“Three Weeks Before Fort Sumter: Nashville Pretends Everything Is Normal (It Isn't)”
What's on the Front Page
On March 17, 1861, the Nashville Union and American's front page bristles with official proclamations from Tennessee Governor Isham G. Harris commanding sheriffs across five counties to hold judicial elections and fill vacant militia positions. The lead proclamations—issued in February but published here—carry an air of administrative routine that masks the extraordinary moment: Tennessee stands at the precipice of secession, and these elections are essentially the machinery of a state preparing for civil war. Alongside the formal notices, Nashville's merchant class dominates the page with bold advertisements: Metcalf Brothers hawks their spring dry goods, James Low & Co. in Louisville peddles bolts of cotton sheeting and printed cloth, and Clark & Fuller's Arbrosal Oil claims to cure everything from headaches to horse founder. Interspersed are classified notices for flour, apples, and boots—the ordinary commerce of a Southern city still pretending normalcy.
Why It Matters
March 1861 is the hinge moment of American history. Fort Sumter would fall to Confederate guns just three weeks after this paper rolled off the press. Tennessee, a border state with deep economic ties to the Upper South and the North, was still publicly debating secession—though Governor Harris, a secessionist, was clearly preparing the state machinery for what was coming. These election proclamations and the continued advertising reveal a society in denial, or at least compartmentalization: merchants were still importing goods, courts were still functioning, life appeared to go on even as the political ground shifted beneath their feet. By June, Tennessee would secede and join the Confederacy. Nashville itself would fall to Union forces within a year.
Hidden Gems
- James W. Hamilton, a boot and shoe maker, advertises that he operates his own tannery and promises 'particularly all Heavy Boots, Shoes and Negro Brogans' — an explicit and chilling reminder that enslaved people were factored into the commercial calculations of even small Nashville manufacturers, sold the cheapest footwear.
- S. W. H. Ward's New York shirt company promises 'Self Measurement for Shirts' with printed directions sent free, allowing customers to measure themselves and mail prepaid shirts back from Broadway—a remarkably sophisticated mail-order system operating three months before the war shut down such North-South commerce.
- A mysterious classified notice from H. E. (initials only) announces his relocation to New Orleans 'on account of the health of my family' and mentions forwarding enslaved people ('negroes') to New Orleans if they don't sell in Nashville—revealing the internal slave trade's logistics at the exact moment secession was being decided.
- The Stretch Forbes drugstore advertises 'Ambrotype, Melainotype, Photographic and Daguerreotype Goods'—multiple competing photography technologies still coexisting in 1861, suggesting how rapidly technology was evolving even as the nation fractured.
- Doctor Wright's 'Rejuvenating Elixir' for treating 'General Debility' and 'Disorganisation of the Organs of Generation' sells for fifty cents per bottle and is endorsed by the entire Medical Faculty—patent medicines with wildly exaggerated claims dominated newspapers and preyed on desperate patients for decades.
Fun Facts
- Governor Isham G. Harris, whose proclamations dominate the front page, became Tennessee's Confederate governor after secession. He was so zealously pro-secession that even Jefferson Davis found him troublesome; after the war, Harris went into exile in Mexico and Canada rather than submit to Reconstruction, eventually returning to serve in Congress and the U.S. Senate—a remarkable arc of defiance.
- The Clark & Fuller Arbrosal Oil advertisement claims to cure everything from rheumatism to 'Dog Bites' and 'Rat Bites,' with testimonials from physicians. This was the golden age of patent medicines—before the FDA existed (founded 1906), anyone could sell anything as a cure. The oil was actually made in Nashville and marketed regionally, one of hundreds of such nostrums that constituted medical treatment for ordinary Americans.
- Stretch Forbes' drugstore was a one-stop shop for items that would horrify modern sensibilities: pure alcohol, 'Swedish Leeches' (still used medically), mercury compounds (which caused more harm than good), and extensive surgical and dental instruments. The store also sold photography supplies and trusses—reflecting how druggists functioned as the closest thing to a modern pharmacy-meets-medical-supply hybrid.
- The Nashville and Chattanooga Railroad mentioned in a classified ad was crucial infrastructure that Union and Confederate forces would fight over repeatedly during the war. Control of Tennessee's railroad network became central to the military strategy of both sides; this March 1861 notice about freight trains seems almost poignant in retrospect.
- The continued import of goods from Louisville and New York—visible in every advertisement—would become nearly impossible within months. By summer 1861, the South was effectively blockaded, and merchants like those advertising here would pivot to blockade-running, using Confederate ships to smuggle goods past the Union Navy.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free