What's on the Front Page
New York's theaters are ablaze with spectacle on this February evening in 1862. The New-York Daily Tribune devotes considerable space to E.L. Davenport's performances at an unnamed playhouse, where audiences can catch him in three productions: *The Wife*, *Faint Heart Never Won Fair Lady*, and *Black-Eyed Susan*. But the real sensation sweeping Manhattan is Commodore Nutt at Barnum's American Museum—a 29-inch-tall man weighing just 44 pounds who is drawing "unprecedente crowds" and charming audiences with "songs and dances in character." Barnum is reportedly paying the diminutive performer $30,000 for three years of appearances. The Tribune's theater critics can barely contain their amazement, with one declaring him "doubtless the smallest grown man in the world," while comparing him favorably to the famous Tom Thumb. Meanwhile, the Hutchinson Family vocal ensemble is performing at a benefit concert for "daughters of deceased or disabled volunteers"—a haunting reminder that beneath the gaslights and evening wear, the nation is tearing itself apart in the Civil War.
Why It Matters
February 1862 finds America in the depths of the Civil War's first winter. While battles rage and families mourn, New Yorkers still crave entertainment—a distinctly human need that transcends national catastrophe. The mention of "deceased or disabled volunteers" in benefit concert advertising reveals how the conflict has already penetrated civilian life. Theater, museums, and curiosities offer escape from an increasingly grim reality. Barnum's exploitation of human difference—parading Commodore Nutt as spectacle—was considered wholesome family entertainment in this era, reflecting attitudes toward disability and otherness that would astound modern sensibilities. Yet these diversions also show a city determined to maintain normalcy even as the nation bleeds.
Hidden Gems
- The New-York Tribune offered mail subscriptions for $10 per annum in advance, but city subscribers could get daily delivery for just 12½ cents per week—yet the paper cost only TWO CENTS on the street. The subscription model was actually a premium service for those wanting guaranteed daily delivery.
- A small classified ad seeks "a neat Girl of 15" to work as chambermaid, waiter, or nurse—child labor was so normalized that age-specific job postings for young teens required no special justification or concern.
- Barnum was paying Commodore Nutt $30,000 for three years ($1,000,000+ in today's money), making the 29-inch-tall performer one of the highest-paid entertainers in America—more than most skilled laborers earned in a lifetime.
- The Tribune published 'ABSTRACTS of important Acts of the Second Session of the XXXVIth Congress' in their almanac, suggesting serious readers followed legislative proceedings in newspaper form—there was no other practical way to stay informed about federal law.
- Multiple ads advertised servant-finding agencies operating on 6th Avenue and 11th Street, explicitly listing availability of 'German, Irish, English, Protestant, and Catholic' workers—immigration and religious discrimination were openly marketed alongside help-wanted postings.
Fun Facts
- Commodore Nutt was billed as a genuine rival to Tom Thumb, the dwarf performer who had become an international celebrity under P.T. Barnum's management. Tom Thumb had earned Barnum a fortune in the 1850s; by 1862, Barnum was clearly betting Nutt could replicate that success—and the $30,000 contract shows just how lucrative human curiosity could be.
- The Tribune advertised gold pens at prices ranging from 25 cents to $6, with different sizes and quality grades. These were luxury writing instruments in an era when most Americans used dip pens and inkwells—the level of detail in these ads reveals a sophisticated consumer market for business professionals and the wealthy.
- Barnum's American Museum, where Commodore Nutt performed, was located on Broadway in lower Manhattan and functioned as part carnival, part natural history exhibit, part freak show. It would eventually be destroyed by fire in 1865, but in 1862 it was the premier attraction in New York City—more visited than the Metropolitan Museum.
- The Hutchinson Family's benefit concert for 'daughters of deceased or disabled volunteers' reveals the immediate human cost of war by February 1862—less than a year into conflict, there were already widows and orphans requiring charitable support.
- The newspaper itself—with elaborate subscription pricing, different editions (daily, semi-weekly, weekly), and multiple advertising tiers—was a sophisticated publishing operation. The Tribune was one of the most influential newspapers in America, and by 1862 it had become a powerful voice for Republican politics and the abolitionist cause.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free