“Lee's Army is Collapsing From Within—And Ohio Vigilantes Know It (Aug. 18, 1863)”
What's on the Front Page
Two months after Gettysburg, the Cleveland Morning Leader reports startling intelligence from inside Robert E. Lee's army: a refugee named William H. Marks, freshly arrived from Virginia, confirms widespread demoralization in Confederate ranks. Mississippi and Texas regiments, disgusted with the war effort following the fall of Vicksburg and Port Hudson, attempted to desert en masse near Snickersville—only to be forcibly returned to duty by J.E.B. Stuart's cavalry in armed confrontation. The North Mountains, Marks says, are "full of deserters" from Lee's army, and soldiers openly discuss rumors that Lee himself has tendered his resignation to Jefferson Davis in protest. Meanwhile, in Stark County, Ohio, a dramatic street confrontation erupts when a Southern sympathizer named Klice appears in Waynesboro wearing a butternut (Confederate symbol). Lieutenant Ross, fresh from Vicksburg, draws a revolver on him; a local man produces an ax handle; Klice tears the emblem from his shirt and begs for mercy. The paper celebrates this vigilante justice as patriotic action.
Why It Matters
August 1863 marks a critical hinge in the Civil War. Lee's invasion of Pennsylvania had ended just six weeks earlier at Gettysburg—a Union victory that shattered Northern fears of defeat. Now, as Northern morale climbs, reports of Confederate collapse began circulating. The Marks account—published prominently in the New York Times and reprinted here—provided Northerners with proof that the rebellion was rotting from within. Simultaneously, the article on English financial markets reveals that European capitalists who'd bet on Southern victory were losing their shirts: Confederate bonds had plummeted 20 percent. Back home, the butternut incident shows simmering tension between Copperhead (Peace Democrat) sympathizers and War Republicans in Ohio—a crucial swing state whose governor, David Tod, was a War Republican, but whose 1864 gubernatorial race would pit a Copperhead challenger against him.
Hidden Gems
- A slave woman in a Rockville, Maryland hospital shields a Union officer under her truckle-bed from Confederate raiders, and when a rebel officer threatens to shoot her unless she reveals his location, she calmly responds: 'I wish you would, sir, for I am very tired and want to rest'—the officer laughs in bewildered defeat.
- A prominent New York Democrat who tried to employ poor white laborers on a Virginia estate in gold mining was visited by three gentleman from neighboring plantations (including future rebel General Jenkins) and ordered to fire his white workers and purchase slaves instead—even though his white workers were willing to accept wage cuts from 80 cents to 60 cents per day.
- Four men from Lima, Ohio were arrested for the federal crime of harboring deserters and each posted $1,000 bail—evidence that Lincoln's government actively prosecuted those who sheltered draft dodgers and runaways.
- Queen Victoria's letter condemning female rope-walking exhibitions in England came after a pregnant woman fell to her death at Birmingham, and the audience demanded the show continue—the Queen's secretary called the victim 'a male,' prompting the paper's sharp editorial correction.
- Chicago's Board of Trade excursion to Portland, Maine culminated in a 'Grand Clam Bake' featuring 90 bushels of clams, 2,500 oysters, 150 lobsters, 60 codfish, 10 bushels of potatoes, 600 ears of corn, 50 dozen eggs, and 2 bushels of onions, all baked simultaneously.
Fun Facts
- The paper mentions rumored tension between Lee and Davis—Lee would indeed resign in April 1865 after Petersburg, though historians debate whether he formally tendered resignation. The rifts over strategy were real: Lee wanted aggressive offense; Davis wanted defensive consolidation.
- J.E.B. Stuart's cavalry action stopping deserters near Snickersville in mid-August 1863 was part of a broader collapse: by summer 1864, desertion would reach catastrophic levels—some estimates suggest 100,000+ Confederates absent without leave by war's end.
- The English financial panic over Confederate bonds is a perfect snapshot of war-profiteering: British industrialists and bankers had openly bet on Southern victory for years, believing cotton wealth was unbeatable. The collapse of Confederate credit markets after Gettysburg meant fortunes evaporated overnight.
- The butternut as a symbol: 'butternut' referred both to the natural plant dye used by rural Confederates and became slang for Southern sympathizers. Ohio, a border-state mentality, had significant Copperhead populations who wore them defiantly—vigilante violence like this incident became normalized by 1863-64.
- The article on slavery's effect on white labor documents a historical irony: slavery depressed wages for all workers and locked poor whites out of employment, yet poor whites often fought to preserve the system. This contradiction would haunt Reconstruction and the post-war South for decades.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free