“1865: When freed slaves told Union officers 'we want nothing to do with white men'”
What's on the Front Page
Six months after Lee's surrender, the South Carolina coast is in chaos. The New York Herald reports that freed slaves on some thirty-two plantations in Colleton district — including islands like James, John, and Wadmalaw — have essentially seized control, refusing to work with white landowners and threatening to expel anyone who tries to interfere. When Lieutenant Colonel Pope of the 54th Massachusetts (a Black regiment) tried to inspect one plantation, the freedmen 'hooted at' him and 'told him they wanted nothing to do with white men.' Meanwhile, Charleston's mechanics and workingmen have formed their own political party specifically 'in opposition to the encouragement of Negro workmen' and nominated Confederate hero Wade Hampton for governor. The situation is so dire that General Oliver Howard of the Freedmen's Bureau has rushed to Charleston to sort out the mess, while disease ravages the island communities — on James Island alone, 800 out of 3,500 freedmen died of smallpox in August and September.
Why It Matters
This snapshot captures Reconstruction at its most chaotic moment. President Johnson's lenient policies toward the South are colliding with the reality of four million newly freed slaves and the question of who controls the land they worked for generations. The Freedmen's Bureau, created just months earlier, is already feuding with military commanders over authority. These tensions — over labor, land, and racial hierarchy — will define the next decade and ultimately shape the Jim Crow system that follows. The white workingmen's political organizing against Black labor competition foreshadows the racial politics that will dominate Southern elections for the next century.
Hidden Gems
- Charleston's election managers had to ask the military for money to buy new ballot boxes because soldiers had destroyed all the old ones as being 'tainted with secession' — a literal cleansing of democracy's tools
- The paper cost five cents in 1865 — equivalent to about $0.85 today, making it quite expensive for daily reading
- Ex-Governor Aiken is watching helplessly as freedmen on his plantation 'appropriate the crops, kill the stock and cut the timber' while he's legally barred from reclaiming his pardoned land
- The Freedmen's Bureau has seized Charleston's public schools and appointed Reuben Tomlinson as 'Superintendent of Education for the State of South Carolina,' refusing to return buildings unless trustees agree to integrate white and Black children
- Three different political tickets are running, but they all nominated the exact same candidates for Lieutenant Governor and State Senators — only the gubernatorial race and representatives differ
Fun Facts
- Wade Hampton, nominated by Charleston's workingmen, would indeed become governor in 1876 through a violently contested election that helped end Reconstruction nationwide — his victory was part of the deal that put Rutherford Hayes in the White House
- The 54th Massachusetts regiment whose officer was threatened was the same unit featured in the movie 'Glory' — by 1865, these celebrated Black soldiers found themselves mediating between freed slaves and white authorities
- General Oliver Howard, rushing to Charleston to handle the crisis, was known as the 'Christian General' and would later found Howard University — but his Freedmen's Bureau became one of the most controversial agencies in American history
- This newspaper's whole number '10,646' means the Herald had been publishing daily for nearly 30 years — making it one of the most established papers covering the unfolding crisis of Reconstruction
- The mention of the Wirz trial at the bottom refers to Henry Wirz, commandant of Andersonville prison, who would become the only Confederate executed for war crimes — his trial was happening simultaneously with this post-war chaos
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free