“On the Brink at Vicksburg: How a Naval Commander's Caution Might Cost the Union Everything”
What's on the Front Page
The Evening Star's front page is dominated by a detailed correspondent's account from the Mississippi River theater of the Civil War, where the Union blockade of Vicksburg is faltering amid Confederate resistance and disease. The correspondent reports that Commodore Farragut's fleet has departed downriver—destination unknown, possibly Mobile Bay—leaving behind only token gunboat protection. Most damning is the criticism of Flag Officer Davis's "supine" inactivity: rather than venturing up the Yazoo River to destroy the Confederate ironclad Arkansas while it was still under construction, Davis allowed his crews to be "prostrated by disease," forcing an embarrassing withdrawal from the Peninsula. The rebels, meanwhile, strengthen their position daily under General Van Dorn, moving guns and troops with impunity. The correspondent's frustration is palpable: "circumstances clearly indicate the entire failure to remove the base of operations." The paper also reports on a pair of panicked draft-exemption manias gripping New York and Brooklyn after rumors of militia conscription—crowds descended on clerks' offices with fabricated ailments, only to miraculously recover when the Governor denied the draft was imminent, turning "the lame" to "walk" and "the blind to see." A final notice describes an attempted cavalry raid on Kentucky abolitionist Rev. Robert J. Breckinridge, narrowly foiled when messengers warned him of mounted Texas Rangers waiting at his country seat.
Why It Matters
By August 1862, the Civil War was entering a grinding phase where Union military strategy—and morale—faced mounting questions. The Vicksburg campaign would ultimately drag on for ten more months, becoming one of the longest sieges in American history. This correspondent's critique of timid naval leadership reflected real frustrations in Washington about why the war wasn't being won decisively. Simultaneously, the conscription panic in Northern cities exposed deep anxieties about the war's cost in lives and the class divisions it was creating—wealthy men could afford to buy substitutes or claim exemptions, while poorer men faced the draft. The attempt to capture Breckinridge shows how personal the conflict had become in border states like Kentucky, where neighbors turned against one another over slavery and Union loyalty.
Hidden Gems
- The Carondelet gunboat was sent upriver with explicit instructions to "destroy everything in the shape of a skiff or raft between this and Memphis"—a detail revealing how the Union navy tried to strangle Confederate logistics by eliminating transport vessels before they could even launch.
- A carpenter named Thoa W. Spencer was killed when a Confederate artillery shell passed through the boiler deck of the mail vessel and "cut him almost in twain." The correspondent notes he "leaves a wife and one child in Cincinnati"—a quiet, devastating reminder that this distant river war had direct human cost in Northern homes.
- Matthew's Machines for making soda water are advertised as the solution for every sutler (military provisioner)—suggesting even battlefield commerce was industrializing in 1862, with specialized equipment for bottling sparkling drinks to sell to troops.
- William A. Batchelor's Hair Dye ad promises it "turns Brig, Red or Rusty Hair instantly" to black or brown—yet the fine print reveals the store is located at 81 Barclay Street in New York, but also references a "Late" location at Broadway and 110 Bond—suggesting the business was mid-relocation, a detail that humanizes wartime commercial disruption.
- Dr. Combbirty is advertised as having cured someone who was "stone blind for upwards of two years," with testimony from 'Siba Bailey' at a barbershop on 3rd Street—the miraculous medical claims of the era were unregulated and extraordinary, offering everything from blindness cures to mineral waters.
Fun Facts
- The correspondent mentions Sterling Price crossing into Arkansas to cut Union supply lines—Price was one of the Confederacy's most aggressive western commanders, and his cavalry operations would make him legendarily difficult to pin down throughout the war, frustrating Union generals for another three years.
- Commodore Farragut, mentioned by name as leading the departing fleet, would go on to become the first full Admiral in U.S. Navy history in 1866—at this moment in August 1862, he was still building his reputation, and this correspondent's critique of the cautious naval strategy he left behind reflects real disputes about aggressive versus defensive approaches.
- The panicked draft-exemption scenes in New York—where men miraculously recovered from blindness and lameness when the draft was denied—foreshadow the New York City Draft Riots that would explode exactly one year later in July 1863, when actual conscription began and working-class men rioted for days.
- Robert J. Breckinridge, the Kentucky minister nearly ambushed by cavalry, was the uncle of Vice President John C. Breckinridge—making this a family conflict within the political elite, with Robert supporting the Union while his famous relative had sided with the Confederacy.
- The steamboat Sallie Wood, mentioned as having been sunk by a rebel battery, was one of thousands of civilian vessels pressed into military service during the war—the Mississippi River became a floating supply line, and every steamboat was potentially a target, fundamentally disrupting pre-war commerce.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free