Friday
August 18, 1865
The Bedford gazette (Bedford, Pa.) — Bedford, Pennsylvania
“1865: Confederate Governor's Brutal Confession — 'Our Hearts Were Never In It'”
Art Deco mural for August 18, 1865
Original newspaper scan from August 18, 1865
Original front page — The Bedford gazette (Bedford, Pa.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Bedford Gazette features a remarkable speech by Benjamin F. Perry, Andrew Johnson's handpicked Provisional Governor of South Carolina, delivered in Greenville on July 3, 1865 — just months after the Confederacy's collapse. Perry pulls no punches in his post-mortem of the rebellion, declaring that 'the heart of the Southern people never was in this revolution' and that there wasn't a single state except South Carolina where a majority actually favored secession. The speech reads like a brutal autopsy of Confederate failure, with Perry revealing that General Lee's army had 70,000 men on the muster roll but only 14,000 ready for battle due to mass desertion and absenteeism. Perry saves his harshest criticism for Confederate leadership, noting that the very people who pushed hardest for war — politicians, newspaper editors, and preachers — were the same ones exempted from military service by the Confederate Congress. He argues that Lincoln's assassination was actually no great loss to the South, claiming Andrew Johnson is 'a much abler and firmer man' and more acceptable as a Southern Democrat who understands slavery. The Bedford Gazette editor clearly relishes printing this inflammatory speech, challenging local rival the Bedford Inquirer to defend Johnson's choice of Perry as governor.

Why It Matters

This speech captures the brutal reality of Reconstruction politics in summer 1865, when President Johnson was trying to rapidly restore Southern states through provisional governors rather than the harsh military occupation favored by Radical Republicans in Congress. Perry's candid admissions about Confederate weakness and his praise for Andrew Johnson over Lincoln reveal the delicate balancing act Johnson was attempting — installing Southern leaders who would acknowledge defeat while still being acceptable to white Southern voters. The Bedford Gazette's pointed challenge to the rival Bedford Inquirer reflects how even small Pennsylvania towns were deeply divided over Reconstruction policy, foreshadowing the political battles that would soon tear Johnson's presidency apart.

Hidden Gems
  • The newspaper's subscription terms reveal the cash-strapped reality of 1865 America: $2.00 per year if paid in advance, but jumping to $3.00 if you waited more than six months — a 50% penalty for late payment
  • Perry claims that taking Southern slaves from the post office without subscribing was considered 'prima facie evidence of fraud and a criminal offence' by U.S. courts — showing how seriously newspaper theft was taken
  • The governor admits he watched the original secession meeting from his law office window five years earlier, describing it as 'college boys and their professors, merchants, mechanics, doctors, lawyers and soldiers from the hotels' rushing into the courthouse
  • Perry reveals that planters typically rented land for 'one-third of the gross products' and argues this would be more profitable than slave labor, since most farmers 'make anything except by the increase of their slaves'
Fun Facts
  • Benjamin F. Perry praised General Lee as 'next in greatness to General Washington' — this was just four months after Appomattox, when Lee was still considered a traitor by many Northerners and wouldn't become a beloved national figure for decades
  • Perry's claim that only South Carolina had a secession majority was largely accurate — most Southern states' secession conventions were dominated by wealthy planters who didn't represent popular opinion, and several states like Tennessee initially rejected secession
  • The speech reveals the staggering cost of the Civil War: Perry mentions 'five thousand millions of dollars' spent by Southern states, plus $2 billion worth of freed slaves — making it the most expensive conflict in American history to that point
  • Perry's prediction that the South would be 'happy and prosperous again' in ten years was remarkably prescient — by 1875, the economy had largely recovered, though Reconstruction's political gains for freed slaves were being systematically rolled back
  • The newspaper's location in Bedford, Pennsylvania puts it right along the path of Lee's invasion route to Gettysburg just two years earlier — local readers would have visceral memories of Confederate troops marching through their region
Contentious Civil War Reconstruction Politics Federal Politics State War Conflict Civil Rights
August 17, 1865 August 19, 1865

Also on August 18

1846
Bavaria Opens Its Doors to American Settlers—Plus a $120 Lost Wallet and a...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1856
Before the War: New Orleans' Last Summer of Unchecked Commerce (1856)
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1861
War Diary: The Rebel Army Marches Toward Washington—And a Union Doctor...
The New York herald (New York [N.Y.])
1862
100 Years Back: McClellan's Grand Army Quietly Retreats from Richmond—A Union...
Chicago daily tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1863
Lee's Army is Collapsing From Within—And Ohio Vigilantes Know It (Aug. 18, 1863)
Cleveland morning leader (Cleveland [Ohio])
1864
The South's Desperate Gamble: How Atlanta's Siege Revealed the Confederacy Was...
The evening telegraph (Philadelphia [Pa.])
1866
Cholera, Fenian Invasions & Murdered Freedmen: America's Chaotic Summer of 1866
The Evansville journal (Evansville, Ind.)
1876
Starving on Marrow and Beetles: A 71-Year-Old Gold Rusher Breaks 27 Years of...
Arizona weekly miner (Prescott, Ariz.)
1886
Inside the Machine: Why a Forgotten 1886 Gossip Column Reveals How Washington...
The Washington critic (Washington, D.C.)
1896
300-Room Mountain Resort, Pianos Worth $27,000 Today, and the Bicycles You...
Among the clouds (Mount Washington, N.H.)
1906
1906: Bank Teller's Tragic End & the $2M Scandal That Rocked Chicago
Macon beacon (Macon, Miss.)
1926
1926: When tourists drove from Panama to Minnesota and women out-shot the men
Grand Rapids herald-review (Grand Rapids, Itasca County, Minn)
1927
1927: When a 103-Year-Old Newspaper Risked Everything for the Doomed Prisoners
Springfield weekly Republican (Springfield, Mass.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free