“Traitors and Grammar: How a Massachusetts Newspaper Explained the Civil War—and Why a Confederate Official Promoted Swearing”
What's on the Front Page
The Worcester Daily Spy's March 18, 1862 front page reveals a nation fractured by Civil War—and a newspaper determined to document the moral failures that led there. Vice President Andy Johnson, speaking on the Bright case, unleashes a blistering indictment of Southern senators who deliberately sabotaged the Crittenden Compromise in 1861. Johnson recalls confronting Senator Judah Benjamin on the Senate floor: "Vote, and show yourself an honest man," he challenged. But Benjamin and five other Southern senators refused to vote on the amendment that could have averted war. "Who, then, has brought these evils on the country?" Johnson thunders. "Southern traitors... They wanted no compromise." The piece also reports the American Tract Society's missionary work at Fort Warren, where political prisoners—including the notorious James Slidell—are being distributed religious literature. One anecdote captures the absurdity of the moment: Slidell actually *encouraged* a Christian gentleman to take up swearing, claiming it provided "great relief." Meanwhile, Worcester's economy hums with commercial listings: Louis Lewisson advertises $50,000 worth of winter clothing at "an immense sacrifice" due to "the condition of the times"—wartime inflation and uncertainty reshaping local commerce. The page also includes a lengthy essay on "Objectionable English," pillorying common grammatical sins from both sides of the Atlantic.
Why It Matters
In March 1862, the Civil War was nine months old and already reshaping American society. Johnson's bitter speech captures the Union's conviction that the South hadn't stumbled into secession—they'd chosen it, repeatedly rejecting compromise even when it was within their grasp. The Crittenden Compromise of December 1860 represented the last real chance to avoid bloodshed, so Johnson's claim that six Southern votes could have changed history carries weight. This was the moment when Northerners stopped viewing the conflict as a constitutional dispute and started seeing it as a war against traitors who'd had every opportunity for peace. The Fort Warren anecdotes reveal something equally important: even amid war, Americans on both sides maintained human contact. Imprisoned Confederate officials received Christian tracts; released prisoners visited Northern charity offices. This speaks to the Civil War's peculiar intimacy—a war fought between fellow countrymen who hadn't yet fully processed their own mutual alienation.
Hidden Gems
- The American Tract Society was distributing religious literature to Confederate prisoners at Fort Warren in Boston, and former inmates were actually returning after release to thank their captors. This reveals a startling civility in Civil War prisoner treatment that contrasts sharply with later conflicts.
- Louis Lewisson's Clothing Bazaar advertised $50,000 worth of winter clothing being liquidated at cost due to 'the condition of the times'—one of the few direct references to wartime economic disruption on this front page, showing how the conflict immediately cascaded into civilian commerce.
- The lengthy grammar essay criticizes Americans for inventing the verb 'to progress'—calling it 'a barbarism recently introduced from America.' Even amid Civil War, Anglo-American linguistic snobbery was alive and well, with British editors fretting over American innovations.
- Fort Warren is mentioned casually, but this was Boston's major Confederate prisoner-of-war camp, where future Confederate Vice President Alexander Stephens and other high-ranking officials were held. The camp would hold over 1,000 prisoners by war's end.
- James Slidell, who advised swearing as 'great relief,' was one of the most significant Confederate diplomats—he was captured at sea in the Trent Affair, an incident that nearly dragged Britain into the war on the South's side just weeks before this article was published.
Fun Facts
- Vice President Andrew Johnson, whose hard words about Southern traitors appear here, would become president just three years later after Lincoln's assassination—and his harsh Reconstruction policies would make him deeply unpopular in the North by 1868.
- Senator Judah Benjamin, mentioned here refusing to vote for compromise, would become the Confederacy's Secretary of State and most trusted diplomat. After the war he fled to England and became a successful barrister, arguably having a more prosperous post-war career than most Union generals.
- The Worcester Daily Spy, established in 1770, was already 92 years old when this issue ran—making it older than the United States itself. It would continue publishing until 1958, surviving through the entire arc of American history from Revolution to the atomic age.
- The Crittenden Compromise Johnson references would be completely forgotten by the 20th century, yet it represents perhaps the single moment where Congress got closest to preventing 620,000 deaths—making it one of history's great counterfactuals.
- That essay complaining about American linguistic innovations ('to progress' as a verb) was fighting a losing battle—Americans were actively reshaping English to match their industrial, optimistic culture. The editor of Chambers' Journal couldn't have known his objections would prove futile.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free