“A Soldier's Warning from Florida: 'We'd Rather Stay 10 Years Than Disgrace Ourselves' (Connecticut, 1863)”
What's on the Front Page
The April 17, 1863 Willimantic Journal opens with a detailed genealogical history of the Bibbins family, tracing the lineage back to Arthur Bibbins, an early settler who arrived in Windham around 1715 from Glastonbury, Connecticut. The article meticulously documents births, marriages, and deaths across generations, noting that Arthur Bibbins himself lived to an extraordinary 107 or 108 years old while working as a shoemaker. But the most compelling content comes from a letter dated March 26, 1863, written by a soldier with the 7th Connecticut Volunteers stationed in Fernandina, Florida. The correspondent reports the regiment is in fine condition and takes pride in their capture of Fort Pulaski, lamenting that "some of the New York papers have tried to steal it from us." He passionately urges Connecticut voters to elect William A. Buckingham as governor and warns against the "Seymour party," declaring the regiment would "rather stay ten years than have a disgraceful settlement"—a stark reminder that even as the Civil War raged, home-front politics divided the North. The page also features Alfred Tennyson's ode to Princess Alexandra's royal marriage, a report on a purported smallpox cure from Nova Scotia involving an "Indian cup" plant, and a Gothic tale of a "haunted inn" in Antwerp that turns out to be a sleepwalking girl.
Why It Matters
This newspaper snapshot captures America in spring 1863—a pivotal and agonizing moment in the Civil War. The conflict was nearly two years old, casualty lists mounting, and Northern morale wavering. The soldier's letter from Florida is essential testimony: it shows how the war saturated domestic politics, how distant Connecticut regiments followed home elections obsessively, and how the commitment to total victory divided Americans. The reference to Seymour (Democratic candidate opposing the war effort) versus Buckingham (the War Republican) reflects the genuine political fracture threatening the Union cause itself. Meanwhile, the genealogical column and literary pieces show a society still trying to maintain cultural life and local pride even as its sons fought in swamps and marshes hundreds of miles away. The juxtaposition is poignant: family histories being carefully recorded, poetry celebrating British royalty, ghost stories for entertainment—all while real men were dying at places like James Island.
Hidden Gems
- The soldier reports the 7th Connecticut lost significant men in 'the bloody fight on James Island' but emphasizes they were 'the last and the only Regiment that left the field in good order'—a boast that reveals how regiments competed for honor even in defeat, and how soldiers framed retreat as tactical excellence.
- Arthur Bibbins supposedly worked as a shoemaker 'until after he was one hundred years old' and lived to 107–108 in 1788—meaning he would have been born around 1680, making him a contemporary of King Philip's War and the earliest colonial settlements.
- The smallpox 'cure' from Nova Scotia claimed the remedy could be 'largely mixed with tea and coffee, and given to the connoisseurs in these beverages to drink, without their being aware of the admixture'—describing a medical deception that would be unthinkable by modern standards, yet presented as progress.
- The letter writer notes Fernandina has 'about 280 houses' and describes it as 'a rather poor looking city' where 'Every man that built a house had a somewhat different style'—a glimpse of what an occupied Confederate town looked like to Northern eyes in 1863.
- The 'Haunted Inn' story, while appearing as light entertainment, may reflect real anxieties about travel, safety, and the supernatural that captivated Victorian readers seeking psychological relief from war news.
Fun Facts
- The soldier's reference to William A. Buckingham—'the soldiers friend'—was not mere hyperbole. Buckingham, elected governor in 1863, would become one of the North's most aggressive war governors, raising multiple regiments and spending state funds lavishly on the war effort, earning genuine devotion from Connecticut troops.
- The 7th Connecticut Volunteers' claim to Fort Pulaski appears justified by history: they were indeed instrumental in that capture in April 1862, though competition for credit was fierce. The soldier's complaint about New York papers stealing glory reflects how fiercely regiments guarded their reputations—a form of psychological survival.
- Tennyson's ode to Princess Alexandra was written in 1863 for her marriage to the Prince of Wales, making this newspaper's publication of it remarkably timely. Yet it's striking that a Connecticut town received it at all, showing how transatlantic culture still flowed despite the American war consuming attention.
- The genealogical column's meticulous recording of births and deaths reflects a pre-Civil War obsession with establishing American family pedigrees and respectability—ironically, many of these carefully documented descendants would be killed in the war within months of this article's publication.
- The letter from Fernandina is dated March 26 but published April 17—a three-week mail delay that was standard for Civil War correspondence, meaning soldiers' families were always reading month-old news about loved ones, amplifying anxiety.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free