Saturday
September 9, 1865
The daily Gate City (Keokuk, Iowa) — Keokuk, Iowa
“1865: 'We own everything by conquest' — Sherman's shocking speech & the forgotten soldiers”
Art Deco mural for September 9, 1865
Original newspaper scan from September 9, 1865
Original front page — The daily Gate City (Keokuk, Iowa) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

General Sherman delivers a fiery speech defending the 'right of conquest' over defeated Confederate states, declaring that rebels forfeited everything when they 'ventured their all' against the Union. The western hero tells a soldiers' festival in Ohio that by conquest, the government now owns all rebel property—their slaves, mules, horses, cotton, and even their lives, which they keep only by 'our forbearance and clemency.' Meanwhile, the U.S. Christian Commission sounds desperate alarms about 160,000 soldiers still stationed across Texas and the Western frontier, pleading 'Not a Dollar in the Treasury' to supply these forgotten troops with basic necessities. The Republican ticket for Iowa features William M. Stone for Governor and Benjamin F. Gue for Lieutenant Governor. A horrifying story emerges of Captain Charles P. Johnson of the 17th Iowa Infantry, who lies face-down at Benton Barracks after a Minnie ball passed completely through his body at Jackson, Mississippi in 1863—he's been flat on his stomach for twenty-seven months, unable to move, yet was discharged just one day before he would have qualified for three months' additional pay.

Why It Matters

This September 1865 snapshot captures America's confused transition from war to peace. While Sherman articulates the harsh logic of total victory, the Christian Commission's plea reveals how quickly the public lost interest in supporting troops once the shooting stopped. The debate over President Johnson's Reconstruction policies—particularly regarding Black suffrage—shows the fundamental questions about federal versus state authority that would define the next decade. With 160,000 soldiers still occupying the South and West, Reconstruction was far from over, yet civilian support was already evaporating. The tension between military necessity and war-weary citizens would plague efforts to rebuild the South and protect newly freed slaves.

Hidden Gems
  • A farmer's wife near Brantford, Upper Canada confessed on her deathbed to poisoning six people during her lifetime—four children (including two of her own) and two adults—claiming she had 'a mania for poisoning' and barely restrained herself from killing all her relatives
  • Captain Johnson was promoted to Captain just three days before he turned 18 years old, making him one of the youngest officers in the Union Army
  • The Western branches of the Christian Commission are specifically requesting 'vegetables and other articles' for soldiers—a reminder that proper nutrition was still a major concern for troops in remote postings
  • Sherman's speech took place 'near Lancaster, Ohio'—ironically, this was the hometown of his fellow general and future president William Tecumseh Sherman's namesake
  • A woman who once spat on Captain Johnson when he was a prisoner later came begging him to intercede with Sherman on her behalf after Atlanta fell
Fun Facts
  • General Sherman's 'right of conquest' speech would later haunt Reconstruction—his harsh rhetoric gave ammunition to critics who argued the North was treating the South like a conquered foreign nation rather than wayward states
  • The Christian Commission mentioned receiving 'unparalleled courtesy' from railroad and telegraph lines—these same companies were rapidly connecting the continent, with the transcontinental railroad just four years from completion
  • Captain Johnson's tragic case of being discharged one day before qualifying for extra pay wasn't uncommon—the government was desperately trying to cut costs after spending $3.2 billion on the war, roughly half the nation's entire pre-war wealth
  • Iowa's debate over Black suffrage mentioned in Secretary Harlan's letter was ahead of its time—the state would actually grant voting rights to Black men in 1868, two years before the 15th Amendment required it
  • The mention of 60,000 troops in Texas reflects the massive 'Army of Observation' stationed there to pressure French forces out of Mexico—a little-known near-war that helped end Napoleon III's puppet regime
Contentious Civil War Reconstruction Politics Federal War Conflict Military Civil Rights Crime Violent
September 8, 1865 September 10, 1865

Also on September 9

1846
How a Traitor's Shame Haunted Him Across an Ocean: Benedict Arnold's Forgotten...
Indiana State sentinel (Indianapolis [Ind.])
1856
Inside Antebellum New Orleans: The Business Directory of a Doomed Economy (1856)
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1861
Dogs Gone Mad, Counterfeits, and Parade Day in Wartime New Orleans (Sept. 9,...
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1862
The Tax That Won the Civil War: October 1st Changes Everything (And the Feds...
Daily State sentinel (Indianapolis, Ind.)
1863
50 Deserters a Night: The Confederacy Comes Apart (September 1863)
New-York daily tribune (New-York [N.Y.])
1864
Last Gasp of the Confederacy: What Mississippi's War Department Charged for a...
The daily clarion (Meridian, Miss.)
1866
One Year After Appomattox: A Radical New Orleans Newspaper Argues Why Democracy...
New Orleans tribune (New Orleans [La.])
1876
Silver Riches & Stagecoach Misery: Inside Booming Arizona, 1876
Arizona citizen (Tucson, Pima County, A.T. [i.e. Ariz.])
1886
When a Foundryman Stole a Newspaper's Horse: Life in 1886 Michigan
Weekly expositor (Brockway Centre, Mich.)
1896
The Slaver's Noose: Why a 35-Year-Old Execution Haunted 1896 America
The Louisiana Democrat (Alexandria, La.)
1906
When the Czar's Uncle Went Too Far: Royal Scandals & Forgotten Wars of 1906
Albuquerque morning journal (Albuquerque, N.M.)
1926
When Teachers Had Their Names in the Paper & $35 Could Land You in Jail
Pocahontas times (Huntersville, W. Va.)
1927
Ford's Mystery Car Has the World Obsessed (And We Still Don't Know What It Is)
Clinch Valley news (Jeffersonville, Va.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free