“When Fish Skins Replaced Windows: Arctic Wisdom & Civil War Conscription in 1864 Portland”
What's on the Front Page
The Portland Daily Press of August 12, 1864, opens with a scholarly article on "The Inhabitants of Our Northern Waters," examining the marine life of Arctic and polar seas. The piece, drawn from Sir John Richardson's work on the Polar Regions, details the devastating impact of systematic whaling and seal hunting on northern ecosystems. It notes that formerly productive waters off Spitzbergen and Davis' Straits are being "fished out," forcing both marine animals and the Esquimaux peoples dependent on them to flee to remote Arctic refuges. The article compares fish species across polar regions—notably the absence of sturgeons in American Arctic rivers versus their abundance in Asian waters—and describes how natives preserve fish through freezing for winter sustenance. Beyond this scientific content, the page carries editorial commentary on "Gumption," a charming essay defining this indefinable quality as a sixth sense combining tact and common sense, illustrated through examples of people who comically mishandle simple tasks. The paper also reprints a soldier's letter from Sherman's army endorsing the military draft as necessary to preserve the Union, and reports on newspaper competition in New York between the Herald and the rebel-sympathizing World.
Why It Matters
This August 1864 edition arrives at a critical juncture in American history—three years into the Civil War, with Union victory still uncertain. The prominence given to a soldier's letter defending the draft reflects the genuine anxiety gripping the North about conscription and war-weariness. The Herald-World rivalry described shows how deeply the conflict had polarized even the press. Meanwhile, the lengthy Arctic natural history piece reveals Victorian-era American intellectual interests even amid national trauma: curiosity about distant lands, scientific taxonomy, and environmental change. The war itself lurks beneath even seemingly apolitical content—the Navy Department's call for sealed bids on materials (occupying much of the page) underscore the industrial mobilization sustaining Union military efforts. For Portland, Maine, a maritime hub, these naval procurement notices would have held direct economic significance.
Hidden Gems
- The Portland Daily Press costs $8.00 per year for daily delivery, or just three cents per single copy—yet the competing Maine State Press runs only once weekly at $2.50 per year, showing how the daily newspaper model was still nascent and premium-priced.
- A remarkable detail buried in the Arctic article: fish skins were so valuable to Arctic natives that they used burbot skins 'in place of glass for windows' on the Obi River in Siberia—demonstrating how scarcity drove ingenious substitution in frontier regions.
- The Navy Department's contract notice stipulates that 'twenty per centum will be withheld from the amount of bills until the contract shall have been completed'—an early form of retainage that remains standard in construction contracting 160 years later.
- The editorial on 'Gumption' includes the complaint that such people 'will bring you the sheep-shears to cut a piece of Florence silk, or a pair of embroidery scissors to cut a hemp rope'—specific enough to suggest the writer had witnessed these exact absurdities.
- Advertising rates reveal a precise hierarchy: special notices cost $1.75 per square for the first week, while business notices in reading columns fetch only 12 cents per line—suggesting classified/display advertising commanded far higher premiums than simple editorial plugs.
Fun Facts
- The article on Arctic marine life cites expeditions by Sir John Franklin and Sir Edward Parry—both of whom had vanished in Arctic exploration attempts just two decades earlier, making their scientific data a haunting legacy of polar exploration's human cost.
- The paper's discussion of sturgeon in Arctic rivers proves prescient: these fish would face near-extinction by the 20th century due to overfishing and dam construction, validating the 1864 warnings about systematic depletion of northern resources.
- The soldier's letter defending the draft was reprinted from the Boston Post—indicating that even wartime journalism operated through a national exchange network of reprinted content, creating de facto wire services before the telegraph fully unified American news.
- John T. Gilman, listed as editor, was a fixture of Portland journalism; the Press itself would survive until 1921, making it one of Maine's longest-running newspapers despite being born during the Civil War's darkest phase.
- The Navy Department's August 1864 call for sealed bids on materials reflects that the Union Navy was actively expanding—by war's end it would grow from 90 ships to nearly 700, making this routine procurement notice a artifact of the industrial transformation that won the war.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free