“"Profiteers and Starvation: November 1863's Moral Reckoning"—When War Greed Met Confederate Collapse”
What's on the Front Page
On this November morning in 1863, Portland's newspaper wrestles with a stark moral crisis: while the Civil War rages on, war profiteers are making fortunes—one merchant reportedly pocketing a million dollars in a single year—yet these same wealthy men refuse to enlist or encourage recruitment. The Boston Transcript, quoted prominently, sounds an alarm: "Those who draw the great prizes are a limited number; those who wish to draw them are an unlimited number," warning that unchecked greed will destroy the nation's will to fight. Meanwhile, dispatches from Eastern Virginia paint a horrifying picture of Confederate destitution. General Ewell returned six pounds of sugar sent by a desperate woman, saying he couldn't accept supplies when families were starving. Lee's army survives on dry crackers alone. One plantation has only a peck of meal for an entire household, including a dying son. The paper notes grimly that Confederate suffering has intensified since Union forces captured Chattanooga and Knoxville, cutting off Southern supply lines—and winter approaches.
Why It Matters
November 1863 marks a pivotal moment in the Civil War's moral reckoning. The Union had just won at Gettysburg and Vicksburg months earlier, yet three years into the conflict, Northern will was flagging and economic inequality threatened to fracture support for the war effort. This page captures the deep anxiety among patriotic editors that capitalism was corroding patriotism—that young men would dodge the draft to chase war profits rather than save the nation. Meanwhile, the South faced physical collapse: starving civilians, depleted supply lines, and a grinding resource crisis that would intensify over the winter. These competing crises—Northern moral exhaustion and Southern material collapse—would define the final eighteen months of the war.
Hidden Gems
- The U.S. Navy was actively recruiting 1,000 seamen directly from the newspaper's office at the foot of Exchange Street, suggesting chronic manpower shortages even in the Navy by late 1863—a sign of how the war was consuming the nation's eligible men.
- A Vermont farmer demanded an orphan boy who was 'active, brave, tractable, prompt, industrious, clean, pious, intelligent, goodlooking, reserved and modest'—and the asylum's superintendent sardonically replied their boys 'were all human, though they were orphans, and referred him to the New Jerusalem.' A delightful example of mid-war dry humor amid real social stress.
- Palmer's Artificial Leg advertisement boasts it was 'worn by upwards of six thousand persons' and notes that 'soldiers of all the New England States' were being supplied 'without charge.' By 1863, amputation was so common that prosthetics had become a thriving business and government responsibility.
- A new dry goods store at 81 Middle Street advertises goods 'bought for NETT CASH, and must be sold for NETT CASH, thereby enabling us to Sell as Low AS ANY HOUSE IN THE UNITED STATES.' The emphasis on cash-only retail reflects the widespread credit crisis and tight wartime liquidity.
- Gen. Schofield's proposal to enlist enslaved Black men in Missouri 'whose masters receive receipts...which may be made the basis of a claim against the Government' reveals how late 1863 debates about Black recruitment still centered on compensating slaveholders rather than liberating people.
Fun Facts
- The editorial about profiteering foreshadows a century of American debate over war profiteering—from World War II's investigation of munitions makers to the post-2001 scrutiny of defense contractors. The outrage printed here in Portland would echo for generations.
- General Ewell's refusal of six pounds of sugar from a starving woman is a footnote to one of history's greatest ironies: Richard Ewell was a brilliant Confederate corps commander whose chivalry in small moments contrasted sharply with the industrial slaughter he orchestrated in battles. He'd survive the war and die in 1872.
- The Portland Daily Press subscription rate of $3.00 per year—roughly $65 in today's money—was steep enough that only literate, relatively affluent citizens could afford daily news. This paper's editorial voice against war profiteering reached only a thin slice of Portland's population.
- Palmer's Artificial Leg advertisement of 'upwards of six thousand' users by November 1863 is staggering when you consider the war still had 18 months to run. By Appomattox, that number would swell—contributing to the estimated 60,000 amputees the war would create.
- The college advertisement for 'Bryant, Stratton & Co.'s Chain of Commercial Colleges' shows the North investing in education and business training even as young men were dying on battlefields—a sign that Northern society was hedging its bets, preparing for a post-war commercial boom regardless of the war's outcome.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free