“When War Democrats Turned on Peace Democrats: A Springfield Rally Changes Illinois Politics, September 1863”
What's on the Front Page
The Canton Weekly Register's September 21, 1863 edition is dominated by coverage of a massive Union rally held in Springfield, Illinois, featuring rousing speeches from Colonel John Dougherty and General Isaac N. Haynie. These Democratic leaders mounted a passionate defense of President Lincoln and the war effort, denouncing "Copperheads"—Northern Democrats opposing the war—as traitors worse than the rebels themselves. Col. Dougherty spent nearly an hour excoriating the recent Illinois Legislature for attempting to send "ministers plenipotentiary" to negotiate with rebellious states, calling them "a God defying, Constitution violating set of scoundrels." He gave full-throated endorsement of Lincoln's Emancipation Proclamation, though he criticized it for being "too merciful." Gen. Haynie emphasized that Lincoln's election was legitimate and binding—even those who opposed him must accept the people's will. The speeches reveal a crucial moment when War Democrats were publicly breaking ranks with peace Democrats, rallying behind Lincoln to preserve the Union.
Why It Matters
September 1863 was a turning point in Northern politics. While Union armies had won at Gettysburg and Vicksburg just two months earlier, war-weariness was setting in. The Copperhead movement was gaining traction, especially in the Midwest, and the 1864 election loomed as a referendum on continuing the conflict. These Springfield speeches represent the pro-war Democratic establishment fighting back against their own party's peace faction. This internal Democratic civil war would define the election year ahead and shape whether Lincoln could maintain the political coalition needed to finish the war and abolish slavery.
Hidden Gems
- The Register cost $1.50 per year if paid in advance, but jumped to $2.50 if you waited until the end of the year—a 67% penalty for late payment, suggesting serious cash flow problems for rural papers during wartime.
- An ad for the "People's Cheap Store" appears four times on the front page alone, hawking Balmoral hoops, embroidered curtains at 25 cents per yard, and the latest "Dress Goods, Clothing and Shawls...at New York prices"—suggesting Canton merchants were aggressively competing with urban retailers even during the Civil War.
- Col. Dougherty references a "copperhead concern" that assembled in Canton on June 17, 1863, and passed resolutions against "further offensive prosecution of this war"—documenting that anti-war organizing was happening right in this small Illinois county seat.
- Perry R. Crosswell, a member of Co. D, First Iowa Cavalry stationed in Arkansas, sent the newspaper a deed he'd found lying loose around the Jonesboro courthouse, demonstrating how Civil War soldiers were scattered across distant theaters and maintaining connections to their home counties.
- The paper mentions a severe windstorm that "took every sail off of the pump windmill at the Depot," showing how vulnerable frontier infrastructure was to weather—these windmills were critical for watering horses and serving the railroad.
Fun Facts
- Col. Dougherty invoked Andrew Jackson's 1833 Nullification Crisis as his model for patriotic unity—Jackson had threatened to hang South Carolina secessionists, and Dougherty was essentially arguing Lincoln should be equally ruthless. Jackson's willingness to use federal force against a rebellious state became the Democratic playbook for war supporters in 1863.
- Gen. Haynie's admission that he "opposed Lincoln and spoke many times against him" before the 1861 election, but now supported him fully, represents the dramatic political realignment happening in real time—this wasn't written hindsight, but a living politician confessing his changed mind to a crowd.
- The paper's billing of itself as "A Family Paper—Devoted to politics, News, markets, Education; the Agricultural, mechanical and mercantile Interests, Internal Improvements, &c" shows how newspapers positioned themselves as comprehensive community institutions, not just political organs—yet this edition is almost entirely devoted to one political speech.
- Dougherty's casual mention that some copperheads' newfound wealth 'came from the French and British Governments' reflects genuine Northern paranoia about foreign intervention supporting the rebellion—a fear that shaped Union diplomacy throughout the war.
- The Register was published from the third story of Ball's Building at the northeast corner of the public square—suggesting even small-town Illinois newspapers occupied prime downtown real estate, indicating they were prestigious civic institutions worth investing in prime locations.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free