Friday
August 5, 1864
Burlington free press (Burlington, Vt.) — Chittenden, Burlington
“Atlanta Burns & British Meddlers: Why America Said 'No Thank You' to Peace—August 5, 1864”
Art Deco mural for August 5, 1864
Original newspaper scan from August 5, 1864
Original front page — Burlington free press (Burlington, Vt.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

As Union General William Tecumseh Sherman wages his brutal siege of Atlanta on this sweltering August day in 1864, the Burlington Free Press prints General John Bell Hood's official dispatch describing a massive two-corps Confederate counterattack that claimed to have captured artillery and hundreds of prisoners. Hood's report, transmitted through Richmond, describes Hardee's corps launching a night march to strike Sherman's left flank near Peachtree Creek, followed by Cheatham's assault on entrenchments—accounts the paper treats with skepticism, noting "the great fight before Atlanta was a drawn battle." But overshadowing even this pivotal battlefield engagement is a peculiar diplomatic crusade: a British delegation has petitioned Her Majesty's government to mediate peace between North and South, arguing that England, France, Belgium, and Spain should collectively pressure the Federal government to negotiate. Lord Palmerston's reply is withering—he warns that premature intervention would only "exasperate the North" and quotes an old couplet: "They who in quarrel's interpose, / Will often wipe a bloody nose." The paper's editors bristle at the suggestion that Vermont—"recognized as at the head and front of those who decline to treat with rebels in arms"—should entertain such terms.

Why It Matters

August 1864 marks a hinge moment in the Civil War. Sherman's Atlanta campaign is proving that the Union can strike deep into the Confederate heartland and hold ground—a demonstration that Northern victory, while costly, is becoming inevitable. Simultaneously, the war's grinding human toll has created a genuine "peace party" both in the North and internationally, with British abolitionists and industrial interests hoping to broker an end. This tension between military momentum and war-weariness defines the final year of the conflict. Meanwhile, Vermont—a stalwart Republican state—is being asked to raise fresh quotas of soldiers under a new conscription call for 500,000 men. The state's quota remains uncertain, but the machinery for recruiting and conscription is already grinding into motion.

Hidden Gems
  • Twenty substitute brokers are now operating in Burlington and have allegedly formed a 'perfect ring' to monopolize the conscription substitute market at extortionate prices—a glimpse into how Civil War conscription spawned a shadow economy that enriched middlemen while draining families' savings.
  • The Vermont Central Railroad Company and Burlington's town selectmen are negotiating the discontinuation of railroad service through the town, with the company offering to sell 1,000 cubic yards of bridge stone to the town for $3 per yard—a bizarre postwar infrastructure settlement that reveals how local development was tangled up with railroad monopolies.
  • The paper notes that Union recruiters are being assigned to work in rebel states, including one agent stationed in Nashville, Tennessee, who 'is familiar with that portion of the South having resided for years in Atlanta'—suggesting the North was already planning Reconstruction administration while the war still raged.
  • A note encourages residents to report any Burlington man who has served in the Navy during the war so the town can claim credit toward its military quota—revealing how towns competed for credit and how military service was parsed down to individual accounting.
  • The newspaper explicitly criticizes a recent Vermont State Convention resolution that suggested states had been 'absolved from the duty of allegiance,' calling the claim 'absurd' and noting the resolution was passed 'in a body' without members even understanding what they were voting on—a rare moment of press criticism of party proceedings during wartime.
Fun Facts
  • General John Bell Hood, whose dispatch dominates the battle coverage, was the same commander who would lose Atlanta to Sherman just days after this dispatch was filed—this August 22nd battle was actually his last major offensive, and he would spend the rest of the war in retreat and defeat.
  • The British peace delegation's argument that England should intervene echoes genuine geopolitical tensions: Britain's textile industry depended on Southern cotton, but Northern military victories in 1864 convinced the British government that the Union would win—ending any real prospect of European mediation. Lord Palmerston's skeptical response reflected hardening British conviction that neutrality was wiser than backing a losing cause.
  • Vermont's quota system and state credit for Navy service reveals how the Civil War was fought as a disaggregated effort—towns and states competed for recruitment numbers and credited themselves with soldiers' service, creating perverse incentives that the substitute broker 'rings' directly exploited.
  • The mention of recruiting agents working in rebel states like Tennessee in August 1864 shows that Union military planners were simultaneously planning how to govern the South even before Lee surrendered—Reconstruction was already being improvised in the midst of active combat.
  • The railroad negotiation about bridge stone and discontinuance reveals post-war infrastructure anxieties: the Vermont Central Railroad was already negotiating its withdrawal from Burlington, suggesting private corporations were abandoning unprofitable routes even as the war continued—a precursor to the railroad consolidations that would reshape the American economy in the 1870s and 1880s.
Contentious Civil War War Conflict Military Politics Federal Politics International Economy Labor
August 4, 1864 August 6, 1864

Also on August 5

View all 10 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free