“Lincoln's Crushing Victory: How America Chose War Over Peace (Nov. 13, 1864)”
What's on the Front Page
Lincoln's decisive re-election victory dominates the Chicago Tribune's November 13, 1864 front page, with Union majorities rolling in from across the nation. "From Maine to California, from the Atlantic to the Pacific, the cry is still for war," the paper declares triumphantly. California delivered a stunning 25,000-vote majority for Lincoln—a dramatic reversal from 1860 when he lost the state by 657 votes to Douglas. Maine's "handsome majority of eighteen thousand" is expected to swell to 25,000 once soldier votes are counted. Closer to home, Chicago gave Lincoln 37,239 votes with a city majority of 1,831. The Tribune's editorial tone is euphoric: they've even installed new type to print the paper, hoping these new letters "will chronicle peace and a restoration of the integrity of the Republic." Beyond politics, General Sherman's mysterious movements continue southward, General Grant repulsed a sharp rebel attack, and naval forces captured Plymouth, North Carolina—taking 52 pieces of artillery and "hundreds of loyal North Carolinians" under rebel occupation.
Why It Matters
This election occurred at the war's darkest hour for Lincoln, with many Northerners exhausted by four years of slaughter. A Democratic victory would likely have meant negotiated peace with the Confederacy intact. Instead, Lincoln's mandate—amplified by soldier votes—ensured the war would continue to unconditional Union victory and the abolition of slavery. The Tribune's joy reflects the North's commitment to finish what they started. This moment transformed the Civil War from a constitutional struggle into a revolutionary war for emancipation, setting the stage for Reconstruction and America's tortured century of racial reckoning.
Hidden Gems
- The Tribune proudly announces it's switched to new type mid-election coverage—a practical detail revealing how 19th-century newspapers constantly evolved their physical appearance, with font changes treated as newsworthy events worthy of editorial comment.
- A reader in Orange, New Jersey sent detailed coverage of locals firing a cannon captured during the War of 1812, which had been spiked by angry Democrats post-election. Union men had a blacksmith drill it open again and fired it triumphantly—celebrating an election victory by weaponizing history itself.
- Confederate currency was already worthless in Texas: 'Jeff. Davis' currency has been almost entirely set aside by the rebels of Texas, only Greenbacks being accepted.' The rebel economy was collapsing even as their armies fought on.
- General Cortinas, a former Republican governor of Matamoras, Mexico, defected to become an Imperialist—and at a public dinner there, guests toasted 'The Union of the Southern Confederacy and Mexico' while the band played 'Bonnie Blue Flag.' Confederate leaders were desperately seeking foreign alliances.
- The Tribune's circulation rates reveal Civil War economics: daily delivery in Chicago cost $10 annually, while a club of twenty-one copies cost $40—meaning bulk subscriptions ran about $1.90 per copy per year, far cheaper than individual rates.
Fun Facts
- Lincoln's 1864 electoral victory was narrow enough that if just a few thousand Ohio soldiers had voted Democratic, George McClellan—the general Lincoln had fired—might have become president and ended the war prematurely. The paper's jubilation was justified; this was democracy's knife-edge moment.
- The Tribune mentions testing a new wrought-iron rifled 7-inch gun designed by 'Mr. Ames of Connecticut' that withstood thirty-pound powder charges 700 times without damage—achieving ranges of seven miles. These innovations represented America's rapid industrial militarization, turning Connecticut manufacturers into weapons designers who would reshape warfare.
- The Confederate Congress was debating whether to arm enslaved people for military service, with debate centering on whether this should happen only if 'the white element should become exhausted.' Within months, Lee would approve arming 300,000 slaves—a desperate measure that revealed the Confederacy's terminal weakness.
- European newspapers, particularly the London Herald, were defending the Confederate privateer Florida and denouncing the Union Navy's capture of it in a Brazilian harbor as 'piracy.' Britain and France never formally recognized the Confederacy, but their financial and rhetorical support kept Southern hopes alive until the very end.
- The paper reports that navigation on the Mississippi River has closed for winter, with the last St. Paul boat arriving that morning. This seasonal reality meant Civil War campaigns had to follow river conditions—Lincoln's re-election came just as Northern armies would have four months of winter to consolidate gains before spring offensives.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free