Monday
September 23, 1861
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.]) — New Orleans, Orleans
“New Orleans, September 1861: Gunboats, Duels, and the Panic of Early War”
Art Deco mural for September 23, 1861
Original newspaper scan from September 23, 1861
Original front page — New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

New Orleans is ramping up for war. A freshly launched gunboat slid into the water Saturday morning at John Hughes & Co.'s Algiers shipyard—built in just two months—signaling the Confederacy's desperate need for naval defense. The paper notes with barely concealed urgency that "they cannot be finished a moment too soon." Meanwhile, the city streets thrummed with military pageantry: Major General John L. Lewis reviewed nearly 2,000 Louisiana Legion troops on Canal Street, inspecting the Orleans Guards, French Legion, and Beauregard Battalion. All "worthy the confidence of the public," the paper assures readers. But beneath the martial polish, the front page reveals a city descending into chaos. A duel between Edgar Desforgers and Mr. Dussumier turned fatal—both men dead within hours, their bodies destined for the coroner's table. Separately, Jerry Sullivan was shot dead by Thomas Maher at the corner of Annunciation and Richard streets. An English drunk named Horatio Davis was arrested for parading a "star-spangled banner" down the levee, shouting toasts to the American flag—his Confederate-suspicious behavior landed him in the calaboose. Even the horses couldn't handle the tension: 15 to 20 government animals spooked near St. Louis and were trampled to death by wagon trains.

Why It Matters

September 1861 was the Confederacy's fever dream moment. Four months into the Civil War, the South still believed in quick victory. New Orleans, the Confederacy's largest city and economic crown jewel, was frantically militarizing—building gunboats, drilling troops, preparing for Federal invasion. The newspaper's tone oscillates between confidence and paranoia: pride in the new gunboat's "rapidity" of construction, but also hypervigilance about Union sympathizers like Horatio Davis waving the American flag. This wasn't yet the industrial bloodbath of 1863-1865; this was a society still trying to normalize warfare while holding itself together through social ritual (military reviews, duels, courts) even as violence seeped into every corner—the streets, the dueling grounds, the levee itself.

Hidden Gems
  • A doctor named M. Poelman held a death certificate hostage for $30 (later negotiated down to $25), threatening to declare that Major Mathis was poisoned and have the body disinterred unless paid. He was committed for trial on charges of 'swindling and misfeasance as a physician'—grave robbing threats as debt collection.
  • The Mexican correspondence reveals five state governors conspiring to reinstate former president Comonfort, signaling that the Civil War wasn't just an American crisis: Mexico was simultaneously imploding, with the Church Party, liberals, and military strongmen all jockeying for power.
  • A classified ad for 'Letters from absent volunteers' lists over 150 unclaimed mail recipients—poignant evidence of men who left New Orleans for war and whose families couldn't track them down.
  • The paper reports that foreign vessels were granted special privilege to enter the Rio Grande and discharge cargo at Matamoros because of 'the blockade of the ports of the South'—the Union blockade was already choking Confederate trade just four months in.
  • Government horses 'became frightened' and stampeded down Broadway, killing 15-20 of their own—an oddly Kafkaesque detail suggesting panic and disorder even in military logistics.
Fun Facts
  • John Hughes & Co. built that gunboat in two months—a pace the paper calls 'almost astonishing.' By war's end, the Confederacy would desperately need such rapid production, but its industrial base was fatally limited. The North would build thousands of vessels; the South would struggle to replace losses.
  • Major Mathis, the man whose death certificate was held for ransom, died on the 12th after being sick only a short time. He was described as 'an old resident of the Faubourg Derri'—likely one of New Orleans' original Creole families. His death became a criminal extortion case, showing how even mortality became a transaction in wartime.
  • The Mexican correspondent notes that five governors met to restore the Constitution of 1857 and reinstate Comonfort—a direct parallel to American constitutional crisis. Both nations were simultaneously tearing apart: America over slavery and union, Mexico over Church power and federalism.
  • Horatio Davis, the drunk Englishman arrested for waving the American flag, faced imprisonment for what amounted to Union sympathy—a crime in the Confederacy. By 1863-1864, such cases would be routine; in September 1861, it signaled how quickly dissent was being criminalized.
  • The stampede of government horses killing 15-20 animals recalls the Civil War's staggering animal casualties: over 1.5 million horses and mules would die in the conflict, often from disease, overwork, and accidents like this one—more animal deaths than human combat deaths.
Anxious Civil War War Conflict Military Crime Violent Crime Corruption Politics International
September 22, 1861 September 25, 1861

Also on September 23

1836
September 1836: Inside the Washington Mansion Auction That Launched a Dynasty
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1846
How Baltimore's Volunteers Became America's First Conquerors (And What It Cost)
American Republican and Baltimore daily clipper (Baltimore, Md.)
1856
Davenport, Iowa, 1856: When a River Town's Merchants Ignored the Coming Civil...
Daily Iowa State Democrat (Davenport, Iowa)
1862
Peace Rumors & Dying Generals: Worcester Faces Civil War Fatigue, September 1862
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1863
Sam Houston Dies as Maryland Pivots to Emancipation—And Ohio's War Democrats...
Cleveland morning leader (Cleveland [Ohio])
1864
Generals Abandon Ship: How Lincoln's Own Party Nearly Lost Him the 1864 Election
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1865
1865: 'Slavery is dead forever' — A defeated governor's stark ultimatum
The Portland daily press (Portland, Me.)
1866
One Year After Lee's Surrender: Why New Orleans Is Rioting Again (and Other...
The daily Gate City (Keokuk, Iowa)
1876
1876 Augusta: When Fish Sold for 10¢/lb and Wall Street Promised to Turn $10...
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1886
Michigan Fair Week 1886: When a Piano on Display and Apples on a Branch Made...
Weekly expositor (Brockway Centre, Mich.)
1896
Czar Arrives in Scotland Under Heavy Guard as Bryan Storms West Virginia—and...
Waterbury Democrat (Waterbury, Conn.)
1926
1926: 132,000 Pack Stadium as Dempsey-Tunney Drama Unfolds
New Britain herald (New Britain, Conn.)
1927
Tunney's Miracle Comeback: How a Champion Dodged Destiny in Front of 150,000
Douglas daily dispatch (Douglas, Ariz.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free