“Lincoln's Secret Meeting Revealed: A Kentucky Delegate's Haunting Account of Pre-War Negotiations”
What's on the Front Page
The front page of this December 1862 Auburn newspaper is dominated by an extraordinary account: ex-Governor Charles Morehead of Kentucky recounting his secret meeting with President Lincoln just months before the Civil War erupted. Morehead, originally a Union man, details his desperate attempt to broker peace as part of a delegation to Washington. He describes how Secretary of State William Seward pledged his 'sacred honor' that there would be 'no collision between North and South' in sixty days—a promise catastrophically broken. The core of the story is Morehead's vivid recollection of sitting down with Lincoln around 9 p.m. one night with fellow delegates including Virginia's W.C. Rives and Missouri's General Donovan. Lincoln, Morehead recalls, insisted he was 'accidentally elected' and had said nothing against Southern interests—except his famous 'house divided' statement, which he claimed was merely abstract. When pressed on slavery in the territories, Lincoln refused to budge, saying his entire life opposed its extension there. Morehead's final plea to Lincoln is haunting: 'if he did [resort to coercion], the history of his Administration would be written in blood, and all the waters of the Atlantic Ocean could never wash it from his hands.'
Why It Matters
By December 1862, America was already nine months into the bloodiest conflict in its history. Lincoln had issued the preliminary Emancipation Proclamation just two months earlier, fundamentally transforming the war's purpose. This firsthand account of pre-war negotiations reveals the desperate last-ditch efforts by moderate border-state men to prevent secession through constitutional guarantees on slavery—efforts that failed because neither North nor South would bend. The fact that this speech was published in Auburn's Placer County newspaper shows how intensely Californians followed the crisis; though geographically remote, California's economy and politics were deeply enmeshed with national events. The war would reshape everything, including the gold rush economy that had built Auburn itself.
Hidden Gems
- The Temple Saloon ad advertises 'two elegant Billiard Tables'—billiards was the video game of 1862, a status marker that shows Auburn's mining wealth created demand for sophisticated leisure establishments.
- Hamilton's Mountaineer Stage Line connected Auburn to Sacramento via Dutch Flat and Illinoistown, with stages leaving at 5 a.m. to connect with trains—this web of transportation was literally stitched the state together during the war years.
- Dr. E. J. Whitcomb's ad notes his office occupies 'the corner brick, opposite the Temple, recently occupied by M. E. Mills, Esq.'—suggesting business turnover and movement even in small Gold Country towns during wartime.
- The subscription rates reveal who could afford news: $4/year for annual subscription (roughly $140 today), with single copies available, meaning not everyone regularly read the paper—it was a luxury.
- W.M. Sexton, Justice of the Peace, advertised services drawing 'Deeds, Mortgages, Bills of Sale, and Homesteads'—showing Auburn was transitioning from pure mining camps to settled communities with property law needs.
Fun Facts
- Morehead mentions serving in Congress with Lincoln—they were indeed colleagues in 1847-49, a detail that makes their pre-war negotiation genuinely poignant given how little common ground they found.
- The speech was published in the Liverpool Mercury on October 13, 1862, then republished here in Auburn weeks later—this shows how transatlantic the American crisis was; British newspapers covered it intensely because Southern cotton was vital to Lancashire mills.
- Morehead references William Seward's promise to 'settle this matter to the entire satisfaction of the South in sixty days'—Seward would become one of Lincoln's closest advisors and remain Secretary of State through Reconstruction, making his broken promise historically significant.
- General Donovan mentioned as a participant 'distinguished himself in the Mexican War'—the Mexican War veterans of the 1840s were now split between Union and Confederate generals, creating a literal reunion of old comrades on opposite sides.
- Lincoln's anecdote about 'guv it up' references a Kentucky legal case—his use of frontier humor to deflect Morehead's moral plea about bloodshed is both poignant and historically revealing of how he operated under enormous pressure.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free