comet will approach Earth so closely it could convert oceans to ash and rocks. The article traces the comet panic back to 1832, when a French seer made similar doomsday prophecies with such grip on the public mind that the Professor of the Observatory felt compelled to officially refute the calculations. The front page includes a lengthy poem poking fun at apocalyptic dread, with lines like "Let's have done with the world 'tis sufficiently old." Below the celestial drama sits a column of witty aphorisms—"A blind man, like a newspaper, requires a leading article"—and a humorous anecdote about a drunk passenger mistaking a pier glass mirror for a door on an ocean steamer. The page also catalogs the world's largest bells, from St. Paul's at 18,000 pounds to Moscow's legendary unsung bell of 1833, weighing an estimated 432,772 pounds and standing nineteen feet high.
Why It Matters
In 1866, Hawaii was a kingdom in transition. Just four years earlier, the Great Mahele had redistributed Hawaiian lands, and American merchant interests were deepening their grip on the islands. This Honolulu newspaper reflects a colonial Anglo-American sensibility—published in English, filled with European and American references, carrying news of comet scares that gripped the Atlantic world. The piece captures the Victorian appetite for both scientific wonder and satirical skepticism about panic-mongering. Amid the Civil War's aftermath on the mainland, Hawaii's merchant class was consolidating power through commerce, a dynamic visible in the page's dense business advertising section featuring American import-export houses, shipping agents, and commission merchants anchoring Honolulu's growing role as a Pacific trade hub.
Hidden Gems
- The front page advertises Hawaiian Marriage Certificates for sale by H. M. Whitney—suggesting the formal standardization of legal marriage was still novel enough to require specialized blank forms, a window into how quickly colonial legal systems were being imposed on Hawaiian society.
- T. Mossman & Son advertises a 'splendid assortment' of porcelain and cut glass—including 'Silver Plated Tea and Paint Spoons'—indicating that even remote Honolulu had access to Victorian luxury goods that would have seemed extravagant to most of the world's population.
- The Kuokoa newspaper advertisement notes it has 'the largest circulation in the Group' and is read by both Hawaiians and foreigners, with translations into Hawaiian offered free—a rare acknowledgment of the bilingual reality of occupation-era Hawaii.
- Bishop & Co. Banking House advertises it can draw bills of exchange on the Bank of California in San Francisco and on three separate banking houses in Boston—a striking reminder that mid-19th-century Hawaii was already deeply wired into American financial networks.
- An ad mentions 'the justly celebrated Kawaihae Potatoes' available at the port of Kawaihae—a specific Hawaiian commodity that had become distinctive enough in Pacific trade to market by place name, showing how even agriculture was being reshaped for foreign commerce.
Fun Facts
- The comet panic of 1832 mentioned on the front page was real: Biela's Comet did make a close approach and spawned genuine public anxiety in Europe and America. By 1866, educated readers would have remembered the false alarm, making this satire of doomsday fears particularly timely.
- The Moscow bell referenced here—the unsung 432,772-pounder cast in 1533 for Empress Anne—is the famous 'Tsar Bell,' which still stands in the Kremlin today and remains the largest bell in the world. The paper's note that it 'was never hung' is correct; it cracked during a test in 1737.
- H. M. Whitney, listed as publisher and seller of marriage certificates and newspapers, was one of Hawaii's most influential early American settlers and would become a major force in Hawaiian printing and commerce—his descendants remained influential in Hawaiian affairs for generations.
- The dense listing of commission merchants and shipping agents reflects that Honolulu was becoming a crucial refueling and supply point for Pacific whaling fleets—an industry that was the internet of its day, creating enormous wealth and geopolitical leverage.
- The appearance of multiple insurance companies (New England Mutual Life, New York Phenix Marine) advertising in a Hawaiian newspaper shows how global capital markets were already operating in the 1860s, with American firms extending financial instruments to the Pacific frontier.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free