“What Evansville Was Selling When the Civil War Started (Spoiler: Oysters & Military Buttons)”
What's on the Front Page
The Evansville Daily Journal of August 30, 1861, is almost entirely dominated by business cards and local advertisements—a remarkable window into how a border town operated during the opening months of the Civil War. The masthead proudly announces it has "the LARGEST CIRCULATION of any paper in Southwestern Indiana" and boasts of publishing "the Latest News from the Seat of War." Yet the actual war news is conspicuously absent from this front page. Instead, readers encounter densely packed advertisements for everything from livery stables and furniture factories to confectioners, boot makers, and a flooring mill. The Evansville Journal Company, under editors James H. McNeely, F. M. Thayer, and Jno. H. McNeely, has filled the page with practical notices—a lawyer advertising his services at Third Street, Richardson & Britton's livery stable promising to "always be ready to accommodate," and Philip Decker hawking his lard oil, soap, and "pure Catawba wine of our own raising." Most strikingly, there are "Soldiers' Trimmings" for sale: gilt braid, military buttons, union cockades, and flags made to order. This suggests Evansville's economy was already pivoting toward war production and military supply, even as the paper claims to bring the latest battlefield dispatches.
Why It Matters
August 1861 was a pivotal moment. Fort Sumter had fallen in April, and the First Battle of Bull Run had shocked the North just weeks earlier in July. Indiana, a border state with deep ties to both North and South, was mobilizing. Evansville, situated on the Ohio River facing Kentucky (a slave state still deciding its loyalty), sat at the crossroads of this conflict. The absence of war news on the front page—replaced instead by commercial life proceeding as normal—reflects a peculiar American moment: the early weeks when people hoped the conflict would be brief, and local business could continue. The "Soldiers' Trimmings" ads reveal that even as citizens tried to maintain normalcy, the machinery of war was already changing what they bought and sold. This page captures a community in transition, not yet fully accepting that nothing would be normal again.
Hidden Gems
- Philip Decker is selling "pure Catawba wine of our own raising" in Evansville, Indiana in 1861—suggesting a thriving local winemaking industry that has completely vanished from the region's identity today.
- A confectioner at No. 15 South First Street is the 'sole agent for Maltby's Unrivaled Baltimore Oysters'—meaning fresh oysters were being shipped and sold in landlocked Indiana during the Civil War, a luxury accessible to ordinary townspeople.
- The flooring mill advertisement notes it has 'new and complete Machinery of the latest style'—suggesting industrial investment was still happening in August 1861, even as the nation fractured.
- Multiple ads mention 'war times' explicitly (J. Smith's shirt business notes 'Prices to suit war times'), showing local merchants were already adjusting their language and pricing within weeks of the conflict starting.
- An 1861 calendar is printed on the front page, a standard feature, yet it represents a moment when readers still expected to use a paper calendar for the full year ahead—unaware how many subscribers would be in uniform by year's end.
Fun Facts
- The Evansville Journal claims the 'LARGEST CIRCULATION of any paper in Southwestern Indiana'—in an era when virtually every town had competing dailies. Today, Evansville has one newspaper; in 1861, it had multiple, each claiming superiority. This represents the peak of American newspaper density, never to be matched again.
- Schapker & Bussing are advertising 'Soldiers' Trimmings' including 'Staff Buttons,' 'Infantry Union Cockades,' and custom flags with 'silvered stars'—this was August 1861, meaning uniform production was already industrialized and commercialized at the local level within four months of Sumter.
- The paper lists advertising rates with astonishing specificity: a one-line ad costs 50 cents, while six months of daily advertising costs $8.50 to $29.75 depending on size. This hyperlocal advertising economy would eventually be destroyed by national media and, much later, the internet.
- De Forest, Armstrong & Co. are proudly announcing they've received 'Amoskeag' prints—a fabric from the famous Amoskeag Manufacturing Company mills in Manchester, New Hampshire. Those same mills would become a symbol of industrial decline 150 years later.
- The paper notes that ads 'amounting to $3 or less must invariably be paid in advance'—meaning in 1861, three dollars was significant enough that it needed cash guarantee policies, yet Philip Decker will extend '6 days paper negotiable in bank' for larger commercial transactions, showing how credit and currency worked in a war-time economy.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free