“Harvard's President Was Born in a Farmhouse—And His Mom's Genealogy Was Wrong for 90 Years”
What's on the Front Page
The Willimantic Journal's August 21, 1863 edition is dominated by a sprawling genealogical history of the Bingham family of Windham, Connecticut—a detailed tracing of bloodlines, marriages, and descendants stretching back generations. The article meticulously documents family branches, including notable figures like Deacon Elijah Bingham, whose three sons were famously treed by a bear cub and its protective mother in New Hampshire for 15 hours until the deacon arrived and killed the animal with his broad axe. But the most prominent genealogical entry concerns Joseph Bingham Jr., whose daughter Jerusha married the legendary Reverend Samuel Kirtland, the celebrated missionary to the Oneida Indians. Jerusha's story is particularly dramatic: she gave birth to twin sons—John Thornton and George Whitfield Kirtland—at General Herkimer's residence in 1770 while traveling to visit her mother, then returned to her husband's dangerous wilderness mission. One son, John Thornton, became President of Harvard College. The page also includes a reflective essay titled 'Summering: Enjoying Ourselves,' a philosophical defense of leisure time in an age of relentless productivity, complete with a vivid fishing expedition narrative.
Why It Matters
Published in August 1863, midway through the Civil War, this local Connecticut newspaper reveals how communities maintained cultural continuity and historical memory even as the nation tore itself apart. Genealogical publishing was serious business in 19th-century America—these detailed family records served as property documentation, inheritance proof, and community identity markers. The emphasis on New England's founding families and their connections to institutions like Dartmouth College and Harvard reflected the region's self-conscious role as keeper of American intellectual and moral authority. The inclusion of missionary narratives and Indian relations (the Kirtland-Oneida connection) shows how even small-town papers engaged with America's broader colonial legacy and Indian removal policies.
Hidden Gems
- Jerusha Bingham Kirtland was the niece of Dr. Eleazar Wheelock, founder and first President of Dartmouth College—meaning one of America's most prestigious universities began with her uncle's vision. The genealogy documents how tightly woven elite colonial family networks were.
- The Deacon's bear-killing story contains a startling detail: the three boys clung to the tree for 15 hours while their father spent the night searching in darkness, terrified of bears and wolves, before finding them at dawn. This is a real, documented family legend that survived in print.
- John Thornton Kirtland, Jerusha's son born on horseback during her journey, became President of Harvard College—one of the highest intellectual positions in America—yet his mother was described as simply 'the daughter of a respectable farmer of Windham.'
- The genealogy explicitly corrects a widespread biographical error repeated in multiple published works and the Genealogical Register: most historians wrongly claimed Jerusha was the daughter of Jabez Bingham of Salisbury, with a lineage traced to Miles Standish. The Windham records prove this false.
- Samuel Kirtland, Jerusha's husband, was renowned enough that his life appeared in Dr. Sprague's 'Annals of the American Pulpit'—yet the paper devotes substantial space to correcting genealogical claims about his wife, showing how historical accuracy was contested even in primary sources.
Fun Facts
- The Kirtland twins born in 1770 were given indigenous names by the Oneida Nation: George Whitfield became 'La-go-ne-ost' and John Thornton became 'Ah-Gan-owiski or Fair-Fan'—a remarkable symbol of cultural exchange during America's early Indian mission period, even as the nation was systematically dispossessing tribes of their lands.
- Jerusha Bingham Kirtland's death on January 22, 1788 is recorded here, but her legacy was so significant that generations later, in 1860, her genealogy was still being debated in published registers and descendants were writing to newspapers to correct the record—showing how women's historical importance could be remembered even when obscured by patrilineal naming.
- The essay 'Summering: Enjoying Ourselves' argues that leisure time makes workers more productive—a surprisingly modern argument about work-life balance being published in the middle of the Civil War, when the nation was in crisis and productivity was tied to military and industrial output.
- Samuel Kirtland's second wife was Mary Donally, whom he married after Jerusha's death in 1788; Mary lived until August 1830 (age unknown but clearly long-lived), meaning Kirtland experienced 42 years of marriage across two wives during the founding era of American missionary work.
- The genealogy notes that one of Joseph Bingham's sons 'was at the battle of Bunker Hill and was a cripple for 20 years'—a casual mention of Revolutionary War combat trauma buried in a family history, documenting how war disability quietly shaped everyday life in post-independence America.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free