Tuesday
August 2, 1864
The evening telegraph (Philadelphia [Pa.]) — Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
“The Crater: Inside the Failed Mining Assault That Nearly Broke the Union Army”
Art Deco mural for August 2, 1864
Original newspaper scan from August 2, 1864
Original front page — The evening telegraph (Philadelphia [Pa.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The front page is dominated by two major Civil War battles unfolding almost simultaneously on August 2, 1864. The first dispatch reports from the Army of the Potomac near Petersburg, Virginia, where Union forces executed an audacious mining operation at dawn—literally blowing up a Confederate fort by detonating gunpowder buried 500 feet underground. "A terric quaking of the earth, and a sudden beclouding of the atmosphere" preceded the assault, creating a crater that soldiers describe as horrifying: "fifty feet long" and filled with "twisted, dusty, and saturated" bodies, "heads of men protruding through the crevices in the earth." Despite initial success, the attack ultimately failed when Confederate reinforcements poured cannon and musket fire from multiple directions. Union forces retreated in disorder, with the 4th Division (colored troops) wavering under intense fire. Casualties were staggering—roughly 2,500 men by official count, though observers suspect the true number is higher. Meanwhile, the Army of the Potomac refused Confederate flags of truce, suggesting broader strategic tensions. Some believe Lee's lines are weaker than expected; others think the rebels are planning some "extensive move" and want to keep communications quiet.

Why It Matters

August 1864 was a critical moment for the Union. The war had dragged into its fourth grueling year, and Northern morale was fracturing—some feared Lincoln would lose the November election to a peace candidate. This "Crater" battle near Petersburg, part of Grant's grinding campaign to encircle and strangle the rebel capital at Richmond, symbolized both Union determination and the horrifying cost of attrition warfare. The failure to break through Confederate lines meant months more of siege, bloodshed, and political agony lay ahead. The deliberate refusal of Confederate flags of truce hints at escalating brutality and desperation on both sides. The presence of colored troops in combat was still relatively new and controversial in the North—their hesitation under fire would fuel bitter debate about Black soldiers' combat readiness, though officers blamed the tactical situation, not courage.

Hidden Gems
  • General Bartlett, commanding a brigade in the crater assault, was captured because his prosthetic leg—lost at Fort Hudson—broke during the fighting, leaving him unable to escape. The text notes this with stark matter-of-factness: 'rendered it impossible for this callant young general to move hence his capture.'
  • The text reveals a chilling retaliatory order from General Burbridge: 'for every Union citizen shot by guerillas two of the Rebel prisoners in our hands should be put to death.' This represents the war's descent into tit-for-tat executions, with the killing of someone named Poole mentioned as the spark.
  • The 4th Division of the 9th Corps consisted entirely of Black soldiers ('the 4th Division colored troops'). Officers repeatedly ordered them forward with escalating intensity—'Cheers on! Thus may linger further forward, again further! Order! Again urged to go forward by their officers; to which... both were altogether useless.' Their withdrawal under fire would become a flashpoint in debates over Black military service.
  • Union soldiers captured only 232 prisoners during the entire assault, with the highest rank being a Captain. The text notes this small haul sardonically—an indication of how few rebels were actually in the sector or how thoroughly disorganized the Union attack became.
  • A brief market report buried at the bottom shows wheat trading at Chicago prices, corn at $1.63, and various commodities in apparent shortage—reflecting the North's economy strained by four years of total war.
Fun Facts
  • The mining operation described here—the 'Dictator' mine near Petersburg—was one of the largest explosive charges detonated in warfare up to that point. Packed with 8,000 pounds of gunpowder, it created a crater 170 feet long, 60 feet wide, and 30 feet deep. No one had ever attempted anything quite like it before, making this battle a genuine technological experiment in a desperate war.
  • General Bartlett, whose prosthetic leg failed him during retreat, had lost the original leg as a 21-year-old captain at Fort Hudson in 1863. Despite his disability, he would survive the war and go on to command the Department of the East and help reorganize the postwar military. His capture and survival here represents the grim persistence required of officers on both sides.
  • The colored troops' hesitation to advance into the firestorm would become deeply controversial. Union officers blamed faulty tactics and overwhelming firepower; Northern newspapers and politicians blamed the soldiers themselves. This moment contributed to months of recrimination about Black soldiers' combat effectiveness—a debate that would haunt the Army until proper integration finally occurred in the 1950s.
  • The Confederate refusal of flags of truce suggests Lee was executing scorched-earth tactics. Just days later, Confederate cavalry under Jubal Early would raid Pennsylvania itself—the 'raid into Pennsylvania' mentioned in the dispatch. Lee was attempting a daring offensive while Grant hammered at Petersburg, a high-risk strategy born of desperation.
  • By August 1864, the Union Army had suffered roughly 90,000 casualties in Grant's Virginia campaign alone—more than Lee's entire army. The North was running low on manpower, which is partly why Black recruitment suddenly became urgent. This single failed battle near Petersburg cost more lives than entire campaigns just two years earlier.
Tragic Civil War War Conflict Military Civil Rights
August 1, 1864 August 3, 1864

Also on August 2

View all 11 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free