“Tears in the Senate: Jefferson Davis Says Goodbye Before the War (Feb. 1, 1861)”
What's on the Front Page
The front page opens with a soaring patriotic poem by George D. Prentice titled "The New Year and the Union," invoking divine imagery to rally Americans against what he calls "traitor hearts" threatening the nation's bonds. But the real news is below: the formal, tear-stained withdrawal of U.S. Senators from Alabama, Florida, and Mississippi from Congress on January 21st. The piece captures what the paper calls "the most solemn and impressive scene which has occurred at the capitol since the pendency of the present troubles." Senator Jefferson Davis—soon to be president of the Confederacy—gave the most memorable farewell, carefully distinguishing between nullification (a state resisting federal law while remaining in the Union) and secession (a state's sovereign right to leave). Davis declared Mississippi had "justifiable cause" and that he would have followed her action regardless of his personal beliefs. His words reportedly moved hardened senators to tears. The withdrawal marks a decisive moment: these men are walking out of the Senate itself, not returning.
Why It Matters
This newspaper was published just one month before Fort Sumter's bombardment would ignite the Civil War. By early February 1861, seven states had already seceded, but the nation still clung to hope that cooler heads might prevail. Davis's dignified farewell—emphasizing that secession was a legal constitutional right, not treachery—represented the South's intellectual defense of its position at this final moment before guns spoke. The poem and the reporting show how Americans on both sides genuinely believed they were fighting for the nation's soul: Northerners saw secession as dissolution and betrayal; Southerners saw it as the exercise of state sovereignty their founders had established. This was the last time these men would share the chamber as colleagues. Within weeks, they would be enemies.
Hidden Gems
- The paper includes a lengthy literary essay titled 'Prairie Papers' by someone named Ethel, comparing the novel 'Rutledge' (an 'actual transcript of New York society') to 'Jane Eyre'—revealing that serious book criticism and literary debate occupied substantial front-page real estate even as the nation tore itself apart.
- A small notice mentions Rev. Dr. Cahill boasting to Napoleon: 'I am read every week by millions of men, and I am read all over the civilized world'—a journalist's audacious self-promotion claiming global reach in 1861.
- Senator Davis's speech carefully invokes John C. Calhoun (who 'now reposes with his fathers') and Andrew Jackson, arguing that Jackson's famous 'nullification crisis' doctrine of coercion cannot apply to a state that has already left the Union—a sophisticated constitutional argument made as a farewell.
- The paper is identified as 'Saint Paul, Friday, February 1, 1861'—published in Minnesota Territory, a Free State, giving Northern perspective on Southern secession at this pivotal moment.
- Davis argues that Mississippi, by seceding, 'divests herself of every benefit...severs all the ties of affection...and thus claiming to be exempt from any power to execute the laws of the United States'—essentially the legal theory that would justify Confederate independence in Southern eyes.
Fun Facts
- Jefferson Davis, delivering this farewell address, would be elected President of the Confederate States exactly three weeks later on February 22, 1861. This Senate speech is him saying goodbye to his former colleagues before becoming a wartime leader.
- The Prentice poem's invocation of 'the harp of Liberty' and condemnation of 'traitor hearts' was typical of how Northern newspapers weaponized patriotic language in early 1861—each side claiming sole ownership of the Revolution's legacy.
- Senator Davis's careful distinction between nullification and secession reflected sophisticated constitutional theory that was genuinely disputed in 1861—even Lincoln would have to define and refine these terms once the war began, showing how novel and contested the legal ground was.
- This Minnesota territorial newspaper reprinting a Senate scene from Washington and a literary essay about English novels shows how information moved rapidly through telegraph and mail networks—the same speed that would soon carry orders for soldiers to Fort Sumter.
- The 'thrilling scene' of senators withdrawing occurred on January 21st but wasn't published in Minnesota until February 1st—a 10-day news lag that felt immediate for 1861 readers but underscores how fast events were actually moving toward conflict.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free