“"The South Will Soon Be With Us"—What the Confederacy Predicted (and Got Wrong) on This Day in 1861”
What's on the Front Page
On May 13, 1861—just weeks after Fort Sumter's bombardment ignited the Civil War—Cincinnati's Daily Press splashes across its front page the latest dispatch from Alexander Stephens, Vice President of the Confederate States. Fresh from a mission to Virginia, Stephens declares triumphantly that Virginia has already seceded and joined the Confederacy, while North Carolina will "be out of the Union before Saturday night." He predicts Tennessee, Kentucky, Missouri, and Arkansas will follow, and speaks with particular passion about Maryland's defiance of Lincoln, calling Baltimore's cause "the cause of us all, from the Atlantic to the Rio Grande." The speech crackles with sectional fervor and confidence in the South's inevitable expansion. Alongside this explosive political news, the paper carries the usual urban fare: advertisements for Dan Rice's traveling circus (featuring trained tigers, acrobats, and an "animated cavalcade"), a new soda water establishment at Central and Sixth, and business cards for plumbers, brass founders, and veterinarians. The contrast is jarring—Cincinnati bustles with commercial life while the nation tears itself apart.
Why It Matters
This newspaper captures America at a pivotal hinge moment. By mid-May 1861, the war was only three weeks old, yet the Confederacy was already consolidating support and recruiting border states. Stephens' confident predictions about Maryland, Kentucky, and Missouri reflected the genuine possibility that the conflict could spread far beyond the Deep South, potentially shifting the entire geographic and political calculus of the war. Cincinnati, as a major Ohio river city, occupied a precarious position—close enough to Confederate territory to feel threatened, yet firmly in Union territory. For Cincinnatians reading this over their morning coffee, Stephens' words would have felt simultaneously distant and dangerously near. The juxtaposition of wartime anxiety with everyday commercial life shows how American society was learning to exist in a state of profound rupture.
Hidden Gems
- A farmer in Montgomery County, Pennsylvania offers to donate "all the grain he has on hand and one hundred head of cattle" to feed Pennsylvania's troops—an early glimpse of how the Civil War mobilized civilian resources and self-sacrifice at the grassroots level.
- The "Varieties" section includes a darkly comic item: 'To what decision must the South loon come? Dread Scott'—a cutting reference to the 1857 Supreme Court decision that denied citizenship to African Americans, which many blamed for accelerating secession.
- Dan Rice's circus advertised "FOUR DAYS' FESTIVAL IN THE QUEEN CITY" opening that very evening (May 13) with performances of *The Flying Dutchman* and exotic animal acts—entertainment proceeding as normal even as the nation convulses.
- A subscription to the Cincinnati Daily Press cost just 3 cents per copy or $7 per year—meaning a working-class reader could stay informed about the war for roughly $140 in today's money annually.
- The paper advertises Sutler's Premium Blacking and Sherrick's Baltimore Oyster Ketchup—products from the very cities caught in the war's crossfire, showing how trade networks were still functioning across enemy lines even as armies mobilized.
Fun Facts
- Alexander Stephens, the Confederate VP whose victory lap dominates this front page, would later become a fierce critic of Jefferson Davis's war conduct and serve in Congress after the war—one of the few Confederate leaders who lived to reshape Reconstruction politics.
- The paper mentions that Queen Victoria has sunk into 'settled melancholy' since her mother's death—yet Britain's mood toward the American Civil War was actually quite complex. Despite Cincinnati's worries, British intervention never materialized, partly due to cotton alternatives discovered in India and Egypt.
- Dan Rice's circus, prominently advertised here, was one of 19th-century America's most famous entertainment empires. Rice would later inspire the character of Buffalo Bill and represented the kind of mass entertainment that unified Americans even as their nation split apart.
- The reference to 'armed neutrality' debates involving Kentucky Senator John Crittenden reflects that border states weren't inevitably Confederate—Crittenden himself remained a Union supporter despite his slaveholding background, a position that would eventually cost him the support of his own family.
- This issue reveals Cincinnati's dual identity: a thriving commercial hub advertising luxury goods (imported soaps, oyster ketchup, trained animal acts) while simultaneously serving as a recruitment and supply hub for the Union Army—the city would become crucial to Northern logistics throughout the war.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free