“Sherman Burns Jacksonville: When the Union Came South, Florida Learned the Cost of War”
What's on the Front Page
Federal forces under General William Tecumseh Sherman have captured Jacksonville, Florida, encountering virtually no resistance from Confederate troops. The Union gunboats Ottawa, Seneca, and Isaac Smith steamed up the St. Johns River on March 12th and occupied the town without a shot fired—the rebels had evacuated their batteries and abandoned their guns on orders from General Trapier. But the Union army arrived too late to prevent catastrophe: retreating Confederate forces set the town ablaze that very afternoon. Eight massive sawmills forming a near-perfect circle along the riverbanks were torched, along with the elegant Neilson House hotel, warehouses, and the railroad depot. The destruction was staggering—$500,000 worth of property reduced to ash (roughly $16 million today). Jacksonville, once a thriving port of 4,000 people that exported 50 million feet of Florida pine annually, now lies in ruins. In response, loyal citizens held a mass meeting and passed resolutions declaring their attachment to the Union and denouncing secession as unconstitutional, while Sherman issued a proclamation promising protection to those who remain and encouraging them to rebuild their state government.
Why It Matters
This March 1862 dispatch captures a pivotal moment in the Civil War: the Union's aggressive push into the Deep South and the beginning of what would become total war strategy. Sherman's arrival in Florida foreshadowed his later infamous campaigns through Georgia and the Carolinas. The capture of Jacksonville gave the North control of critical railroad infrastructure and a coastal stronghold, but the burning of the town—whether by Confederate order or Union forces—signals the escalating devastation civilians would endure. The citizens' resolutions are equally significant: they represent the early fracturing of Confederate support, with loyal unionists emerging from hiding once federal protection arrived. This document reveals how the war was becoming not just about armies and battles, but about competing visions of governance and loyalty—and about which government could actually protect its citizens.
Hidden Gems
- Jacksonville's lumber trade was staggering: the town alone sawed roughly 50 million feet of Florida pitch pine annually, worth $25-$30 per thousand feet in Northern markets—making it one of the most valuable export centers in the state, yet utterly vulnerable to military occupation.
- The citizens' protest document reveals they were living under martial law so severe that 'freedom of speech and a free press' had been denied them, and that Confederate conscription was 'procured by threats and misrepresentations'—suggesting the Confederacy was far less united than its leadership claimed.
- General Sherman's proclamation was deliberately printed from type 'struck off by the compositors from the New York Herald office now serving in the Forty-eighth and Seventy-ninth regiments New York Volunteers'—meaning Herald employees were actively fighting in the war and setting type in the field.
- The Neilson House hotel, destroyed in the fire, was specifically noted as 'well known to Northern Invalids'—it was a health resort where wealthy Northerners went for the mild climate, suggesting pre-war economic ties between North and South that the war was severing.
- The list of sawmill owners shows staggering individual losses: Fairbanks alone lost $140,000 (roughly $4.5 million today), while smaller operators lost $15,000-$40,000 each—this wasn't abstract war; it was the systematic destruction of specific men's fortunes.
Fun Facts
- The gunboats searching for the famous yacht 'America' mentioned in this dispatch were looking for one of the most celebrated racing vessels in history—she had won the first America's Cup in 1851 and was now being hunted as a Confederate prize. She would eventually be scuttled and lost to history.
- General Sherman, who arrives in Jacksonville in this very dispatch, would go on to become the architect of 'hard war'—total war strategy targeting civilian infrastructure and morale. This moment in Florida was his laboratory; his later March to the Sea through Georgia would make Jacksonville's burning look modest by comparison.
- Jacksonville's position on the St. Johns River—'navigable for two hundred miles above here for large vessels'—made it strategically crucial; control of this river gave the Union access to Florida's interior. The Confederacy would never recapture the city during the remaining three years of war.
- The citizens' meeting resolution calling for a loyal State government convention was prescient: it anticipated Lincoln's Reconstruction policy by years, suggesting some Floridians understood the war would end not in secession but in political reorganization.
- Samuel L. Burritt, the civilian who delivered Jacksonville's surrender speech to Commander Stevens, risked being branded a traitor by both sides—he remained in a conquered city as a Union sympathizer while the Confederate state government in Tallahassee (160 miles away) still held power elsewhere in Florida.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free