Monday
November 18, 1861
The New York herald (New York [N.Y.]) — New York City, New York
“Rebel Diplomats Captured at Sea: How Two Confederates Nearly Started a War With Britain”
Art Deco mural for November 18, 1861
Original newspaper scan from November 18, 1861
Original front page — The New York herald (New York [N.Y.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The USS San Jacinto has arrived at Fortress Monroe carrying two Confederate diplomatic commissioners—James M. Mason and John Slidell—captured from the British mail steamer *Trent* on November 8th off Bermuda. The seizure marks a dramatic moment in the young Civil War, as these rebel ministers were en route to England and France to seek diplomatic recognition and support for the Confederacy. The Herald devotes its entire front page to the affair, providing detailed sketches of both men's backgrounds and political careers. Mason, a Virginia native and former U.S. Senator, was Chairman of the Foreign Affairs Committee. Slidell, born in New York but long a Louisiana power broker, had served as U.S. Minister to Mexico. The paper traces their extraordinary escape from Charleston aboard the swift steamer *Theodora*, their triumphant reception in Havana (where Cuban ladies presented them with a Confederate flag), and their capture when they transferred to the British ship *Trent*. The Herald also prints legal analysis questioning whether the capture of commissioners aboard a neutral vessel was justified under international law.

Why It Matters

In November 1861, the Confederacy was fighting for survival—not just militarily but diplomatically. Recognition from Britain or France could mean loans, trade, and perhaps military intervention. Mason and Slidell's capture transformed a military moment into an international crisis. Britain took the seizure of its mail steamer as a humiliation, nearly pushing the two nations toward war. This incident, known as the *Trent* Affair, would dominate diplomatic headlines for months and nearly shattered the Union's foreign relations at a critical moment. The Herald's breathless coverage reflects how Americans understood this wasn't just about two men—it was about whether the world would treat the Confederacy as a legitimate nation or a domestic rebellion. The paper's detailed profiles humanized the commissioners while also mocking them, particularly George Eustis, whom the Herald dismisses as pompous and talentless.

Hidden Gems
  • The Herald sarcastically notes that George Eustis 'was scarcely ever seen without a quizzing glass in his eye, although it was rumored in Washington that he could see much better without it'—suggesting his affectations were pure theater.
  • The *Theodora* escaped the Charleston blockade 'a little before midnight on Friday, October 11,' in such darkness that 'a light rain began falling which rendered the chances of being detected exceedingly slim'—their escape depended literally on bad weather.
  • John Slidell's father was 'honest old John Slidell, the tallow chandler, of Broadway'—a candlemaker whose son rose from immigrant poverty to become a U.S. Senator and Confederate commissioner.
  • The Herald notes pointedly that Mrs. Eustis is 'a daughter of Mr. Corcoran, the Washington banker, now in Fort Lafayette' (imprisoned by the U.S. government)—revealing how the Civil War split elite families.
  • The paper reports that Cuban ladies of Matanzas sent 'a splendid flag for the Hampton Legion' to the *Theodora*, suggesting Confederate military units were already operating in Cuba and receiving international support.
Fun Facts
  • James M. Mason was born November 3, 1798, near Washington and graduated from the University of Pennsylvania in 1818—he was 63 years old during this capture, making him a relic of the early republic being thrust into modern diplomatic crisis.
  • John Slidell's brother, Alexander Slidell Mackenzie, commanded the USS *Somers* under President Tyler and infamously hanged Midshipman Spencer for suspected mutiny—the Herald invokes this dark family history to suggest the Slidells had always been controversial figures.
  • The *Theodora* carried not just commissioners but Slidell's wife and four children, making this a family escape from Charleston under blockade—the Herald emphasizes the personal stakes alongside the diplomatic ones.
  • The Herald reports that Cuban spectators in Havana gave the *Theodora* an 'enthusiastic reception' while 'the Yankees in Havana were, as a matter of course, much displeased'—showing how the Confederacy was winning hearts in the Caribbean while losing battles at home.
  • Captain Robert B. Pegram of the *Nashville* (which the commissioners were originally supposed to board) 'entered the United States service in 1820'—meaning a 41-year naval career ended with him serving the Confederacy, illustrating the deep sectional divisions splitting the officer corps.
Contentious Civil War Diplomacy War Conflict Politics International Military
November 17, 1861 November 19, 1861

Also on November 18

View all 12 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free