Monday
May 9, 1864
The New York herald (New York [N.Y.]) — New York City, New York
“Victory! Grant Breaks Lee's Attack—And Won't Stop Pressing”
Art Deco mural for May 9, 1864
Original newspaper scan from May 9, 1864
Original front page — The New York herald (New York [N.Y.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The New York Herald announces a decisive Union victory in the Battle of the Wilderness. General Grant's Army of the Potomac has repelled a fierce Confederate assault led by General Robert E. Lee, forcing the rebel commander to withdraw after two days of brutal fighting (May 8-9, 1864). Secretary of War Edwin Stanton reports that between 6,000 and 8,000 Union soldiers have been wounded, with notable casualties including Brigadier General Alexander Hays, killed in action, and General Alexander S. Webb. Other commanders wounded include Generals Hancock, Getty, Gregg, Wadsworth, Bartlett, Carroll, and Owen. On the Confederate side, Generals Jones and Jenkins were killed, and Senator Hunter and General Pickett are reported dangerously wounded. The Herald presents this as a crucial turning point—Lee's anticipated knockout blow has failed, and Grant's army maintains the offensive, pursuing the retreating rebels. Concurrent dispatches report successful Union operations on the James River and Peninsula, including the capture of Fort Walthall and destruction of railroad connections between Petersburg and Richmond.

Why It Matters

May 1864 marked a turning point in the Civil War. Grant had been promoted to supreme commander of all Union armies just weeks earlier, and this battle—the first major engagement under his leadership—would define the war's trajectory. Lee's strategy of striking hard and fast to demoralize Northern commanders had worked before, but Grant refused to retreat. Instead, he wheeled left and kept pressing southward toward Richmond. This grinding campaign of attrition would ultimately break the Confederacy's back. The North's industrial capacity meant it could replace 8,000 casualties; the South could not. Grant's willingness to absorb enormous losses while maintaining pressure represented a new, brutal style of warfare that the Union could sustain but the Confederacy could not.

Hidden Gems
  • Secretary Stanton explicitly instructs the Herald's editor: 'You may give such publicity to the information transmitted to you as you deem proper...designed to give accurate official statements...and to withhold nothing from the public.' This represents an extraordinary transparency—a sitting Secretary of War essentially directing the press to publish military dispatches.
  • The dispatch mentions Brigadier General Alexander Hays's biography in granular detail: born 1822 in Pittsburgh, graduated West Point in 1844 ranking 20th in his class, fought at Palo Alto and Resaca de la Palma in the Mexican War, then left the Army in 1848 to become an iron manufacturer in Pennsylvania before raising the 63rd Pennsylvania Infantry when war broke out.
  • A single sentence reveals the chaos of the wounded evacuation: 'Three thousand of our wounded, whose injuries are slight, are to be cared for where they now are, while the others are to be brought to Washington.' This suggests a casualty count so massive that forward hospitals couldn't handle all 6,000-8,000 wounded.
  • The Herald cites information from 'Assistant Secretary of War Dana, who is stationed at the telegraphic post nearest to the battle field'—showing that high-ranking officials were positioned near combat zones to transmit real-time intelligence to Washington.
  • A cryptic reference appears: 'There are many things known to the government, all of a cheerful tendency, which it is not proper to state at this time'—a hint that General Butler's James River operations and other ongoing maneuvers were being kept secret from the public.
Fun Facts
  • Brigadier General Alexander Hays, killed in this battle, was a classmate of his corps commander General Hancock at West Point in 1844. They had graduated together and fought in Mexico together—only two decades later, Hays died defending Hancock's left flank during the most critical battle of the war.
  • The Herald reports that General Burnside forced-marched his troops 'a day and night' from Manassas to reinforce Grant by Thursday night—the newspaper claims this 'even surpassed his brilliant forced marches in East Tennessee.' Burnside would later lead the siege of Petersburg and eventually command occupation forces in the South.
  • The newspaper repeatedly notes that Grant has not yet communicated directly with Washington, observing: 'It is not his habit to communicate anything until definite results have been attained.' This reflected Grant's emerging reputation for taciturn determination—he would hold this characteristic throughout his presidency.
  • The War Department had already prepared accommodations for 10,000 wounded before this battle concluded, demonstrating that Lincoln's government expected catastrophic losses as standard. The 8,000 casualties in two days represented perhaps 20% of Grant's force—a staggering attrition rate.
  • General Lee's retreat toward Richmond lines showed he had abandoned his strategy of defending through aggressive offense. The Herald speculates he's 'hastening to the works of Richmond, not only to save the remnant of his own army, but to rescue, if possible, the rebel capital from falling into the hands of that dreaded chieftain, General Butler'—a prescient observation.
Triumphant Civil War War Conflict Military Politics Federal
May 7, 1864 May 10, 1864

Also on May 9

1836
A Virginia Town in 1836: Progress, Profits, and the Price of Enslaved People
Lynchburg Virginian (Lynchburg [Va.])
1846
Gunpowder, Havana Sweetmeats & Political Censorship: Inside Frontier Arkansas...
Arkansas intelligencer (Van Buren, Ark.)
1856
May 1856: What Evansville's Grocery Bills Reveal About Civil War America
The Evansville daily journal (Evansville, Ia. [i.e. Ind.])
1861
New Orleans Goes to War: A City Drills While Business Continues (May 9, 1861)
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1862
A Methodist Preacher-Turned-Guerrilla and 57 Burned Locomotives: War in the...
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1863
May 1863: Vicksburg Braces for Grant While the South's Cracks Begin to Show
Memphis daily appeal (Memphis, Tenn.)
1865
May 1865: Inside Robert E. Lee's Seized Mansion, Now a Union Cemetery
The Portland daily press (Portland, Me.)
1866
One Year After Appomattox: How New Orleans Voted Its Way Back—and Bet on Oil
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1876
A Stubborn Husband Gets His Comeuppance: Oxford Democrat, 1876
Oxford Democrat (Paris, Me.)
1886
How Gladstone's Irish Home Rule Collapse Shattered British Politics (And Why It...
The sun (New York [N.Y.])
1896
Death Sentences for Americans in Havana, Britain in Turmoil Over Rhodes—May 9,...
Waterbury Democrat (Waterbury, Conn.)
1906
1906: When the 'Ice King' built palaces and Maine rivers claimed two young lives
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1926
When Russian workers sent £350,000 to British strikers (and other tales from...
The daily worker (Chicago, Ill.;New York, N.Y.)
1927
Missing Over the Atlantic: The Flight That Vanished Just Before Lindbergh's...
The Montgomery advertiser (Montgomery, Ala.)
View all 14 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free