Thursday
June 2, 1864
Weekly national intelligencer (Washington [D.C.]) — District Of Columbia, Washington D.C.
“Does Lincoln Deserve Credit for Abolition? A Civil War-Era Debate That Still Divides Us”
Art Deco mural for June 2, 1864
Original newspaper scan from June 2, 1864
Original front page — Weekly national intelligencer (Washington [D.C.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Weekly National Intelligencer devotes its lead to a scathing critique of abolitionist firebrand Wendell Phillips, who recently gave a speech at Boston's Emancipation League anniversary questioning President Lincoln's commitment to freeing enslaved people. Phillips directly quoted a letter Lincoln allegedly wrote on April 4, 1864, to Kentucky politician James Hodges, claiming the President said: "I never did any thing for the negro on his own account. I never tried to help him... I never did any thing for him till I was forced to, and then I only used him." The paper's editors defend Lincoln vigorously, arguing that Phillips confuses moral philosophy with political duty—that a magistrate cannot regulate official conduct by "abstract notions of right or wrong" but must follow the law of the land. Meanwhile, Congress grapples with Washington D.C.'s voter registration charter amendment, with Senator Charles Sumner pushing hard to explicitly exclude race-based voting restrictions, while colleagues insist the moment for such measures isn't "practicable."

Why It Matters

In June 1864, America was two months from Lincoln's re-election and deep in the bloodiest phase of the Civil War. The Emancipation Proclamation of January 1863 had freed enslaved people in rebel states—but not enslaved people in Border States loyal to the Union. Radicals like Phillips wanted full abolition enshrined in law; moderates and Lincoln himself moved carefully, fearing Border State defection. This debate reveals the fracture within the anti-slavery movement itself. Some believed Lincoln insufficiently committed; others saw his caution as political necessity. By this date, the 13th Amendment (true national abolition) wouldn't pass Congress for another six months. The D.C. voting rights debate was similarly fraught: full Black male suffrage in the nation's capital remained years away. This paper captures a moment of acute tension between moral principle and political pragmatism.

Hidden Gems
  • The paper notes that Wendell Phillips faced zero censorship consequences for his blistering attack on Lincoln's motives, while opposition figure Clement Vallandigham had been *exiled* by military order for 'words much less derogatory'—a striking admission that free speech was being selectively enforced based on political loyalty.
  • A single-year subscription cost Two Dollars, but the paper offered bulk discounts: order 10 copies and save 20%; order 20+ and save 25%—showing how newspapers cultivated institutional subscribers (churches, civic groups) rather than relying purely on individual readers.
  • The congressional summary reveals Senator Sumner invoked General Grant's famous phrase 'fight it out on this line, if it takes all summer' during a debate about voting rights—a remarkable moment of Civil War military rhetoric being repurposed for Reconstruction politics.
  • Solomon Kohuatamin was sentenced to ten years in state prison for presenting false vouchers to the U.S. Government—a reminder that even amid total war, fraud prosecutions continued, and the machinery of federal accounting was detailed enough to catch it.
  • The House rejected a joint resolution for reciprocity with British North America by just two votes (74 yeas to 84 nays), showing how close the margin was on trade policy with Canada, a crucial non-combatant neighbor.
Fun Facts
  • Wendell Phillips, the abolitionist thundering against Lincoln on this page, was so formidable a speaker that he had already delivered over 2,000 lectures by 1864—a career that would stretch another 20+ years, making him arguably the most prolific orator in American history.
  • Charles Sumner, who fought for Black voting rights in D.C.'s charter debate, had been nearly beaten to death with a cane on the Senate floor in 1856 by South Carolina Representative Preston Brooks—a wound that still troubled him in 1864, yet he remained one of Congress's fiercest voices for racial equality.
  • The paper mentions Lincoln's April 4, 1864 letter to James Hodges of Kentucky, in which Lincoln explained his pragmatic approach to emancipation. Lincoln died less than a year later, and this letter would become a crucial historical document for understanding his actual views on slavery versus political necessity.
  • Senator Wade, defending the D.C. charter bill, would within a year co-author the Wade-Davis Bill proposing far harsher Reconstruction terms than Lincoln favored—a signal that radical Republicans were already splitting with the President over war's end.
  • The debate over whether to amend the charter to exclude no one 'on account of color' was still contentious enough that Congress tabled it until December—yet by 1867, Black men would gain the vote nationwide via the 14th Amendment, suggesting how rapidly political will shifted in just three years.
Contentious Civil War Politics Federal Civil Rights Legislation Election
June 1, 1864 June 3, 1864

Also on June 2

1846
Senate Erupts Over Oregon: Did America's Famous "54° 40' or Fight" Boundary...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1856
"Bleeding Kansas" & Colt Revolvers: What Worcester Merchants Were Selling in...
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1861
June 1861: Nashville Advertises Seeds and Cordials While the South Prepares for...
Nashville union and American (Nashville, Tenn.)
1862
Richmond Celebrates—While Betting on Washington in 3 Weeks | June 1862
Richmond Whig (Richmond, Va.)
1863
A Union Spy's Secret Report from Inside the Confederacy—What He Found Will...
The Portland daily press (Portland, Me.)
1865
1865: The Congressman Who Refused to Beg Lincoln for His Constituent's Freedom
The Bedford gazette (Bedford, Pa.)
1866
One Year After the War Ends, California Dreams of Railroads—and Auburn Grieves...
The Placer herald (Auburn, Placer County, Calif.)
1876
How Arizona's Boomtown Miners Shipped Gold by Stagecoach (120-Hour Journey...
Arizona weekly miner (Prescott, Ariz.)
1886
Federal Crackdown on Anti-Chinese Violence, and Why Cleveland's Marriage...
The Washington critic (Washington, D.C.)
1896
Rum, Ransoms & Gunboats: How Two Naval Commanders Saved a Country's Port in 30...
The Wichita daily eagle (Wichita, Kan.)
1906
1906: Lightning kills 5 at baseball game, melts silver dollar in victim's pocket
Macon beacon (Macon, Miss.)
1926
The 11-year-old hero, 31-pound monster fish, and America's last homesteaders
Grand Rapids herald-review (Grand Rapids, Itasca County, Minn)
1927
Springfield's Grand Makeover: Why This 1927 City Was Obsessed With First...
Springfield weekly Republican (Springfield, Mass.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free