“Stephen Douglas's Final Call to Patriots: A Democrat's Last Letter Supporting Lincoln's War (Sept. 1861)”
What's on the Front Page
The Bedford Gazette's September 13, 1861 front page is dominated by a letter from Senator Stephen A. Douglas, the "Little Giant" of American politics, written just weeks before his death in May 1861. Douglas, a Democrat, makes an extraordinary case for why his party should unite behind President Lincoln's war effort against the Confederacy. He argues that while Democrats opposed compromise with the Cotton States, the moment Confederate forces fired on Fort Sumter in Charleston, the question ceased being partisan politics—it became a choice between government or no government, country or no country. Douglas invokes the memory of Henry Clay and Daniel Webster during the Nullification Crisis of the 1830s, when Whigs "sank the partisan in the patriot" to defend the Union against Andrew Jackson's administration. He calls on modern Democrats to do the same. The letter reveals a man wrestling with loyalty to his party while facing an existential threat to the nation itself. The paper also publishes fierce Democratic attacks on Republicans for attempting to rebrand themselves as the "Union Party," and includes a Supreme Court judge's charge on what legally constitutes treason—a timely and urgent matter in September 1861.
Why It Matters
This newspaper captures a pivotal moment in American political history, just four months into the Civil War. Stephen Douglas's letter is remarkable because it represents the Democratic Party's internal struggle: how could they oppose the Republican administration on policy while supporting the war effort? Douglas died on June 3, 1861, making this one of his final public statements. His death removed a potential moderating force in national politics. Meanwhile, Pennsylvania—where Bedford is located—was a crucial border state and military staging ground, making this local paper's coverage of national political divisions intensely relevant to readers facing the prospect of their sons marching into battle. The debate over constitutional freedoms (freedom of speech, the right to bear arms, the definition of treason) shows how the war was forcing Americans to reconsider the boundaries between liberty and security.
Hidden Gems
- Douglas wrote his letter from Chicago on May 10, 1861, while incapacitated by severe rheumatism—he had to dictate it to an amanuensis—yet still felt compelled to make a public statement about supporting the Union war effort despite his political opposition to Lincoln.
- The Bedford Gazette charges subscribers $1.50 per year ($2.00-$2.50 if paid late), and includes a legal notice explaining that taking a newspaper from the post office makes you financially liable for it, whether you subscribed or not—a reminder of how newspapers functioned as quasi-official documents.
- Judge A.G. Miller, who wrote on freedom of the press, was a native of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, and had emigrated to Wisconsin thirty-five years earlier—showing how the legal and intellectual elite of the era were geographically mobile.
- The paper invokes the specter of France's Reign of Terror as a warning against secret police and mob justice—editors feared that wartime hysteria could lead to authoritarian crackdowns on dissent.
- A small joke appears at the bottom: "To tell if you love a girl—have some tallow headed chap go to see her"—suggesting insecurity about courtship rivalry was as timeless in 1861 as today.
Fun Facts
- Stephen A. Douglas died just four months after writing this letter—on June 3, 1861. He was only 48 years old. Had he lived, his political stature might have made him a crucial bridge figure between Democrats and Republicans during Reconstruction, fundamentally altering the post-war political landscape.
- Douglas's reference to Clay and Webster 'sinking the partisan in the patriot' during the Nullification Crisis of the 1830s was not mere nostalgia—it was a direct historical parallel meant to legitimize cross-party support for war. That earlier crisis had also threatened the Union's survival, and Democratic and Whig leaders *had* united against it.
- The paper was published in Bedford, Pennsylvania, which sits roughly 100 miles north of the Mason-Dixon line—close enough that residents could see or hear battlefield activity from nearby conflicts. Reading about debates over treason law and freedom of the press took on visceral urgency in such border communities.
- Judge A.G. Miller's warning against the 'Reign of Terror' wasn't abstract—European revolutions of 1848 had occurred just 13 years earlier, and many Americans vividly remembered how revolutionary fervor could devour its own children. Civil War anxiety was intertwined with fears of social chaos.
- The Bedford Gazette's attacks on Republicans 'rebranding' as the 'Union Party' show how fluid party identity was in 1861—the modern Republican Party was only six years old, founded in 1854, and hadn't yet become the dominant force it would be after the Civil War.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free