Friday
February 16, 1866
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.) — Chicago, Cook
“One Year After Lee's Surrender: Grant's Bold Gamble on Reconstruction (Feb. 16, 1866)”
Art Deco mural for February 16, 1866
Original newspaper scan from February 16, 1866
Original front page — Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

Just one year after Robert E. Lee's surrender, the Chicago Tribune's front page captures a nation grappling with Reconstruction chaos. The lead story concerns General Grant's position on readmitting Southern congressmen—he favors admitting loyal men who can take the test oath, a moderate stance that would soon put him at odds with Radical Republicans. But the real tumult sprawls across the page: Indiana reports losing 43,154 men in the war; a Liberty, Missouri savings bank was robbed of $72,000 by "negro bushwhackers"; and a Texas Reconstruction Convention debates whether secession was void or merely "voidable." Meanwhile, life carries on: four young men drowned in the Ohio River near Evansville; a naval race between the Winooski and Algonquin was abandoned in a storm (though the Winooski eventually "ran the Algonquin out of sight"); and New York's Broadway theaters and assembly rooms burned, destroying $203,000 in property. The page bristles with the contradictions of 1866—still bleeding from war, yet obsessed with railroads, telegraphs, and commercial opportunity.

Why It Matters

America in February 1866 was at an inflection point. The Civil War had ended just one year prior, but Reconstruction policy remained fractious and undefined. Grant's measured approach to Southern readmission represented moderate Republicanism, but it would soon clash with the Radical Republicans who controlled Congress and wanted harsher terms for the South. The items about freedmen's rights, the Freedmen's Bureau bill, and debates over secession's legality show a nation still fighting ideological battles with military ones barely finished. Meanwhile, the flood of stories about railroads, telegraph companies, and coal sales reveal the North's immediate pivot toward industrial expansion—wealth creation was replacing war production. The robbery by "bushwhackers" hints at the lawlessness of Reconstruction-era chaos that would persist for years.

Hidden Gems
  • A Chinaman's imitation skill impressed the Tribune so much they ran a full story: Canton manufacturers, shown American hats by importers, began hand-making identical hats and selling them back to San Francisco. This was cutting-edge global commerce and manufacturing espionage—in 1866.
  • Wall Street thieves with a sense of humor: a depositor brought two bags of gold to a bank, lost sight of them briefly, and two well-dressed thieves picked them up. When confronted, the thieves claimed they were just wagering whether the bags contained gold or silver. The depositor was delighted to learn he'd been robbed by 'thieves of high standing in the profession.' They retired to drink their 'whiskey skirts' won and lost.
  • New York's city chamberlain deposited $3,000,000 in the Broadway Bank, drew $105,000 in interest annually, and paid the city nothing—described as 'the most lucrative position in the gift of the people of this continent.' Pure nineteenth-century graft.
  • Macon cotton warehouses held 13,000 bales worth $8,875,000 (at 55 cents per pound)—just one year after the South's economic collapse. Reconstruction cotton commerce was rebounding faster than anyone expected.
  • Congress was entertaining a bill to establish an American college in China, funded by accumulated commercial fees from U.S. merchants—a proto-foreign aid scheme to train Chinese students in American law and commerce.
Fun Facts
  • Grant's cautious Reconstruction stance mentioned here—favoring loyal Southerners who could take the test oath—would define his eventual presidency (1869-1877). His moderation infuriated Radical Republicans, who would impeach Andrew Johnson that same year, just weeks after this paper ran.
  • The Tribune mentions a $50,000 appropriation for federal buildings in Cairo, Illinois. Cairo sat at the confluence of the Ohio and Mississippi rivers and was poised to become a major river port—it never happened. The city peaked at 15,000 people in 1900 and today has fewer than 2,000 residents, making this failed federal investment one of the saddest urban stories in American history.
  • The naval race between the Winooski and Algonquin was one of the last great wooden warship competitions. Within a decade, iron-hulled steam vessels would make these races obsolete, and the age of sail-and-steam hybrids would end. This Tribune story captures the tail end of an era.
  • That $88,000 purchase contract dispute over the San Francisco Flag newspaper involved what the paper calls a 'monopoly' held by the Overland Telegraph line. The Tribune framed this as an anti-monopoly fight—presaging the massive railroad and telegraph monopoly battles of the 1880s-1890s that would define the Gilded Age.
  • Indiana lost 43,154 men in the war according to the lead item. That's roughly 10% of the state's pre-war population of 450,000—a staggering casualty rate that explains why Reconstruction and veterans' pensions would dominate American politics for decades.
Contentious Reconstruction Politics Federal Reconstruction Crime Violent Economy Trade Transportation Maritime
February 15, 1866 February 17, 1866

Also on February 16

1836
1836: When Washington's Newspapers Sold Everything—Including People
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1846
Tennessee's Firebrand vs. Virginia's Diplomat: The Oregon Debate That Almost...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1856
America's Forgotten Gambling Habit: When States Ran Lotteries for Profit (1856)
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1861
A Southern Gazette on the Brink: Why This 1861 Newspaper Ignored the Civil War...
Arkansas state gazette (Little Rock, Ark.)
1862
Inside the Rebel Fortress: The Day Union Spies Mapped Bowling Green's 40 Cannons
The New York herald (New York [N.Y.])
1863
A General's Fury: When Union Officers Turned on Northern 'Peace' Advocates—Feb....
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1864
A Soldier's Plea: Inside Richmond's War Offices in February 1864
Richmond Whig (Richmond, Va.)
1865
Feb 16, 1865: 'South Carolina Under His Heel' — Sherman's Army Cuts Confederacy...
New-York daily tribune (New-York [N.Y.])
1876
1876 Augusta: When Laughing Gas Was Cutting-Edge Dentistry & Everyone Sold Hair...
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1886
How Snow Got Stacked in Pyramids: Washington's Winter Crisis of 1886
The Washington critic (Washington, D.C.)
1906
1906: When America Created Modern Police, Roosevelt Nearly Invaded Morocco, and...
The Oregon mist (St. Helens, Columbia County, Or.)
1926
1926: When City Hall hired 10 lawyers (including the Klan's counsel) and a...
The Indianapolis times (Indianapolis [Ind.])
1927
Jazz Made Him Kill, France Said No to Peace: Feb. 16, 1927
The Elkins inter-mountain (Elkins, W. Va.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free