“"Sooner Under England Than The Union": How The South Answered Lincoln's Emancipation In 1863”
What's on the Front Page
The Worcester Daily Spy's front page is dominated by reprinted Confederate newspaper editorials revealing the South's hardening resolve in early 1863. The Richmond Despatch warns Northern Democrats that the South will never rejoin the Union on any terms—not even if the North wrote a new constitution guaranteeing everything the South demanded. The Confederate states would "sooner be under the government of England or France," the editorial snarls, comparing reconstruction efforts to asking a man whose house has been burned and family massacred to renew a business partnership. Meanwhile, the Atlanta Intelligencer protests against any Confederate discussion of admitting free states, insisting the war is explicitly being fought "for a government of southern states, recognizing African slavery as an institution ordained of God." The page also covers heated Congressional debates in Richmond over retaliatory measures against Union prisoners and captured officers, with Senator Foote of Tennessee proposing turning prisoners over to state authorities for execution under laws against "servile insurrection." A lengthy account from a U.S. naval officer details the humiliating escape of the Confederate steamer Oreto through the Union blockade off Mobile—described as resulting from "gross negligence" and "red tape" that delayed pursuit by thirty crucial minutes.
Why It Matters
By February 1863, the Civil War had entered its third year with no end in sight. Lincoln's Emancipation Proclamation had just taken effect one month earlier, fundamentally reframing the conflict from preserving the Union to abolishing slavery. The Confederate leadership's response—as captured here—reveals they understood slavery's centrality and would never accept reunion on Northern terms. Meanwhile, the blockade-running operations described from Nassau show the Confederacy's desperation and ingenuity in maintaining supply lines through neutral British territories. The Union's naval failures underscore why the war would drag on for two more brutal years. These editorials and reports are essentially warfare by other means: the South broadcasting defiance, the North documenting its struggles.
Hidden Gems
- The newspaper itself costs 15 cents per week or $7 per year—yet the Worcester Daily Spy has been publishing since 1770, making it 93 years old on this date, one of America's oldest continuously operating newspapers.
- Confederate Senator Yancey's resolution specifically questioned whether federal officers captured in combat could legally be tried and executed by Confederate states under local laws—a detail that reveals the South was grappling with whether their rebellion created a parallel government with legal jurisdiction.
- The account of the Oreto's escape mentions the U.S. ship's gun deck was "literally afloat" from water flooding in during pursuit, suggesting the vessels were operating in genuinely dangerous conditions off Yucatan.
- The Nassau report reveals that merchant firms like H. Adderley Co. and Saunders & Sons had allegedly made "over a million of dollars" running the blockade—staggering wealth being accumulated by British colonial merchants profiting from the American war.
- The final snippet mentions British Admiral Wilkes was being hunted by Her Majesty's steamer Galatea to be captured and taken to Bermuda—indicating serious international tensions between the Union and Britain over the Trent Affair fallout.
Fun Facts
- The Confederate editorials cited here—especially the Richmond Despatch's harsh rejection of reunion—reflect an increasingly hardline Southern position that would make Sherman and Grant's scorched-earth campaigns toward Atlanta and the Carolinas appear inevitable and justified to Northern readers like those of the Worcester Spy.
- Senator Foote of Tennessee, quoted advocating for executing Union officers under state laws, was actually a complex figure: he'd eventually turn against Davis and the Confederacy, becoming one of the few Confederate politicians who opposed the war's continuation and later supported Reconstruction.
- The steamer Oreto mentioned here would become the CSS Florida, one of the Confederacy's most famous and destructive commerce raiders, ultimately sinking 37 Union merchant vessels—making this failed capture a genuinely consequential moment in naval history.
- The Nassau "neutrality" described here—where British colonial officials looked the other way while blockade runners openly operated—would eventually strain Anglo-American relations so badly that Britain nearly officially recognized the Confederacy in late 1862, nearly triggering a three-way war.
- The mention of a Union defeat at Vicksburg causing jubilation in Nassau refers to the ongoing siege that wouldn't actually end until July 1863—meaning this early February report shows the Confederacy still held hope that Vicksburg could hold and reverse Union momentum on the Mississippi.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free