Thursday
May 5, 1864
New-York daily tribune (New-York [N.Y.]) — New York City, New York
“Abandoned: 40,000 Union Loyalists Left to the Confederacy as North Carolina Falls Apart”
Art Deco mural for May 5, 1864
Original newspaper scan from May 5, 1864
Original front page — New-York daily tribune (New-York [N.Y.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The New-York Daily Tribune leads with devastating news from North Carolina: General Butler has ordered the evacuation of Washington, North Carolina—a heavily fortified position that took two years and enormous sums to build. The retreat abandons over 40,000 loyal Union citizens, both Black and white, to Confederate forces who are already massacring those who accepted Lincoln's amnesty. The capture of Plymouth and evacuation of Washington has rendered thousands of Union sympathizers homeless, forcing them to flee to Newbern and Beaufort with nothing. Adding urgency to the crisis: the families of 1,000 women and children from the 3rd and 16th North Carolina Volunteer regiments are now destitute, and soldiers of the 28th North Carolina haven't received a single dollar of pay or bounty. The paper also reports on Major General Butler's reforms in Norfolk, where he's made the Provost Marshal's office self-sufficient, selling confiscated property to raise over $100,000 and installing gas lighting at a cost of £5,000. Prisoners are being dressed in "Butler's Zouaves" uniforms and put to work paving streets.

Why It Matters

By May 1864, the Civil War had reached a critical juncture. General Ulysses S. Grant had just launched the Overland Campaign in Virginia, making every Union move in the South strategically consequential. The evacuation of Washington, North Carolina—though militarily practical—represented a bitter blow to the Union's claim to be liberating the South. The abandonment of 40,000 loyal citizens undercut Lincoln's entire narrative about restoring the Union and protecting those who embraced emancipation. Meanwhile, the chaos around soldier pay and refugee relief exposed the Union's administrative fragility even as it claimed moral superiority. General Butler's aggressive military governance in Norfolk, with its gas lighting and prisoner labor reforms, previewed the kind of martial authority that would define Reconstruction.

Hidden Gems
  • The paper reports that 'Butler's Zouaves'—prisoners in red-banded caps—are now performing street labor in Norfolk, and that 'their former comrades call them' by this name. This suggests even Confederate prisoners were being reintegrated into Union-controlled cities as a labor force by mid-1864.
  • A mayor of Norfolk attempted to defy Colonel Wheldon's tenant protection order by filing eviction writs, but was told: 'Served you right; it's a wonder he didn't lock you up as it was.' Military rule had completely superseded civil authority.
  • Norfolk's two hotels were 'crowded' and 'their proprietors must be growing rich fast'—even during wartime, entrepreneurs were profiting from the presence of officers and soldiers.
  • The Richmond Examiner's lengthy editorial argues that one good infantryman is 'worth a dozen, or a hundred, or a thousand' of the remaining Confederate cavalry, and warns that 'half the horses now on the meadows are so enfeebled that they must of necessity die.' Confederate logistics were already collapsing by spring 1864.
  • The price list from Georgia shows inflation so severe that a pound of butter cost $10, a pound of meat $4, and a quart of milk $2—gold traded at $30 for $1, revealing the Confederacy's financial catastrophe.
Fun Facts
  • General Benjamin Butler, mentioned repeatedly here for his reforms in Norfolk, would become one of the most controversial figures of Reconstruction. His 'Woman Order' in New Orleans (treating disrespectful women as prostitutes) made him infamous across the South, yet here he's presented as an efficient administrator building gas works and feeding the poor.
  • The paper lists elected members of the Confederate Congress—40 new members and 57 returning. Within a year, Congress would be meeting in a shrinking territory as Sherman marched through Georgia and Grant closed in on Richmond. Several of these representatives would be refugees or prisoners within months.
  • Colonel Wheldon, the Provost Marshal praised here for protecting tenants and standing up to the mayor, represents the militarization of civil governance that would intensify dramatically during Reconstruction—a preview of the military districts that would govern the South from 1867-1877.
  • The article mentions 130 female Treasury Department clerks being relocated from Richmond to Columbia, South Carolina to save money on living expenses. By December 1864, Sherman would burn Columbia to the ground, likely displacing these very women again.
  • The complaint about excess Confederate cavalry eating forage faster than infantry—'a district of country suffers less from the march through it of a brigade of Yankee infantry than a battalion of Confederate cavalry'—foreshadowed the total logistical collapse the South would face within a year.
Tragic Civil War War Conflict Military Civil Rights Politics Federal Economy Banking
May 4, 1864 May 6, 1864

Also on May 5

1836
Insuring the Future: How America's First Insurance Boom Revealed the Optimism...
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1846
Portsmouth's 1846 Health Board Just Invented Modern Quarantine (and Made Some...
The New Hampshire gazette (Portsmouth [N.H.])
1856
A Capital in Chaos: How Washington's Real Estate Boom Masked a Nation Tearing...
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1861
Nashville on the Brink: The Last Ordinary Newspaper Before Tennessee Seceded...
Nashville union and American (Nashville, Tenn.)
1862
Victory in the Shenandoah: Union Soldiers Report Rebels Fleeing Virginia (May...
Daily intelligencer (Wheeling, Va. [W. Va.])
1863
London Laughs at Lincoln's War—And British Ships Are Smuggling Quinine to the...
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1865
The Day They Buried Lincoln: A Nation Mourns and Rebuilds
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1866
Congress Rewrites America's Constitution—And a Poker Thief Gets Caught...
The Shasta courier (Shasta, Calif.)
1876
A Desert Outpost Publishes the Law of the Land—And We See What Life Cost to Get...
Arizona weekly miner (Prescott, Ariz.)
1886
Nebraska's Last Days Before the Eight-Hour Labor Revolt—May 5, 1886
Stjernen (St. Paul, Howard County, Nebraska)
1906
1906: When Big Meat Tried to Bribe Its Way Out of the Diseased Beef Scandal
The labor world (Duluth, Minn.)
1926
1926: Britain Burns While Explorers Race to the North Pole
The Washington daily news (Washington, D.C.)
1927
Death Watch in Massachusetts: As Sacco & Vanzetti's Fate Looms, Gov. Fuller...
Springfield weekly Republican (Springfield, Mass.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free