Friday
August 25, 1865
The New York herald (New York [N.Y.]) — New York City, New York
“The Trial That Defined War Crimes: Andersonville's Commandant Faces Justice”
Art Deco mural for August 25, 1865
Original newspaper scan from August 25, 1865
Original front page — The New York herald (New York [N.Y.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The front page is dominated by the military trial of Captain Henry Wirz, the Swiss-born commandant of the notorious Andersonville prison camp where thousands of Union soldiers died during the Civil War. The court has refused to postpone the trial any further, despite desperate pleas from Wirz's defense attorney, Mr. Schade, who claims his previous legal team abandoned the case just weeks before trial, leaving him alone to defend a man facing potential execution. Wirz himself has written a letter to General Wilson, claiming he was merely "a tool in the hands of his superiors" and desperately seeking safe conduct to leave the country. The prosecution is laying out horrific testimony about conditions at Andersonville, with witnesses claiming that seventy-five percent of the Union prisoners who died there "could have been saved." Wirz's defense team is scrambling with multiple legal strategies: arguing he was promised safe conduct when he surrendered, claiming he's covered under the surrender terms between Generals Sherman and Johnston, and insisting he was just following orders as a low-ranking officer in the Confederate system. The courtroom drama is intense, with new counsel volunteering mid-trial and heated exchanges over jurisdictional questions.

Why It Matters

This trial represents America's first major war crimes prosecution, setting precedents for how the nation would handle accountability after civil conflict. Just four months after Lincoln's assassination and Lee's surrender, the country is grappling with fundamental questions: How do you prosecute war crimes when both sides claimed to be legitimate governments? Can military officers claim they were "just following orders"? The Wirz trial is essentially America's post-Civil War reckoning with the horrors of Andersonville, where an estimated 13,000 Union prisoners died. The legal arguments being made—about safe conduct promises, military jurisdiction, and the boundaries of the Sherman-Johnston surrender terms—would echo through American military justice for generations. This case is helping define how a reunited nation handles justice versus reconciliation.

Hidden Gems
  • Wirz's original defense team of "Messrs. Hughes, Denver and Peck" had the case for "three or four weeks" before suddenly abandoning it, leaving attorney Schade scrambling alone at the last minute
  • A new lawyer, "O.S. Baker, Esq., who was in the court room, volunteered his services to assist as counsel for the defence" right in the middle of proceedings
  • The defense claims Wirz was previously arraigned and put on trial "on the 21st of August, 1865" before a military commission that was then "broken up without his agency or consent," meaning he's arguing double jeopardy
  • Captain Noyes of General Wilson's staff allegedly promised Wirz safe conduct if he would provide information to headquarters, but Wirz claims this promise was broken when he was arrested
  • The prosecution cites an official opinion from "Judge Holt, the Chief of the Bureau of Military Justice" about when someone can be considered to have been previously tried
Fun Facts
  • Henry Wirz would become the only Confederate officer executed for war crimes after the Civil War—he was hanged on November 10, 1865, making this trial a preview of his fate
  • Andersonville prison, which Wirz commanded, crammed 33,000 Union prisoners into a 26-acre stockade designed for 10,000—creating conditions so horrific that even some Confederate officials were appalled
  • The "Bureau of Military Justice" mentioned in the trial was a brand-new institution, created in 1862 as America's first systematic approach to military law and justice
  • The Sherman-Johnston surrender terms that Wirz's defense cites were actually rejected by Washington as too lenient—Sherman had to renegotiate harsher terms, which is why this legal argument was shaky
  • This trial established the precedent that "following orders" is not a complete defense for war crimes—a principle that would later influence the Nuremberg trials after World War II
Tragic Civil War Reconstruction Crime Trial War Conflict Military Crime Violent
August 24, 1865 August 26, 1865

Also on August 25

1836
A Maryland Gold Rush Pitch From 1836—And the Slave Auction Listed Below It
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1846
One Cent for Virtue: Inside the First Issue of Washington's Temperance...
The Columbian fountain (Washington, D.C.)
1856
1856: New Orleans Commerce in Overdrive—Steamboats, Windmills, and the Summer...
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1861
Bull Run Victory in Nashville: The South's Finest Hour—or So They Thought
Daily Nashville patriot (Nashville, Tenn.)
1862
Richmond Under Pressure: The Moment the South's Military Luck Began to Turn...
Richmond Whig (Richmond, Va.)
1863
Charleston Under Fire: How the Civil War Turned on Sleeping Civilians (Aug 25,...
Memphis daily appeal (Memphis, Tenn.)
1864
1864 Connecticut: While Sherman Closes In on Atlanta, a Small-Town Paper...
The Willimantic journal (Willimantic, Conn.)
1866
ONE YEAR AFTER APPOMATTOX: Republicans Plan Second Civil War? (1866 Auburn,...
The Placer herald (Auburn, Placer County, Calif.)
1876
Apache Gunfight & Deadly Windstorm Hit Arizona Territory—Plus the Centennial...
Arizona weekly miner (Prescott, Ariz.)
1886
How a Cow Derailed a Train & Geronimo's Last Stand Begins—August 25, 1886
The Washington critic (Washington, D.C.)
1896
McKinley vs. the Depression: How a Tariff Speech Predicted the 1896 Election...
The Wichita daily eagle (Wichita, Kan.)
1906
Bombs in St. Petersburg, Political Intrigue in Honolulu, and the Great Hawaiian...
The Hawaiian star (Honolulu [Oahu])
1926
When a Senator's Last Wish Was a Simple Country Funeral (Plus: Record-Breaking...
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1927
Lost Aviators, Doomed Radicals, and a Priest in the Ruins: August 25, 1927
Amerikanski srbobran (Pittsburg, Pa.;Pittsburgh, Pa.)
View all 14 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free