“While the Civil War Raged, Evansville's Merchants Sold Rat Traps: A Forgotten Front Page from September 1861”
What's on the Front Page
The Evansville Daily Journal for September 11, 1861, is dominated by business advertisements and commercial announcements—a striking contrast to what's conspicuously absent from the front page: war news. Though the masthead boldly promises "Latest News from the Seat of War," the entire visible front page is consumed by local merchants hawking everything from furniture to oysters. J. & E. Ivinson advertise their portable steam engines and circular saw mills with references to customers across the country. The American House hotel announces its grand opening for August 1st (suggesting this is a reprint or advance notice). Jewelry dealer Bittrolpp Bros. tout watches and silver ware at "astonishing low figures," while Jacob Straus & Son fill column after column with hardware inventory: axes, saws, hinges, scythes, curry combs, and rat traps. The calendar for 1861 and advertising rate tables fill remaining space. Not a single headline about secession, battle reports, or military movements appears above the fold—only the quiet commercial machinery of a border-state city trying to conduct business as usual.
Why It Matters
September 1861 was four months into the Civil War. Fort Sumter had fallen in April; Bull Run (Manassas) had shocked the North with Confederate victory in July. Evansville, Indiana, sat on the Ohio River across from Kentucky—a slave state that remained in the Union but harbored Confederate sympathizers. This newspaper's refusal or inability to lead with war news speaks volumes about the dissonance of the era: while armies mobilized and young men died, merchants still needed to move inventory, hotels still needed guests, and machinery still needed to be sold. The paper's claim to print "Latest News from the Seat of War" appears to be marketing promise rather than delivery—the real estate of the front page belonged to commerce, not crisis.
Hidden Gems
- The American House hotel claims it will fill 'such a house as Evansville has for many years stood greatly in need of'—suggesting the city was growing rapidly enough to demand first-class accommodations, yet wasn't prosperous enough to have built them before.
- Philip Decker advertises 'Pure Catawba Wine, Of our own raising'—wine production in Indiana in 1861, suggesting a pre-Prohibition agricultural economy that would vanish within 50 years.
- James Steele's lumber yard offers 'Packing Boxes of all kinds made to order'—a business that would become obsolete with standardized shipping containers in the 20th century.
- The advertising rate table shows that a 3-month advertisement in the Daily costs $8.50, while a 2-month advertisement costs $15—the pricing structure makes no mathematical sense, suggesting either a typo in OCR or a desperate rate sheet designed to push longer commitments.
- Roeder & Becker's boot shop emphasizes that 'Only first-rate hands are employed in our business'—contemporary language for skilled labor that reflects a pre-mass-production manufacturing economy.
Fun Facts
- The paper boasts the 'LARGEST CIRCULATION of any paper in Southwestern Indiana'—yet it's a daily edition crammed into what appears to be a single broadsheet. By 2024, newspapers with similar regional dominance would print hundreds of thousands of copies; this was likely in the low thousands at most.
- De Forest, Armstrong & Co., a dry goods merchant with an address in New York, advertises 'Wamsutta Prints' and 'Amoskeag' fabrics directly to Evansville retailers—these would become iconic American textile brands. Amoskeag Mills in Manchester, New Hampshire, would become the world's largest textile manufacturer, employing 17,000 workers by 1915, before collapse in the 1920s.
- J. & E. Ivinson manufacture portable steam engines and saw mills. The industrialization of lumber milling was exploding in 1861—within a decade, the Great Lakes timber boom would fuel American expansion, and within 40 years, old-growth forests would be largely depleted.
- The paper's advertising emphasizes 'Prices to prompt Customers just as favorable as Eastern'—revealing anxiety about competing with larger Eastern markets and suggesting Evansville merchants were fighting to retain local customers who might order from distant suppliers.
- C. Armstrong's furniture factory claims to be 'one of the best arranged and conducted Factories west of Cincinnati'—Cincinnati was still America's manufacturing powerhouse in 1861, a role it would lose to Pittsburgh and Chicago within two decades.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free