“"He Would Incite Them to Riot While He Purchases Safety"—Iowa Newspaper Exposes Copperhead Hypocrisy, August 1864”
What's on the Front Page
The Gate City leads with urgent war dispatches from Virginia in late August 1864, as Union forces execute a brilliant tactical victory. The 5th Army Corps under General Ayres successfully executed a flank movement on the Weldon Railroad, repulsing three desperate Confederate counterattacks and inflicting an estimated 1,000 enemy casualties against 400 Union losses. But the paper's moral fury is reserved for the *Chicago Times*, a Democratic newspaper the editors accuse of sedition for opposing the military draft. The Times had published arguments claiming the draft was unconstitutional and urged readers to resist—all while its own editor had purchased a substitute to avoid service himself. The Gate City seethes with righteous indignation: "He would incite them to actions, would have them incur guilt, in which he will not be personally a participant." The paper also reports France will not recognize Confederate independence unless the South abolishes slavery within ten years, and publishes a fiery speech from an Indiana war veteran denouncing peace advocates as traitors.
Why It Matters
August 1864 was a pivotal moment in the Civil War. Lincoln faced re-election in November with War Democrats and Peace Democrats questioning whether continued fighting was worth the cost. The Confederacy, though weakened, still held Petersburg and hope for European recognition. The military draft had already sparked the horrific New York City riots in July; newspapers like the Chicago Times were stoking fears of similar violence. By printing this content, the Gate City was participating in a fierce propaganda battle over whether Americans should fight to total victory or negotiate peace. The paper's venom toward the Times reflects how newspapers didn't report neutrally—they were active combatants in the struggle for national opinion, especially in border states like Iowa where Copperhead sentiment was real.
Hidden Gems
- The Chicago Times editor had personally purchased a draft substitute for himself while publicly denouncing the draft as illegal—a hypocrisy the Gate City gleefully highlights as proof of his treachery.
- France's recognition of the Confederacy was explicitly conditional on slavery abolition within ten years, showing that by late summer 1864, even European powers understood slavery's central role in the conflict.
- The paper matter-of-factly reports that 'some of the colored boot-blacks in Washington make $10 a day'—a small detail suggesting Black entrepreneurship in the capital even during wartime.
- A boy named Charles Underwood, 'one of the most useful and promising boys' in Muscatine, was killed by a railroad train while trying to hold his aunt's frightened horses; he survived four hours after his shoulder was nearly torn off and his vital organs exposed.
- A 'copperhead distiller of Lyons' faces a monthly revenue tax of nearly thirty thousand dollars, revealing the financial drain of wartime taxation on civilian industries.
Fun Facts
- General Hancock mentioned here as withdrawing from his 'second expedition' to the James River—Hancock would become one of the war's most celebrated commanders and later the 1880 Democratic presidential nominee, nearly defeating Garfield.
- The paper quotes an Indiana veteran named J.H. Woodward, 'at one time Adjutant of an Indiana regiment,' delivering a brutal speech at a peace rally where he likens the audience to sinners at hell's gate. Woodward's obscene denunciation ('exterminate every d—d rebel') captures the raw anger of Union soldiers by summer 1864, a far cry from early war romanticism.
- This paper was published just 12 days after the New York draft riots that killed over 100 people—the Gate City's vicious editorial against the Chicago Times was written with fresh horror of civil insurrection in mind.
- The Weldon Railroad mentioned in multiple dispatches was one of Petersburg's last supply lines; control of this rail line would become pivotal in the final siege of Petersburg that led to Lee's surrender in April 1865.
- France's refusal to recognize the Confederacy without slavery abolition, printed here on August 24, effectively ended Southern hopes for foreign intervention—a quiet death knell buried in afternoon dispatches.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free