“"Frozen Potato Toes" and Other Excuses: How One Connecticut Town Dodged the Draft in 1862”
What's on the Front Page
The Litchfield Enquirer's October 16, 1862 edition leads with a sharp satirical poem titled "Exemption," reprinted from the Amenia Times, that mocks the parade of able-bodied men traveling to Litchfield to claim draft exemptions from military service during the Civil War. The poem lampoons their creative excuses with biting humor: one man claims a childhood broken arm renders him useless, another complains of cross-eyes, a third insists his weak left leg prevents marching, a fourth frets that an injured toe will "freeze like a potato" in cold weather, a fifth fears fainting at the sight of a musket. The poet's refrain—"Columbia! unfurl thy proud banner with joy"—drips with sarcasm, suggesting that if these "patriots" are the nation's defenders, the Union's cause must be "surely victorious" indeed. Below this, the paper runs the opening chapters of a serialized story about a mysterious young woman purchasing her late mother's bureau at auction, establishing the sentimental fiction that occupied much of the era's newspaper space.
Why It Matters
October 1862 was a critical moment in the Civil War. The Union had recently suffered devastating losses at Second Bull Run and was reeling from Confederate victories in the Eastern Theater. President Lincoln had just announced the preliminary Emancipation Proclamation days before this paper's publication. Against this backdrop of national crisis and military urgency, the casual draft-dodging depicted in the poem reveals deep class and social tensions in Northern communities. Connecticut, though firmly Union, still housed plenty of reluctant soldiers and those wealthy enough to avoid service entirely. The poem captures the bitter local resentment toward exemption-seekers—a phenomenon that would intensify after the 1863 Draft Riots in New York City. It's a window into how ordinary Americans experienced the war's demands.
Hidden Gems
- A full set of upper teeth in 18-karat gold, custom-made and 'warranted to fit,' cost just $25 for the next six months—the dentist, G. Crossman, was so desperate for business that he explicitly states he doesn't want the work to leave for Hartford. This reflects both the economic hardship of wartime Connecticut and the competitive underpricing of skilled labor.
- The business directory lists five different attorneys in tiny Litchfield—more lawyers than blacksmiths or carpenters—suggesting either considerable legal disputes or that law was a gateway profession for ambitious men in rural Connecticut.
- Robert M. Treat manufactured 'Safety Tug Irons' and corn shellers in Litchfield, a detail revealing the town's agricultural focus and the technological innovations (however modest) being applied to farming during wartime.
- Ambroтипes—early photographic portraits on glass—are advertised as 'popular pictures taken with great success' at Udds Gallery, showing how quickly photographic technology (patented in the 1850s) had penetrated even small New England towns by the Civil War era.
- Vermont roofing slate was being sold in Litchfield 'very cheap' by H.E. Wine of South Norwalk, demonstrating the regional trade networks that moved materials across state lines even during wartime disruption.
Fun Facts
- The Litchfield Enquirer was edited and published by James Humphrey Jr. from the third floor of the Enquirer Building—a reminder that before the consolidation of media, every town of any size had its own independent newspaper, often a one-man operation. Litchfield's paper cost $1.50 per year for village subscribers and $1.25 for mail subscribers, roughly equivalent to $50-55 today.
- The serialized story about the young woman and the bureau—running across multiple weeks—was how 19th-century newspapers hooked readers into loyalty. This technique was pioneered by Charles Dickens in the 1830s and became standard in American papers by the 1860s. Readers would eagerly await the next installment, much like modern streaming series.
- Connecticut provided roughly 55,000 soldiers to the Union Army during the Civil War—about 10% of the state's population. Exemption seekers like those mocked in the poem represented a real problem: draft evasion was rampant enough that it contributed to the need for the controversial 1863 conscription act, which sparked the deadly New York Draft Riots just six months after this paper was published.
- The dental advertisement mentioning that teeth 'don't use yet, for the want of business' is a rare moment of economic honesty in 19th-century advertising—a dentist essentially admitting he's underemployed and desperate. This hints at the economic disruption the Civil War caused even in Northern communities supposedly profiting from war production.
- The poem's author, signing as 'Red White and Blue,' identifies himself as 'the only son of a resigned West Point graduate'—suggesting he was from a military family that had chosen to step back from service, adding a layer of personal irony to his savage critique of draft-dodgers.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free