Tuesday
February 9, 1864
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.]) — Massachusetts, Worcester
“Postmaster Confesses to Bank Murder: How Detectives Caught Him Red-Handed with $70 Still in His Pocket”
Art Deco mural for February 9, 1864
Original newspaper scan from February 9, 1864
Original front page — Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Worcester Daily Spy leads with a sensational murder confession that has gripped Massachusetts. Edward W. Green, the postmaster of Malden, has been arrested and has fully confessed to the December 15th murder of Frank E. Converse, a young assistant cashier at the Malden Bank. Green shot Converse twice in the head with a Smith & Wesson revolver—once behind the ear, once in the temple—and stole approximately $4,000 from the bank. The breakthrough came when detectives noticed Green's suspicious indifference during the town's investigation, then tracked his suspicious spending: he paid off a seven-hundred-dollar debt using Malden Bank bills just weeks after the murder. Upon arrest, police recovered $615 hidden in an old boot in the post office and $3,454 stashed beneath the floorboards of the Volunteer Engine House. Green, just 27 years old with a wife and infant child, confessed calmly but later broke down in his cell. He claimed his sole motive was debt relief—a chilling reminder that desperation can drive ordinary men to extraordinary crimes.

Why It Matters

This 1864 murder case arrived at a pivotal moment in American history. While Worcester readers absorbed the Malden Bank murder, the nation was locked in the final year of the Civil War—Lincoln's re-election was still months away, and the outcome of the conflict remained uncertain. The paper's second major story features Senator Charles Sumner's sweeping resolutions explicitly linking slavery and rebellion as inseparable evils, arguing that crushing the Confederacy required crushing slavery itself. This wasn't abstract—it was the fierce political debate raging as the war neared its turning point. Against this backdrop of national convulsion and moral reckoning, the pedestrian tragedy of a small-town postmaster murdering for money highlights the private desperation that persisted even in the North.

Hidden Gems
  • Green was searched immediately upon arrest and found carrying $70 in Malden Bank bills in his hand—money he was literally still holding when confronted with his crime, suggesting he hadn't even begun to hide or spend it yet.
  • The autopsy of young Converse's head, performed after his funeral, recovered both pistol balls lodged in his skull—a crucial detail that corroborated Green's confession that he fired twice, since no bullets were found in the banking room itself.
  • Green's wife's response to his arrest is described as 'of the most heart rending description'—but the paper offers no further detail about what became of her or their three-month-old infant after the postmaster was committed to the Tombs prison.
  • Green purchased the murder weapon just ten days before the crime at 'the store of Mr. Reed in Boston,' suggesting premeditation, yet he maintained 'the utmost coolness of manner' during his arrest—only breaking down the following morning in his cell.
  • The newspaper gives no detail about Converse's funeral or how the community mourned him, focusing instead entirely on the criminal investigation and Green's confession—a stark contrast to modern true crime coverage.
Fun Facts
  • Edward W. Green was 'scarcely over five feet and an inch or two in height'—making him diminutive even by 1860s standards, yet he succeeded in overpowering or surprising a young bank employee in broad daylight with calculated violence, suggesting desperation can override any physical disadvantage.
  • The Worcester Daily Spy itself was established in July 1770—making it 94 years old when it published this story, one of America's longest-running newspapers, and it would survive another 150+ years before finally ceasing publication.
  • Detective Calder was assigned to follow Green for 'three or four weeks,' tracking his movements, his spending patterns, and the denominations of money he spent—an early example of what we'd now call financial forensics, more than a century before credit cards made such tracking routine.
  • Green reloaded his pistol immediately after committing the double murder and threw the remaining ammunition into a creek near his office, then set it in a bureau drawer fully loaded and capped—suggesting he contemplated further violence or escape.
  • Senator Sumner's resolutions on slavery, printed on the same front page, use strikingly modern rhetoric: calling slavery 'a huge impersonation of crime' and arguing the rebellion 'cannot be crushed without crushing slavery'—language that would influence the 13th Amendment passed that December.
Sensational Civil War Crime Violent Crime Trial Politics Federal Economy Banking
February 8, 1864 February 12, 1864

Also on February 9

1836
How a Gardener Became a Diplomat: Webster Reveals Congress's Chaotic Final Days
State journal (Montpelier, Vt.)
1846
Stephen Douglas Declassifies 28-Year-Old Diplomacy to Prevent War With Britain...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1856
While Kansas Burned: Inside the U.S. Government's Boilerplate Bureaucracy on...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1861
Inside Louisiana's Secret Courtroom Crisis: How One State Tried to Steal the...
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1862
A Fake Doctor Charged $100 (in 1862!) — Inside Civil War New York's Con Artists...
Sunday dispatch (New York [N.Y.])
1863
Arrested & Deported in 30 Minutes: How Civil War Chicago Dealt With Dissenters
Chicago daily tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1865
Feb 9, 1865: 'Peace bubble has burst!' — Lincoln's re-election confirmed as war...
The daily Gate City (Keokuk, Iowa)
1866
One Year After the War: Congress Opens Southern Land to All—And a Colored...
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1876
44% Returns Promised & Fresh Oysters for 43¢: Life in 1876 Augusta
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1886
Cotillions & Courtroom Drama: How Washington Fought Back Against Bell Telephone...
The Washington critic (Washington, D.C.)
1896
A Missouri Democrat Admits His Party Is Doomed (And Gets Booed for It)
The Wichita daily eagle (Wichita, Kan.)
1906
When 400,000 miners threatened America's fuel supply & cattle barons ruled the...
The Oregon mist (St. Helens, Columbia County, Or.)
1926
1926: Ponzi Vanishes Again, Tennis Queens Clash, and Diplomats Trade Insults
The Cordele dispatch and daily sentinel (Cordele, Georgia)
1927
Railroad Stocks Crash 40% in One Day—And a 23-Year-Old Just Made History in...
Brownsville herald (Brownsville, Tex.)
View all 14 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free