“Toxic Candy, Desperate Grizzlies & Grant's Rejected Job Application (Dec. 16, 1864)”
What's on the Front Page
On December 16, 1864, the Worcester Daily Spy leads with a scathing exposé on adulterated candy—a public health crisis that reads like a 19th-century food safety scandal. Confectioners are stretching profits by replacing expensive sugar (30-32 cents per pound) with cheap "terre alba," a chalky substance costing only 1.5 cents per pound. Some large factories use 2,000 to 3,000 pounds of this earth per week, with the worst offenders filling candy up to two-thirds chalk, coating just the outside with real sugar to deceive buyers. The result: children consuming insoluble substances that lodge in their stomachs, causing inflammation and potentially fatal diseases. The paper even provides a simple test—drop the candy in water and look for white sediment at the bottom. Also featured: a harrowing account of Bishop Melvaile's near-drowning aboard the steamship Etna from Liverpool, where a 100-ton wave swept him nearly overboard; a curious artifact from U.S. Grant's past—his rejected 1859 application for county engineer in St. Louis; and reports of wild bears, lions, and coyotes ravaging Southern California ranches during a severe drought.
Why It Matters
This issue captures America in late 1864—the final push of the Civil War, yet the home front is wrestling with the profiteering and deception that always accompanies wartime inflation. Sugar prices had skyrocketed due to the economic disruption, making adulteration profitable and rampant. The candy scandal reflects a broader problem: minimal food regulation and no FDA. It wouldn't be until 1906 that the Pure Food and Drug Act would finally crack down on such practices. Meanwhile, Grant appears in these pages as an obscure military officer applying for a county job—just five years before he'd command the Union Army. The Southern California wildlife crisis hints at how Manifest Destiny was reshaping ecosystems as settlers moved west, destroying habitats and forcing predators to prey on livestock.
Hidden Gems
- The Worcester Daily Spy charges $9.00 per annum—roughly $160 in today's money for a year of daily news, yet the Massachusetts Spy (their sister publication, established July 1770!) apparently costs slightly less, with the exact price obscured by OCR. Both are published by J. Baldwin & Co. from 212 Main Street.
- A New York robbery in broad daylight on Monday afternoon shows sophisticated criminal technique: the robber chokes his elderly victim into submission, pickpockets him, then shouts 'Stop thief! Stop thief!' himself—creating confusion that briefly allows his escape before witnesses recover and pursue him.
- One item casually mentions that U.S. Army mortality averages 72 per thousand annually—only 20 from battle and 52 from disease—then brags this is 'much less than the usual rate of mortality in European armies, and less than one-fourth of that of the British army in the Crimea.' By late 1864, this was actually good news.
- Fashion is literally recycling: Philadelphia importers found wide belt buckles designed for ladies' waists from 28 years earlier (1836) sitting unsold in a garret. When re-released to retailers, they sold so fast that within days only a few remained—and at prices high enough to cover 28 years of interest on the original investment plus substantial profit.
- The San Francisco News Letter's editor offers this crude bon mot to departing Rev. Dr. Bellows: 'May you blow, Bellows, until death rudely stops your wind, and may no curious doctor, after death, cut you open to see where it all came from'—puns on his name in an era when editorial humor ran delightfully dark.
Fun Facts
- The candy adulteration exposé specifically names "terre alba" (white earth) imported from Derbyshire, England. This mineral filler remained a persistent problem in food manufacturing well into the 20th century; it took decades of muckraking journalism and the 1906 Pure Food and Drug Act to finally criminalize the practice.
- U.S. Grant's rejected application for county engineer in 1859 shows a man seeking modest local office just five years before becoming General-in-Chief of all Union armies. The document notes that several signatories recommending Grant 'occupy positions in the rebel army'—a haunting historical artifact signed by men who would soon be his enemies.
- Bishop Melvaile's near-fatal wave during his passage from Liverpool reflects the genuine perils of transatlantic travel in 1864; a cabin boy died in the incident, yet the bishop survived only because two stewards pulled him to safety. Steamship travel was still more dangerous than most people today realize.
- The article on Southern California predators provides one of the few firsthand accounts of grizzly bear density in the region before their near-extinction. By the 1920s, California grizzlies would be completely gone—this 1864 report captures them at the moment of their ecological collapse.
- An item notes that a young New York merchant 'was taken violently, and, it is feared, incurably insane Saturday evening, the cause being no less than excessive prosperity in business'—a striking 19th-century diagnosis suggesting that even in 1864, rapid financial success was recognized as psychologically destabilizing.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free