“The Democrat Who Loved Lincoln's War But Hated Lincoln's Methods—1862 Auburn Weighs In”
What's on the Front Page
The Placer Herald's November 22, 1862 front page is dominated by a lengthy speech from John Van Buren, son of former President Martin Van Buren, delivered at a massive Democratic rally at Cooper's Institute in New York on October 12th. With 50,000 people present, Van Buren addressed the critical 1862 midterm elections during the Civil War, passionately defending his support for Democratic gubernatorial candidate Horatio Seymour over Republican James S. Wadsworth. Van Buren argues that Seymour's election—not Wadsworth's—will best serve the Union's war effort, despite his personal belief that General Dix would have been ideal. He includes his own September 1st letter to Governor E.D. Morgan, offering his military services while reserving the right to withdraw if the war's objectives become 'unconstitutional and unchristian.' The speech captures a crucial moment when Northern Democrats split between war supporters and those demanding peace, with Van Buren positioning himself as a loyal patriot who backs the Union while questioning Lincoln's leadership.
Why It Matters
This speech reflects the fracturing of Northern political consensus in the second year of the Civil War. By late 1862, the conflict had proven far costlier and longer than anticipated—Lincoln's Preliminary Emancipation Proclamation (announced September 22) had also transformed the war from a Union-preservation effort into something broader, alienating War Democrats. The 1862 midterms became a referendum on Lincoln's conduct of the war, with Democrats gaining significant ground. Van Buren's words reveal how even loyal Unionists worried that the Lincoln administration was exceeding constitutional bounds. This California newspaper, published 2,000 miles from the action, demonstrates how intensely the war dominated national discourse—a small county paper in the Sierra Nevada Gold Country devotes its entire front page to Eastern politics and warfare.
Hidden Gems
- The paper's masthead lists subscription rates 'invariably in Advance'—$10 for a year, $3.50 for six months—and charges $2 for the first newspaper advertisement and $1 for each subsequent one, showing tight cash flow management in a frontier town.
- Among the business cards is Hall & Allen Banking at Auburn, Todd's Valley, and Dutch Flat, explicitly advertising they 'Pay the Highest Price for Gold Dust' and 'make advances on Gold Dust consigned for Assay or Coinage'—direct evidence of the Sierra Nevada's continuing gold rush economy in 1862.
- The Temple Saloon and Head Quarters Saloon both advertise billiard tables and liquors prominently, suggesting Auburn's social life revolved entirely around saloons—there are more saloon ads than any other business type.
- A 'Last Notice' from Jacob Feldberg warns debtors that their accounts have been placed 'in the hands of George L. Anderson for collection,' revealing the credit-dependent nature of frontier commerce and the threat of legal collection.
- James Conner's Sons' U.S. Type Foundry advertisement in San Francisco offers 'Every article necessary for a complete News or Job Printing Office' at 'the lowest prices,' showing how even small Nevada Street papers in Auburn could source modern printing equipment from the city.
Fun Facts
- John Van Buren, the speaker, was the son of President Martin Van Buren (1837-1841) and represented a dying breed—the War Democrat who supported Lincoln's Union effort while opposing his methods. He would become increasingly isolated within his own party as the war dragged on, and his caution about the war becoming 'unconstitutional' foreshadowed the postwar constitutional crisis over Reconstruction.
- Van Buren mentions the 'Maine Law'—New York's prohibition of alcohol—which he celebrates Governor Seymour for defeating by his vote. This was a real battle in the 1850s-60s temperance movement, yet here in Auburn, saloons and liquor merchants dominate the classified ads, suggesting California's frontier culture simply ignored Eastern moral crusades.
- The paper notes this speech was delivered at Cooper's Institute, the same venue where Abraham Lincoln gave his famous February 1860 'Right Makes Might' speech that propelled him toward the presidency—showing how this single New York hall was the stage for the era's defining political moments.
- Van Buren's reference to Lincoln arriving in Washington 'in disguise...covered with a Scotch cap...wrapped with a blue cloth cloak' alludes to the real February 1861 incident when Lincoln snuck through Baltimore to avoid assassination threats, a scandal that haunted his image among critics.
- The Auburn paper republishes this New York speech in full, indicating how newspapers of the era functioned as national forums—a California mountain town's readers got the entire 8,000-word oration, demonstrating the obsessive focus on Civil War politics even in remote mining regions 2,000 miles away.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free