Monday
January 25, 1864
The Portland daily press (Portland, Me.) — Maine, Cumberland
“2,000 Dead in Chile, Blocked From Rescue: The Eyewitness Letter That Shattered a Nation's Faith”
Art Deco mural for January 25, 1864
Original newspaper scan from January 25, 1864
Original front page — The Portland daily press (Portland, Me.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Portland Daily Press leads with a harrowing account of a catastrophic church fire in Santiago, Chile that killed over 2,000 people—but the real story is the tragedy compounded by incompetence and callousness. A letter from an eyewitness describes how Chilean police actively *prevented* foreign residents from mounting rescue efforts, beating back would-be heroes with bayonets and gun butts. One man, Mr. Demilow, was bayoneted while trying to drag a young woman named Miss Barren through flames using a cane. Others, including Charles (the letter writer's brother) and Mr. Meigges, managed to slip past police lines and saved dozens—but the time lost to police obstruction proved fatal for countless others. The most sickening details emerge from the aftermath: Chilean laborers tasked with removing bodies treated the dead with grotesque indifference, literally tearing limbs apart with crowbars and joking as they shoveled fragmented corpses into carts like "gravel into a railway car." The disaster has shattered public faith in the Catholic Church and sparked demands for sweeping reforms—wider church doors, no locked exits during services, and a complete government inspection of all religious buildings.

Why It Matters

In 1864, America was mid-Civil War, but the world watched closely. This Chilean tragedy resonated in Portland because it highlighted the broader conflict between individual agency and state authority—a theme eerily relevant as Union forces fought for human freedom at home. The letter's emphasis on foreign nationals (likely British, American, and European expats) being thwarted by an authoritarian police state subtly reinforced American democratic values. The church's culpability and the subsequent loss of Catholic authority in Chile also offered a cautionary tale about institutional failure—relevant to 19th-century debates over religion's role in civil society. The eyewitness account published here gave Portlanders a visceral window into how governance failures abroad could mirror or contradict their own nation's struggles with justice and accountability.

Hidden Gems
  • The newspaper's subscription rate was $7.00 per year 'in advance'—roughly $130 in today's money—with single copies costing three cents. The Maine State Press, a companion publication, cost just $2.00 annually, suggesting a deliberate tiered pricing strategy for different economic classes.
  • Dr. W. W. Devring, a 'Medical Electrician,' advertised that any patient who wasn't cured by his treatments would receive 'the second time for nothing'—an extraordinarily bold guarantee for 1864. He claimed to cure everything from consumption to female complaints to mercury poisoning using electrical therapy, reflecting the era's dazzling pseudoscience.
  • Berry's Hair Renovator ad explicitly claimed to restore gray hair to 'natural color' without using 'silver and other injurious chemicals'—a tacit admission that competitors were literally using heavy metals on customers' heads. The product cost $1 per bottle ($19 today).
  • An 'Insolvency Notice' for the estate of Edward H. Jack of Westbrook allowed creditors six months from September 15, 1863 to file claims, with commissioners meeting in Portland on the 'second and last Saturdays' of each month—a reminder that bankruptcy proceedings moved glacially even in the 1860s.
  • Rev. E. H. Chapin's sermon against profane swearing notes that gentlemen 'restrain their oaths in the presence of ladies'—implying it was socially acceptable (even expected) for men to swear freely among themselves, revealing rigid gender norms of the era.
Fun Facts
  • The eyewitness letter mentions that Santiago's fire department possessed only 'two or three old wooden pumps'—a stark contrast to Portland's own fire companies, which were already transitioning to steam-powered engines. This infrastructure gap explained why a modern city couldn't stop the catastrophe.
  • Colonel Robert G. Shaw, mentioned in the paper as a fallen hero of Charleston who 'led his colored soldiers' in battle, became one of the Civil War's most celebrated martyrs. When Confederates allegedly buried him with his Black troops, they meant it as an insult—but Shaw's Northern allies reframed it as an epitaph of honor. The 54th Massachusetts Infantry Regiment became legendary.
  • Dr. W. W. Devring's claim to cure 'St. Vitus' Dance' (a neurological disorder also called Sydenham's chorea) using electricity preceded modern understanding of neurology by decades. He was practicing what we'd now call pseudoscience, yet he explicitly marketed himself as 'a regular graduated physician'—suggesting medical credentials carried less weight than entrepreneurial audacity in 1864.
  • The Portland Daily Press's masthead lists John T. Gilman as Editor and A. Foster & Co. as publishers. By this point in the Civil War, Northern newspapers were crucial propaganda tools; this modest Maine organ had real political weight in shaping regional opinion.
  • The rental notice and advertisements suggest Portland was experiencing genuine commercial growth in 1864—mid-war prosperity driven by military contracts, shipbuilding, and trade. Unlike the devastated South, the North's economy was actually booming, which subsidized the Union's ability to wage total war.
Tragic Civil War Disaster Fire Politics International Religion Public Health
January 24, 1864 January 26, 1864

Also on January 25

1836
How Washington Bought Uniforms, Built Canals, and Bought People: The...
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1846
How a Whisper Campaign Destroyed a Jewish Editor's Career in 1846 New York
Sunday dispatch (New York [N.Y.])
1856
Shipping Lines to the Future: Inside Antebellum New Orleans' $1 Billion...
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1861
A Vain Choir Tenor, a Dairy Girl's Right Hook, and the Day a Parish Fell Apart...
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1862
A Gold Rush Town Debates Slavery: Auburn's Brutal Choice, January 1862
The Placer herald (Auburn, Placer County, Calif.)
1863
FORT HINDMAN FALLS: Union Army-Navy Triumph Opens Path to Reclaim the...
The New York herald (New York [N.Y.])
1865
The theater ads that survived Lincoln's assassination—Washington, 1865
Evening star (Washington, D.C.)
1866
Congress Decides Freedom's Fate: The Freedmen's Bureau Fight Begins, 1866
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1876
1876: When Congress Fired a One-Handed Civil War Vet, and Grandpa's Brutal...
Oxford Democrat (Paris, Me.)
1886
Lee's Own Words on Virginia (and Why a Publishing Millionaire Died in a...
Savannah morning news (Savannah)
1906
When Nebraska Fined Deer Hunters $100 and Alice Roosevelt Started a Kimono Craze
The Loup City northwestern (Loup City, Neb.)
1926
When a chiropractor confessed to dismembering a milliner (and other tales from...
New Britain herald (New Britain, Conn.)
1927
Why Coolidge Said 'No' to China—And Why He'd Be Proven Wrong in 24 Months
Evening star (Washington, D.C.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free