“Lincoln's Desperate Plea to Soldiers: 'This Great Contest' Is About Democracy Itself—Plus a Foiled Copperhead Coup”
What's on the Front Page
The Chicago Tribune's August 21, 1864 front page captures a nation deep in civil war's fourth year, with no clear end in sight. The paper leads with President Lincoln's address to the 164th Ohio Regiment—a stirring defense of why the Union must fight on, warning that "if our enemies succeed" the very form of free government is endangered. Meanwhile, Secretary Stanton reports mixed military news from Virginia: General Grant's 5th Corps repulsed Confederate Hill's forces near the Weldon Road, but estimates of Southern troop strength remain wildly uncertain (ranging from 15,000 to 70,000 near Richmond). Most intriguingly, the paper prints a detailed account of an unofficial peace mission to Jefferson Davis by Col. James and editor J.R. Gilmore, who sought negotiation but found the Confederate leadership absolutely uncompromising—accepting only independence. The Tribune uses this to blast "Copperheads and Northern traitors" demanding peace, arguing the Davis interview proves vigorous fighting is the only option. Locally, Lake County's Union Convention unanimously backed John F. Farnsworth for Congress and Charles H. Reed for State Attorney. The paper also trumpets its new eight-cylinder printing press, inviting patrons to tour on Wednesday and Saturday afternoons.
Why It Matters
August 1864 was a pivot point in the Civil War—seemingly endless bloodshed, political opposition mounting at home, and no victory in sight. Lincoln himself worried he'd lose reelection in November. This page captures the raw anxiety: peace feelers failing, military progress stalled, and internal dissent over the war's purpose simmering into actual conspiracy (the "Sons of Liberty" plot mentioned at the bottom). The Tribune, a Republican organ, was fighting a two-front battle—against the Confederacy abroad and against "Copperhead" Democrats at home who wanted immediate peace at any cost. Lincoln's speech reframes the war not as military conquest but as a defense of democracy itself—an argument that would define the Union cause for generations.
Hidden Gems
- The paper obliquely references a conspiracy plot by the 'Sons of Liberty' to seize Governor Morton, liberate Confederate prisoners, and spark a Northwest rebellion—and admits that prominent Democratic Congressmen like Voorhees and Joseph K. Edgerton, who had called for armed resistance to the Lincoln Administration, were involved in deliberations about it.
- Admiral Farragut's carefully diplomatic thank-you letter for his sword gift reveals the delicate politics even of military heroes: he claims he didn't receive the original presentation, had it relayed through Brigadier General Bower, and carefully avoids any partisan statement while praising those who 'appreciate' his service.
- The Weekly Tribune's subscription price just jumped to $2.50 per year (club rate $2.00)—the paper explicitly blames 'advances in white paper as well as in all material and labor,' documenting Civil War-era inflation hitting the publishing industry.
- A Dr. Brown from Liberty, Maine was convicted of poisoning drafted men to create medical exemptions for piles, charging $100 per exemption—a dark glimpse of draft-dodging schemes and corruption in the conscription system.
- The paper reports Pennsylvania coal miners demanding higher wages after months at only 14 cents per bushel while coal sold for 16 cents in Pittsburgh, showing labor unrest and profit-squeezing alongside the war effort.
Fun Facts
- J.R. Gilmore, mentioned here as the editor who traveled to Richmond seeking peace with Jefferson Davis, was actually a prolific author who later wrote under the pen name 'Edmund Kirke'—his accounts of this mission would become famous Civil War literature, yet this August day his hopes for negotiation lay in ruins.
- The Tribune's pride in its new eight-cylinder press represents cutting-edge technology for 1864—yet within a decade, faster rotary presses would make this machine obsolete, the same way newspapers themselves would eventually face competition Lincoln couldn't have imagined.
- Senator Wilson of Massachusetts is defending himself against the 'N.Y. Herald and other Copperhead prints'—Wilson would later become Vice President under Grant and a key Reconstruction figure, but in August 1864 he was still dodging accusations he was too soft on peace.
- The paper matter-of-factly reports that gold opened in New York at 261 and closed at 256 on Saturday—the wide fluctuation reflects wartime currency chaos and speculation; the greenback dollar, first issued in 1862, was considered so unstable that gold trading became a major financial indicator.
- Lake County's $200 bounty for veteran recruits represents the desperation of 1864 recruitment—Union states had begun offering increasingly massive bounties as volunteers dried up, leading to bounty-jumpers who'd enlist, collect cash, desert, and repeat in different towns.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free