Wednesday
May 31, 1865
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.) — Illinois, Cook
“May 31, 1865: Jefferson Davis wanted Lincoln's entire cabinet dead, plus Chicago's $18 ice scandal”
Art Deco mural for May 31, 1865
Original newspaper scan from May 31, 1865
Original front page — Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

Chicago is celebrating the end of the Civil War with a grand Soldiers' Fair, featuring speeches by Governor Oglesby and a poem by T. Buchanan Read (author of "Sheridan's Ride"). Meanwhile, the conspiracy trial of Lincoln's assassination continues in Washington, with damning testimony that Jefferson Davis, upon hearing of Lincoln's murder on April 13th, declared "if it were done it were better it were well done, and that Johnson and Stanton were assassinated also." The city is also embroiled in a bitter ice war - the Chicago Ice Company is trying to charge $18 per ton for ice delivery, prompting angry citizens to form a competing "National Ice Company" promising ice at just 50 cents per hundred pounds. General Sherman has submitted his defense of his controversial peace negotiations with Confederate General Johnston, complaining bitterly about Secretary of War Stanton's public criticism. The military departments are being reorganized with Thomas at Richmond, Halleck on the Pacific, Meade on the Atlantic, and Sheridan commanding the Trans-Mississippi. Gold closed in New York at 136⅝, and Lincoln's personal riding horse has been purchased for $6,200 and is heading to Chicago's fair.

Why It Matters

This front page captures America in the delicate weeks after victory - celebrating the Union triumph while grappling with how to treat the defeated South and punish the conspirators. The testimony about Jefferson Davis reveals the bitter hatred still festering among Confederate leaders, while Governor Oglesby's call for "forbearance and forgiveness" reflects Lincoln's own vision for reconstruction. The reorganization of military commands shows the massive logistical challenge of occupying and rebuilding the South, with trusted generals like Sherman and Sheridan taking key roles in the uncertain peace ahead.

Hidden Gems
  • Lincoln's personal riding horse was purchased for $6,200 (roughly $100,000 today) and shipped to Chicago's Soldiers' Fair as an attraction
  • The Chicago Ice Company was charging $18 per ton for ice delivery while offering to sell their entire stock of 'nearly thirty thousand tons' for just $2 per ton to competitors - a markup of 900%
  • Kentucky elected a 'distinguished bushwhacker' (Confederate guerrilla fighter) as Justice of the Peace, and the Secretary of State unknowingly issued him a commission before discovering his background
  • San Francisco subscribed 'a quarter of a million dollars to the seven-thirty loan' on a single Thursday, showing the West's financial support for reconstruction
  • The rebel steamer Magenta was seized at St. Louis by General Pope for 'flagrant acts of disloyalty' during its trip from New Orleans
Fun Facts
  • T. Buchanan Read, whose poem graced Chicago's Soldiers' Fair, wrote 'Sheridan's Ride' - one of the most famous Civil War poems that helped make Philip Sheridan a national hero
  • The conspiracy trial testimony about Jefferson Davis would later be used as evidence of his war crimes, though he would never be tried and eventually became a symbol of the 'Lost Cause' mythology
  • That $18-per-ton ice the Chicago company was charging? Ice was harvested from frozen lakes and stored in sawdust - the high price was pure monopoly gouging in an era before refrigeration
  • General Sherman's complaint about Secretary Stanton's public criticism marked the beginning of a feud that would simmer for years, with Sherman eventually becoming one of Stanton's harshest critics
  • Gold trading at 136⅝ meant it took $1.36 in paper money to buy $1 in gold - a sign of inflation from financing the war that wouldn't be resolved until the 1870s
Contentious Civil War Reconstruction Politics Federal Crime Trial Economy Markets Military
May 30, 1865 June 1, 1865

Also on May 31

1846
Chaos on the Rio Grande: American troops rout Mexico's army as generals flee in...
The New York herald (New York [N.Y.])
1856
May 31, 1856: Delaware Lottery Schemes & Military Land Warrants—A Nation...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1861
Six Weeks Into Secession: New Orleans Mobilizes for War (May 31, 1861)
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1862
Senator Wade's Fiery Defense of Confiscation: Can the Constitution Survive...
Ashtabula weekly telegraph (Ashtabula, Ohio)
1863
A Long-Lost Brother Revealed on a Columbus Street: How One Woman's Stalker...
Daily Ohio statesman (Columbus, Ohio)
1864
Inside Wartime Washington: The Auctions, Condemned Horses & Booming Real Estate...
Evening star (Washington, D.C.)
1866
Federal General Indicted for 'Kidnapping'—and the Academy of Music Burns: May...
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1876
Gold Rush Madness & Lynch Mob Justice: America's Dark Centennial Summer
The daily gazette (Wilmington, Del.)
1886
The White House Wedding Nobody Saw Coming—Plus 13,000 Miles of Railroad Changed...
Savannah morning news (Savannah)
1896
Czar Nicholas II's Coronation: Why Russia's New Ruler Already Disappointed...
The sun (New York [N.Y.])
1906
When steamboats ruled Maryland and undertakers moonlighted as blacksmiths (1906)
Saint Mary's beacon (Leonard Town, Md.)
1926
1926: When Horse Buggies Crashed Into Cars & Evolution Went to Court
Brownsville herald (Brownsville, Tex.)
1927
Priest Gets Poland's Highest Honor While 19 Die in Holiday Carnage—And...
New Britain herald (New Britain, Conn.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free