“Two Presidents, Two Trains, One Collision Course—Read Davis's Full Inaugural Address as Lincoln Headed to Power”
What's on the Front Page
On February 22, 1861—the day Abraham Lincoln traveled toward his inauguration—this Saint Paul newspaper leads with Jefferson Davis's arrival in Montgomery, Alabama, as the newly sworn President of the Confederate States. Davis gave his inaugural address on February 18, declaring that the South's secession was "not a choice" but "a necessity," and that the Confederate states would defend their "positions among the nations of the earth" by "the final arbitrament of the sword" if required. The paper prints Davis's full speech, in which he justifies separation from the Union as an exercise of the right proclaimed in the Declaration of Independence—that governments derive power from the consent of the governed. Meanwhile, a separate dispatch reports Lincoln's movements: his train departed Cleveland on February 16, with the Presidential party traveling through Erie and Dunkirk, where Lincoln grasped the American flag and announced his intentions to the assembled crowds. The juxtaposition is haunting: two men on parallel journeys toward collision, one defending slavery and states' rights, the other bound for the White House to preserve the Union.
Why It Matters
This is the front page from the cusp of America's civil war. Just days before Lincoln's inauguration on March 4, the Confederacy had formed and Davis had taken the oath. The South had already seceded—South Carolina in December 1860, followed by six more states by February. Davis's speech is a masterpiece of legal justification for secession, invoking the Declaration of Independence itself to argue that southern states had every right to withdraw. Yet his warning about being prepared to "maintain by the final arbitrament of the sword" was ominously prescient. Lincoln's parallel journey through the North—stopping to address crowds at every depot—represented a competing vision of Union and popular sovereignty. Within weeks, these two men's visions would collide at Fort Sumter, and four years of bloodshed would follow. This newspaper page captures the moment when rhetoric still seemed to matter more than bullets.
Hidden Gems
- Davis made 25 speeches on his journey from Mississippi to Montgomery—essentially a triumphal tour where he repeated his defiant message at every depot to crowds of 'ladies and gentlemen and military.'
- In his inaugural address, Davis describes the South's economy bluntly: 'An agricultural people, whose chief interest is the export of a commodity required in every manufacturing country'—a euphemism for cotton, and implicitly for slavery, never mentioned by name.
- Lincoln appears on the same front page but in a fragment, his story cut off mid-sentence: 'grasping the staff of the American flag under the folds of which he stood, announced his intention'—we never learn what he announced, a tantalizing incompleteness.
- The paper opens with poetry about keeping Lent ("To fast from strife, / From old debate, / And hate")—a bitter irony given the page's central content about irreconcilable conflict.
- Davis's description of his own temperament is revealing: 'the last man who would be selected as a "fire eater"'—insisting he was a reluctant, measured leader forced into conflict by circumstance, not ideology.
Fun Facts
- Jefferson Davis, born in Kentucky in 1806, was once captured during the Black Hawk War and supposedly formed a 'romantic attachment' and 'bond of amity' with the famous chief Black Hawk—a relationship that continued 'not until his death.' This anecdote, printed here, was propaganda designed to humanize Davis, but it's striking that even the Confederacy felt compelled to depict its president as capable of respecting a Native American warrior.
- Davis served as Secretary of War under President Pierce from 1853-1857—the very cabinet position responsible for military preparedness that would prove crucial in the coming war. His experience with Zachary Taylor in frontier conflicts and his commission as a colonel in the Mexican War made him a credible military figure, which boosted his selection as Confederate president.
- Davis's inaugural speech invokes the Declaration of Independence 76 times implicitly—arguing that the Confederacy was simply exercising rights the Founders themselves had claimed. He frames secession not as rebellion but as rightful reversion of power to the states, a legal argument that would echo through four years of war.
- Lincoln's journey to his inauguration included stops in Erie, Dunkirk, Cleveland, and other northern cities—each one a chance to rally support and show his presence to the northern public. His iconic photograph grasping the flag was a deliberate symbolic act, performed publicly and reported in newspapers like this one.
- This paper is published in Saint Paul, Minnesota Territory—a state that wouldn't formally join the Union until 1858, just three years before this edition. It was not yet fully settled, yet its residents were closely following the secession crisis unfolding in the distant South.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free