“"Dust and Bullets at Cold Harbor": A Vermont Soldier's Raw Account from the Siege of Richmond”
What's on the Front Page
The Green-Mountain Freeman's June 28, 1864 edition leads with a letter from "Anti Rebel," a Union soldier writing from near Cold Harbor on the James River Peninsula, just ten miles from Richmond. He describes the grinding reality of siege warfare: crouching behind breastworks while Confederate bullets whistle overhead, the peculiar sounds of different rifle rounds—some with a "sharp lit" like a whip crack, others with a screech "much like treading on a cat's tail." The soldier details the dust-choked conditions, the abatis (sharpened branches) meant to slow enemy charges, and the nightly digging that inches Union lines closer to the rebel fortifications. Interspersed with this frontline dispatch are casualty reports from Vermont regiments listing the killed and wounded by company—names like Joshua Felton of Company B, who died just one day after returning to the front, and dozens more with wounds listed as "severe" or "slight." A poem titled "The Return of the Bird" mourns springtime birds fleeing the war zone, their nests destroyed and orchards trampled by "half a million men." The page exemplifies how Vermont papers kept communities informed of their sons' fates in Grant's grinding campaign toward Richmond.
Why It Matters
This issue captures the brutal eastern theater of 1864, when General Ulysses S. Grant's Overland Campaign had brought the Army of the Potomac to the gates of Richmond after weeks of costly battles. Cold Harbor—where this letter originates—would soon become infamous as one of the war's bloodiest engagements, yet here we see the preceding siege conditions. For Vermont, this was deeply personal: the state had committed thousands of men to the Union cause, and papers like this one were lifelines for families desperate to know whether husbands, sons, and brothers had survived the latest fighting. The casualty lists were no abstraction—each name represented a household changed forever. This snapshot reveals how the Civil War had become a war of attrition by 1864, grinding forward through earthworks and dust rather than the grand cavalry charges of earlier campaigns.
Hidden Gems
- The soldier describes how dust coats everything so completely that 'a man may thread down his rubber blanket for a seat, and one puff of wind will cover it so completely with dust that it will be difficult to distinguish it from the ground around it'—captured trench warfare conditions so vividly that you can feel the grit.
- Among the casualty reports, Joshua Felton of Fairfax, Vermont is noted with a poignant detail: he had returned from the hospital determined to rejoin his regiment despite offers to stay in the safer rear, driven by 'a conviction of duty.' He lasted one day in the field before being killed instantly by a rifle ball.
- The subscription terms reveal class divisions: $1.50 if paid in advance, otherwise $2.00—roughly $25-33 in modern money. Rural postmasters received the Freeman free; everywhere else in Vermont cost 20 cents a year postage.
- The classified casualty lists distinguish between officers and enlisted men by rank, showing the hierarchical nature of Civil War record-keeping—Lieutenant Hiram C. Bailey appears separately from Private Joshua Felton.
- A soldier's complaint buried in the letter: one fellow 'almost swearing' that he couldn't write a love letter without it being 'smeared and defaced with slovenly looking blots of dirt'—a human detail of how impossible normal life had become in the trenches.
Fun Facts
- The poet mourning displaced birds invokes 'half a million men' on the Peninsula—this matches Grant's actual force strength in June 1864, suggesting local correspondents had reliable casualty and troop estimates from official sources.
- The letter references the Battle of Gaines' Hill from June 27, 1862 ('two years ago'), part of the Seven Days Battles when McClellan's campaign to take Richmond failed—Cold Harbor, two years later in 1864, would see even bloodier fighting under Grant's command, making this letter's tactical pessimism prescient.
- The soldier mentions 'City Point on the James River' as a supply hub—this obscure location would become Grant's main logistics base for the final Petersburg campaign, making it arguably the second most important Union position in Virginia by war's end.
- Anti Rebel's observation that the Second Vermont Regiment is assigned 'any rough, disagreeable duty' reflects that veteran regiments were often used as shock troops, wearing them down faster—the Second Vermont lost 600+ men by war's end, among the highest casualty rates of any Vermont unit.
- The poem's prayer that autumn's flowers will bloom 'ere our fathers and their strong-armed men / May lay their weapons by' captures the widespread belief in summer 1864 that victory was imminent—Lincoln nearly lost his re-election bid that fall, so uncertain was the outcome at this moment.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free